More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by carriekitty carriekitty

What's next?

The Meeting

The air in our living room on Thursday night was thick with a different kind of tension. It wasn't the quiet domesticity of a normal evening; it was a charged, waiting silence. The lights were low, the room clean but not fussy. We'd pushed the coffee table against the wall. Laura and I sat side-by-side on the larger sofa, both wearing simple, matching silk robes—mine black, hers a deep crimson—tied loosely at the waist. We’d agreed on the uniform. We wanted to look like a set.

My phone buzzed on the arm of the sofa.

*Five minutes away.*

I showed Laura the screen. She took a slow, deliberate breath, her knuckles whitening where she gripped her knee. “Showtime,” she whispered, a nervous, excited smile touching her lips. Exactly five minutes later, a soft, firm knock sounded at the front door. Not tentative. Assured. I stood up, my robe whispering against my skin. I walked to the door, feeling Laura’s eyes on my back. I opened it. Alan stood on the step. He looked different outside the context of a luxury hotel suite. He was dressed in dark jeans and a well-fitting charcoal sweater. Handsome in an unassuming way. But his eyes… they held the same focused intensity I recalled. They swept over me in the doorway, taking in the robe, then moved past me into the dim hall, searching for the second shape.

“Carrie,” he said, his voice a pleasant baritone. No false charm. Just acknowledgement.

“Alan. Come in.”

He stepped inside, bringing with him the scent of cold night air and a faint, clean cologne. I closed the door behind him, the click sounding final. He turned as I led him into the living room, and there was Laura, still seated, a vision of composed anticipation in red silk. His gaze locked onto her. A slow, genuine smile spread across his face. It wasn't leering. It was appreciative, almost… grateful. “You must be the friend,” he said.

Laura stood up smoothly, letting her robe fall open just enough to reveal a flash of pale thigh and the outline of her tits. “I am. Laura. I’ve heard…good things.”

“I hope to live up to them,” Alan replied, his eyes flicking between us now, the reality of *two* visibly settling over him, heating his expression. “This is… quite the invitation.”

“We aim to please,” I said, moving to stand beside Laura. We were a united front. “Can I get you a drink? Scotch?”

“Please. Neat.”

I poured three fingers of Carl’s good Scotch into a tumbler and handed it to him. Our fingers brushed. His were warm. He took a sip, his eyes never leaving us, cataloguing every detail.

“So,” Laura said, breaking the quiet. She took a step towards him, her confidence returning in a wave. “Carrie tells me you have a particular fantasy.”

Alan’s gaze darkened. He nodded once, taking another sip. “I do. One I’ve had for a long time.” He set the glass down on the mantelpiece with a soft *clink*. “And you two are going to fulfill it.”

“We are,” I confirmed, untying the belt of my robe. I let it slide off my shoulders and pool at my feet. I stood before him in just black lace lingerie—bra, stockings clipped to a suspender belt. “We’re yours for the evening. To use as you see fit.”

A low sound escaped him. Laura mirrored me, shedding her crimson robe to her naked body. The contrast was deliberate, striking. Two presents, unwrapped. Alan walked towards us, stopping an arm’s length away. He reached out, not to grope, but to touch. His fingertips the edges of my tits, then did the same to Laura’s. “Beautiful,” he murmured, more to himself than to us. “Where would you like me to start?”

“Wherever you want,” Laura said, her voice a husky challenge. “It’s your fantasy. We’re just the scenery.”

That seemed to decide him. The polite veneer melted away, replaced by a hungry focus. “On your knees,” he said, his voice dropping an octave. “Both of you. In front of me.”

We sank down together onto the plush rug, kneeling side-by-side, looking up at him. He undressed. His cock already fully, impressively erect. It was thick, veined, and as I remembered, crowned with a broad, flushed head.

“You first, Carrie,” he instructed. “Since we’re acquainted. Get me wet for your friend.”

I leaned forward, opening my mouth. I took him in, sucking slowly, deeply, coating his length with my saliva. I tasted clean skin and latent salt. I worked him with my tongue, remembering the feel of him, hearing his breath hitch above me. After a minute, he gently pulled my head back by my hair.

“Now you, Laura. See how she’s made it nice and slick for you.”

Laura didn't need telling twice. She moved in, her technique different from mine—more playful, using the flat of her tongue before swallowing him down to the root with a practiced ease that made him groan. We took turns like that for a while, a synchronized, wet worship, our heads sometimes brushing, our moans mingling. He guided us, a hand on each of our heads, setting a rhythm.

“ok” he finally rasped. “Sit on the couch and lie back for me, you too”

We obeyed, moving as one. Lay on the large sofa, our faces turned to watch each other over our shoulders. The air felt cool on my exposed skin

“Who’s first for my cock?” he asked, his voice thick.

“Me,” Laura said instantly, her eyes meeting mine, blazing with excitement.

I felt the sofa cushion shift as he positioned himself behind her. I watched as he used his fingers to tease her through the scarlet lace, pulled off her panties, then guided himself to her entrance, and with one powerful thrust, buried himself in her pussy.

*Uhhhnnn!* Laura’s cry was one of pure, shocked pleasure. Her back arched, her fingers clawing at the sofa fabric. He fucked her like that, hard and deep, each drive pushing her body forward, the slap of skin on lace a frantic beat. I could see her face, eyes squeezed shut, mouth open in a silent scream of ecstasy. After a dozen brutal strokes, he pulled out, glistening wet.

“Your turn, Carrie,” he breathed.

He moved in front of me and plunged into my cunt, filling me in one relentless motion. It was a different stretch than Carl’s, a different angle. I cried out, my own sounds joining Laura’s heavy panting. He fucked me with the same purposeful intensity, his hands gripping my hips hard enough to bruise, his grunts filling the room. Just as I was teetering on the edge, he withdrew again, leaving me empty and throbbing.

“Now,” he growled, his breathing ragged. “The other hole. Laura first.”

He produced a small bottle of lube from his pocket. I heard the squirt, the slick sounds as he prepared her. Laura gasped as he pressed a thick finger into her tight rear entrance, working her open. mmmmm… yes…”

When he was satisfied, he positioned himself again. This time, the push was slower, more insistent. Laura whimpered, a high, **** sound, as he breached her ass, sinking in inch by torturous inch until he was fully seated. He began to move, a shallower, more grinding rhythm that had her trembling, her knuckles white.

“Fuck… so tight…” he groaned, fucking her ass with deep, possessive strokes before pulling out once more, his cock slick with lube.

He moved to me. The cold lube dripped onto my backside. His fingers probed, stretching, preparing. The intrusion was sharp, unfamiliar. Then the blunt pressure of his cockhead. “Mmmm, another tight hole,” he said, and I **** my muscles to unclench. He pushed, and a burning, full sensation bloomed as he entered my ass. It was overwhelming, a violation that tipped straight into blinding pleasure. He fucked my arse with the same single-minded determination, each thrust a lightning bolt of painful, perfect sensation.

He switched back and forth between us like this—pussy, then ass, then pussy again—until we were both incoherent, sweat-slicked and moaning, our bodies used and utterly open to him. The fantasy wasn't just about having two women; it was about *using* two women, completely, interchangeably.

Finally, he pulled out of Laura’s pussy for the last time. He was breathing like a bull, his cock rock-hard and angry red.

“On your knees,” he ordered, his voice guttural.

We scrambled off the sofa, collapsing onto the rug, kneeling side-by-side, our bodies spent and glistening. We looked up at him as he stood over us, his fist pumping his bare, dripping cock.

“This is what I wanted,” he panted, his eyes wild, fixed on the twin vision of our faces below him. “To see two beautiful faces… waiting for it… *ah, fuck!*”

His orgasm wasn't silent. It began with a deep, shuddering groan. Then the first rope of cum shot out, thick and pearlescent, arcing through the air to splatter across my cheek and lips. The next pulse hit Laura’s forehead, painting a white stripe through her fringe. He moved his hips, aiming, painting us. A hot splash landed on my chin and neck. Another coated Laura’s nose and open mouth. It was warm, surprisingly copious, and the smell—musky and potent—filled my nostrils.

He kept coming, the pulses gradually diminishing but no less intense, until our faces were glazed with it, marked by him. The final drops fell onto my tongue as I gasped for air. He stood there for a moment, swaying slightly, looking down at his handiwork—two women kneeling side-by-side, faces gloriously defiled, bodies used in every way he’d desired. A look of profound, almost stunned satisfaction crossed his face.

Please log in to view the image

“God, that was amazing” he said simply, the words heartfelt.

In the sudden, absolute quiet, Laura turned her head towards me, her eyes wide in her cum-painted face. A slow, dazed, utterly blissful smile spread across her sticky lips.

“Holy shit,” she breathed. “That’s a lot of spunk, Alan”

“Told you he cums a lot”, I said

Laura turned her head towards me, her movements slow, sticky. Our eyes met through the streaks. A silent understanding passed between us. We pushed ourselves up to sitting positions, our bodies groaning in protest. We were a mess—his cum was drying on our cheeks, our eyelids, our lips. It was in our hair, on our necks. Wordlessly, I reached for Laura. My thumb, gentle, brushed a thick dollop from her cheekbone. She flinched at first, then leaned into the touch, her eyes closing. I brought my thumb to my own mouth and licked it clean, the taste sharp and musky on my tongue. Her eyes flew open, watching me, darkening with a fresh, quiet heat. It was her turn. She shifted closer on the rug, her knees brushing mine. She cupped my face, her fingers tender against my sticky skin. Her thumb swiped through the cooling mess on my jawline. She held it up, showed it to me—a pearlescent string connecting her thumb to my skin—then slowly, deliberately, put her thumb in her mouth and sucked it clean. A soft moan escaped her, part satisfaction, part renewed arousal.

We continued like that, in a slow, intimate ritual. I licked a stripe from her forehead down to the bridge of her nose. She caught a drip from the corner of my mouth with her tongue. We cleaned each other’s eyelids with soft, fluttering kisses. We used our fingers to gather what had dripped into the hollows of our collarbones, feeding it to each other. There was no hurry. It was methodical, almost reverent. A reclaiming of our own bodies through the shared medium of his gift. All the while, Alan watched from his chair. He sipped his scotch, his expression one of deep, captivated fascination. He didn't speak. He didn't move to join. He was an audience of one, witnessing the aftermath of his own storm. His cock, spent and softening, lay against his thigh, but his gaze was intensely focused. This was part of the fantasy, too—not just the taking, but the possession, and now, the intimate aftermath he’d provoked.

The quiet in the room was a living thing, thick and warm as honey. The only sounds were the rhythm of our breathing. Alan watched us from his throne-like chair, a faint, contented smile on his lips. Laura and I leaned against the sofa, our bodies humming with a deep, pleasant exhaustion, the water in our glasses almost gone.

I was tracing idle patterns on the rug with a fingertip when I felt Laura shift beside me. Not a tired shift, but a deliberate one. I glanced at her. Her eyes, which had been half-lidded and sleepy, were now fixed on Alan with a fresh, speculative intensity. The look was familiar—it was the same one she’d given me before we’d texted him. A look that said *I’m not finished*. Laura reached out. Her hand, gentle but sure, closed around his soft cock where it lay against his thigh. She began to stroke him, slowly, coaxingly, her thumb swirling over the sensitive head. She leaned in, her breath ghosting over his skin, and pressed a soft, open-mouthed kiss to the tip. Then another, lower, on his shaft. Her tongue darted out, a pink flash in the dim light, licking a long, slow stripe from root to crown.

A low groan rumbled in Alan’s chest. His hands came to rest on the arms of the chair, his knuckles whitening slightly. His eyes slid shut for a second as Laura took him fully into her mouth, her head beginning to bob with a slow, sensual rhythm.

That was my cue. The fatigue melted away, replaced by a surge of possessive heat. *He is ours to use, too.* I mirrored Laura. While she focused on sucking him to full hardness, I leaned in and began to lavish attention on his balls. I took the heavy sac into my mouth, suckling gently, rolling the orbs with my tongue, tasting the salt of his earlier sweat. My other hand joined Laura’s on his shaft, our fingers tangling as we worked him together. Within minutes, he was fully erect again, thick and iron-hard in our combined grasp. Laura released him with a wet *pop* and looked across his body at me. Her eyes were blazing. “My turn,” she whispered, her voice husky.

She stood up, never breaking eye contact with me. She turned and, with a graceful movement, straddled Alan’s lap, facing away from him, towards me. She was giving me the view. Reaching behind herself, she guided the broad head of his cock, slick from her mouth, to the tight, forbidden entrance between her cheeks.

Alan’s hands came up to grip her hips, his breath catching. “mmmmm..” he murmured, but his voice was thick with anticipation.

Laura didn't rush. She lowered herself slowly, an inch at a time, her back arching beautifully, her head falling back against his shoulder. A sharp, breathy gasp escaped her as the thick crown breached slid into her ass. I watched, mesmerized, from my position on the floor. I had a perfect, unobstructed view of the junction of their bodies—the way her muscles fluttered and clenched, the slow, inexorable stretch as she impaled herself on him, taking him deeper into her ass.

*Uhhh… nngh…* The sounds she made were pure, strained pleasure. Alan’s jaw was tight, When she was fully seated, she stilled for a moment, panting, letting her body adjust to the incredible fullness. Then, she began to move. Not bouncing, but grinding. A slow, circular rotation of her hips, a deep, internal massage. She leaned back fully against his chest, her hands coming up to tangle in his hair, her face turned to press against his neck. From my vantage point, I could see everything: the flex of her buttocks with each tiny movement, the way his shaft glistened, buried to the hilt, the absolute vulnerability and trust of the act.

“Fuck, Laura…” Alan groaned, his hands sliding from her hips to splay possessively over her stomach, holding her tight against him.

Laura moaned, her eyes finding mine. They were glazed, unfocused with pleasure. “Fuck that feels good…”

I was transfixed by the intimacy of it was even more potent than the frantic fucking from before. This was slow, claiming, deeply connected. I moved forward on my knees until I was right there, my face inches from where they were joined. I could smell the scent of them, see the minute tremors running through Laura’s thighs. I reached out and placed a hand on her knee, a grounding touch.

“That’s deep,” I whispered, my own arousal coiling tight in my belly.

Laura responded by grinding harder, a little faster, drawing a ragged moan from Alan. “Feels… brillaint…” she panted. “So full… ”

The room filled with the soft, wet sounds of her movement, his ragged breaths, her broken whimpers. It was a tableau of profound submission and control, with me as the captivated audience, invited into the very centre of their union. The night, it seemed, was still yielding new, deeper layers of his fantasy, and we were all too eager to explore every one. The slow, sensual grind had built into a steady, deep rhythm. Laura’s back was arched like a bow, her body a taut line of pleasure against Alan’s chest. Her whimpers had become continuous, a soft, **** music in the firelit room. Alan’s hands were vice-like on her hips now, his own breathing a harsh, controlled rasp in her ear. He was no longer letting her set the pace; he was meeting each downward grind with an upward thrust of his own, driving himself even deeper into the hot, clutching tightness of her ass.

“That’s it,” he growled, his voice guttural and raw. “Take it. Take all of it.”

I knelt before them, my own hand still working between my legs, my eyes glued to the point where their bodies joined. I could see the strain in the thick vein that ran along the underside of his cock, pulsing visibly with each beat of his heart. It was throbbing, engorged, a telltale sign of what was coming.

Laura must have felt the change too. Her movements became more frantic, less controlled. He let out a sound that was half-groan, half-roar. His whole body tensed, locking behind her. His thrusts became short, sharp, and impossibly deep, burying himself to the root with each one. His hands clamped down on her hips, holding her immobile. Then it happened. The thick vein beneath his shaft convulsed. A powerful, visible pulse travelled its length. And from the tip of his cock, buried deep inside Laura, the first flood was released. I couldn't see it exit, but I could see its effect. Laura’s eyes flew wide open, a shocked, strangled cry tearing from her throat as the first hot jet filled her depths. Her body seized, a violent tremor wracking her from head to toe.

*Pulse.* The vein throbbed again, a second, massive release. Laura’s head fell back against his shoulder, her mouth agape in a silent scream of overwhelmed ecstasy. Her internal muscles were milking him, triggering another.

*Pulse.* A third. A low, continuous moan was now pouring from her, her body going limp in his grasp, held up only by his hands on her hips and the incredible fullness inside her.

Alan was grunting with each expulsion, a primal, satisfying sound. *“Uhn! Uhn! Fuck!*” His hips jerked involuntarily with each spurt, pumping his seed as deep into her bowels as it could possibly go. Finally, the pulses subsided. The violent tension drained from his body, leaving him slumped back in the chair, breathing in great, heaving gasps. Laura was a boneless, trembling weight in his lap, utterly spent, filled beyond comprehension. Slowly, carefully, Alan lifted her off him. As his slick, glistening cock pulled free from her well-used hole, a thick, pearlescent river of his spend followed, oozing out in a slow, viscous cascade down her inner thigh and onto his own stomach and softening shaft. There was so much of it. It pooled in his navel, coated his pubic hair.

Please log in to view the imagePlease log in to view the image

The sight was obscenely beautiful. Laura, collapsed half on the floor, half against the chair, her backside glistening. Alan, sprawled in the chair, painted with the evidence of his own spectacular release. For a moment, we all just breathed. Then, moving as if in a dream, I crawled forward. My eyes were fixed on Alan’s cock, which lay against his belly, still dribbling the last of his immense load. I leaned in, my mouth hovering inches from him. I didn't look at his face; I looked at the mess. Then I extended my tongue and gave one long, slow, cleansing lick from the base of his shaft all the way to the tip, collecting a mouthful of warm, salty cream. I swallowed, the flavour exploding on my tongue. Then I turned my attention to the pool in his navel. I dipped my head and lapped it clean, my tongue swirling in the shallow dip of his stomach.

Laura shuffled forward on her knees, her movements clumsy with exhaustion. When she reached Alan’s side, she didn't go for his skin. Instead, she placed a hand on his thigh to steady herself, leaned in, and took the head of his still-dripping cock into her mouth. She sucked gently, tenderly, cleaning him with soft pulls of her lips and sweeps of her tongue, swallowing every drop she could coax from him. We worked in a silent, efficient tandem. I licked the streaks from his lower abdomen. She nursed the last remnants from his shaft and balls. When he was clean, we turned our attention to each other. Laura had his spunk trickling from her used entrance. I moved behind her, my hands spreading her cheeks, and I leaned in to lick her clean there too, my tongue delving gently to retrieve what was left inside. She gasped, her body jerking at the sensitive intrusion, but she pushed back against my face, urging me on. When we were done, we collapsed together in a heap on the rug at Alan’s feet, two women thoroughly used, thoroughly cleaned, and utterly complete. We looked up at him.

Alan looked down at us, his expression one of profound, satiated awe. He looked from Laura’s blissfully wrecked face to mine, then at his own body, now spotless. He let out a long, slow breath that seemed to come from the very center of him.

He didn't move to leave. He simply closed his eyes, a king resting amidst the perfect, peaceful ruin of his conquered kingdom, with his two loyal subjects curled at his feet. The fire crackled, casting dancing shadows over our tangled, sated forms. The fantasy had not just been fulfilled; it had been consumed, absorbed, and was now settling into our bones as a permanent, glorious memory. The deep, contented silence stretched on, punctuated only by the settling logs in the fire. Alan’s breathing had evened out into the slow rhythm of near-sleep in his chair. Laura and I lay tangled on the rug, a single, exhausted organism. The digital clock on the mantelpiece glowed a soft blue: 11.30 PM

It was the faint vibration of a phone, muffled in the pocket of his discarded jeans, that finally broke the spell. A single, insistent buzz. Alan’s eyes fluttered open. He didn't startle; he simply surfaced from his sated stupor with a slow awareness. He reached down, fished the phone from his pocket, and glanced at the screen. A slight frown, then a resigned nod.

“It’s time I left I think” he said, his voice gravelly with disuse. He didn't sound disappointed, just factual. The real world was reasserting its claim.

He moved with a surprising economy of effort, standing up from the chair. Laura and I untangled ourselves and sat up, watching him dress. There was no awkwardness, no rush. He pulled on his boxers, his jeans, zipped up. He shrugged into his sweater. Each movement was calm, deliberate. Finally, he picked up his coat from the peg and his small leather washbag from the table. He stood before us, fully dressed, looking once more like the ordinary, handsome man who had knocked on the door hours ago. But his eyes held the ghost of everything that had happened.

He looked from Laura to me, his expression softening into something genuine and deeply appreciative. “Thank you,” he said, the words simple but imbued with immense weight. “Both of you. That was… more than I ever imagined.” His gaze lingered on us, on our naked, marked-up bodies, our faces clean but glowing with the aftermath. “You’re incredible.”

He didn't call us sluts. He didn't need to. The gratitude in his eyes, the reverence in his tone, said it all. We had been his fantasy, and we had exceeded it.

“Any time, Alan,” Laura said, her voice a sleepy purr. She gave him a small, wicked smile. He returned the smile, a flash of the hungry man from earlier. Then he turned and let himself out. The door clicked shut, softer this time, a full stop on the night’s narrative.

For a long moment, we just listened to the emptiness of the house. Then Laura let out a long, shuddering sigh and flopped onto her back on the rug, staring at the ceiling. “Holy. Fucking. Hell.”

I lay down beside her, our shoulders touching. “Yeah.”

“I mean…” she began, then burst out laughing, a tired, giddy sound. “The *volume*, Carrie. The actual volume. When he came in my ass… I felt it hit something inside me I didn't know I had. It was like a warm water balloon bursting. I swear to god.”

I turned my head to look at her. “I saw it. I saw the vein on his cock jumping with each shot. It was like watching a hose pulse.”

“A very productive hose,” she murmured, closing her eyes. A dreamy smile played on her lips. “And then the aftermath. When you were licking it off him… and out of me…” She shivered. “I’ve never tasted so much of a man in my life. And I’ve tasted a few.”

“We drank him dry,” I said, a note of awe in my own voice. “Twice. And there was still enough to paint us the first time and fill you up like a cream puff the second.”

Laura giggled at the analogy. “A cream puff. That’s what I am. A well-filled, thoroughly glazed cream puff.”

We lay there in the dying firelight, not needing to say anything else. The evidence was cooling in our bellies, the memory etched into our muscles. The quiet chat wasn't about planning the next adventure; it was about savoring the sheer, outrageous scale of the one we’d just completed. We were two sluts, yes. But in that moment, covered in the phantom feeling of his incredible load, we felt like queens. We got up and freshened ourselves up, Laura dressed and kissed me, and went home with an ass full of cum. I went upstairs and got in bed, content and fulfilled.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)