Tell her it broke

"Wait, the condom broke!" you exclaimed. She had put your head inside of her but she immediately froze, teasing just the head with her bare pussy. Even just the head sent you into overdrive, as you finally felt how tight and wet her pussy was. You groan as she pulled off of you.

"Come on, I can just pull out! I'm good at it, I swear" you say, but to no avail.

"I don't even know you, I don't trust you like that." she said, and started to get dressed. "And I definitely do not want you to get me pregnant, no offense."

Your cock started to soften, and you got a little angry, but you sucked it up and got dressed as well, knowing there might still be another conquest at the party.