Tearjerkers and Teasing

“Hey, Jay. Tanya told me to come here first.” Brooke greets you, and you ask her to come in and you offer to get her bag but she says it’s fine.

“The movie’s already over, but there’s still some beer left if you want to take a load off while you’re here.” You offer her.

“Nah. It’s cool. I’m not actually here for movie night. I asked Tanya if I could sleep at her place tonight, actually. Maybe tomorrow too. Courtney’s intentionally trying to involve me with her drama with Chad and I’m having none of it.” Brooke informs you.

“She’s being loud with a guy again?” You ask.

“Yup.” Brooke answers, unable to hide her irritation with her roommate.

“Well, you’re welcome to stay here too if you’d like. No one’s using Stella’s room anymore since she’s sleeping with me now.” You offer Brooke.

“That would’ve been smoother if you invited me to sleep in your room instead.” Brooke teases you.

“I mean if you’re in a rush. If you can’t wait a couple more days I can probably slot you in maybe~ —” You tease her back smugly, getting her to playfully slap you in the chest to stop, while she continues to laugh.

“Someone’s getting cocky.” Brooke responds, getting you to laugh with her.

“I mean, if you didn’t run away after finding out about the app; I’m willing to risk that a bit of teasing won’t change your mind if you like me or not.” You tell her.

“It doesn’t.” Brooke assures you. “In fact, you know you’re the shit with the magic; so why not embrace it, right?” Brooke shares some affirmation. “Just don’t go full heel on me, alright?” She adds, sounding like it’s a caveat.

“Whatever you said I shouldn’t go full off, I won’t. I promise.” You tell her.

“You don’t know what heel means? I’m going to need to tutor you on wrestling lingo.” Brooke reacts.

“Hey, Brooke!” The girls shout from the living room, getting you and Brooke to pause your conversation so she can greet them.

“Why are you girls crying!?” Brooke reacts in surprise.

“Toy Story 3.” Cassie answers her, and Brooke immediately understands.

“I get you. The opening of Up does that to me too.” Brooke responds.

“Selena for me. As soon as Dreaming of You hits, and I see that empty mic on stage, I’m weeping. Inconsolable. I’m crying more than the actors in the movie after hearing the news.” Tanya shares.

“Can you be any more stereotypically Latina?” Brooke teases her.

“Cierra tu puta boca.” Tanya reacts defensively.

“Apparently you can.” Brooke continues to tease, making her and Cassie laugh; to the annoyance of Tanya.

“What about you, Mr. Craig? What breaks out your manly tears?” Paige asks you.

“Iron Giant.” You and Stella answer at about the same time.

“Iron Giant?” Brooke asks with a raised eyebrow.

“You are who you choose to be.” Stella says the line for you.

“Suuuupermaaan.” You say in your graveliest, Vin Diesel-iest, voice.

“And the tears flow.” Stella says dramatically, using her hands and fingers to signal tears falling from your eyes like waterfalls.

“I should check that out then.” Brooke responds.

“Oh! The next movie night! We can watch that!” Tanya suggests excitedly, to everyone’s agreement.

“What brings you by, by the way? Are you staying the night?” Cassie asks, and Stella gasps upon finally registering the overnight bag Brooke’s carrying.

“Did you and Dad make plans!?” Stella asks excitedly.

“I guess that’s my signal to go home.” Paige jokes.

“No~! Stella’s just kidding.” You assure Paige.

“Brooke’s staying over at my place. She’s having roommate problems and needs a place to sleep.” Tanya informs the girls.

“Courtney’s giving you trouble? What about?” Paige asks.

“She’s getting **** on Chad by… cucking Chad.” Brooke answers, to the girls’ visible confusion. “Don’t! Don’t make me explain how, since I don’t understand it either. Just know that she’s being intentionally loud so I can hear it.” Brooke shares.

“That’s why she’s sleeping at my place.” Tanya adds.

“From the sound of it, Courtney and Chad are a match made in gym-bo heaven.” Stella reacts. “You get it? I mixed gym bro and bimbo—” Stella then explains her joke, and Cassie immediately stops her by saying, “We got it.”

Despite the explanation, Paige still insists that it’s time for her head back home, so the five of you say your goodbyes to her. Tanya helps Brooke settle in her place afterwards; while you, Stella, and Cassie get ready for bed.

You take out your phone to call Becca, wanting to ask if she and Maddy are alright, or if they’re on their way so Maddy doesn’t miss her curfew; but your doorbell rings again. You know it’s not Tanya since she has her own keys to your apartment now; and assume that it’s either Becca and Maddy or Viv.

You walk to your apartment door and get immediately greeted once you swing it open.

“S’up Virgin?” Viv greets you.

“Look who I saw making her way up the stairs?” Tanya greets you from behind Viv.

“Are we still doing nicknames, girlfriend?” You reply sweetly, trying not to encourage Viv’s teases by showing annoyance after hearing her call you ‘Virgin’. “I really like it better when you just call me by my name, you know. Boyfriend’s good too.” You tell her.

“What? I call you by your name sometimes. Junior’s your name right?” Viv continues to goad you.

“Why you like being difficult, I’ll never understand.” Tanya points out to Viv as the two of them enter your apartment.

“I’m not being difficult! First name basis is earned, and it’s on a ‘what have you done for me lately?’ scale. What Virgin has done for me lately has earned him the nickname.” Viv continues to tease you, making herself and Tanya laugh.

It’s at this time Cassie and Stella exit your bedroom in their sleepwear. Stella’s wearing boy short style panties and a white V-neck tee that’s almost see-through, at least see-through enough that you know she’s not wearing a bra; Cassie, meanwhile, is wearing a purple silky camisole with lace detailing, and matching hipster style panties.

“Oh~ no. Two nights in a row is the maximum amount, Viv. He’s sleeping with us tonight.” Stella reacts upon seeing Viv. The tone in Stella’s voice does send alarm signals in your brain upon hearing it.

Is there a hint of jealousy there?

That shouldn’t be possible with Normalized Polyamory, right? It’s this question that leads you to test out what it is Stella exactly feels in this situation.

“What if I want to sleep at Viv’s tonight? Would that be alright with you, baby?” You ask her, trying to make the question sound as innocent as possible.

“Oh. Yeah. Of course. I was just teasing Viv, Dad. It’s cool.” Stella answers you.

“Are you sure? You’re not going to be jealous of Viv if I do?” You remove all subtlety and ask outright.

“Yeah. Of course. We’re all your girlfriends. Obviously, I want you to sleep next to us tonight, but I won’t blame you or Viv if you guys want more private time.” Stella responds.

“Trust me, after last night, I’m not sure I want more private time with Virgin.” Viv jokes at your expense.

“Virgin?” Cassie asks, curious.

“Hiding your inept skills in fucking me from the other girlfriends, Virgin?” Viv teases.

“Inept!? No fucking way!” Stella reacts in shock.

“Oh~ yeah. I went there. Did you ever wonder why after I was screaming in pleasure from the spanking, we suddenly got all quiet?” Viv asks your teenage girlfriends.

“Hey! You said you loved last night!” You react defensively.

“I didn’t want to hurt your wittle ego, so I just said it to make you feel better.” Viv continues to goad.

Then it hits you.

“Just admit it. Wittle Becca was scayuhd of asking the group out.”
...
“We consider this foreplay, Jay.”
...
“I’m acting like a bratty sub to give Becca an opening to ‘discipline’ me.”

Memories of what her and Becca talked about last night flash quickly in your mind.

This is Viv’s foreplay.

“Here’s my advice about that. Do what you want, but always have your sub in mind.”

Do what you want.

“…an opening to ‘discipline’ me.”

Always have your sub in mind.

“That sounds like a ‘you’ problem, Viv. You could have just taken off your compression shorts.” Cassie points out.

“I’m submissive, remember!? He should have done that himself. I wanted him to take control!” Viv says defensively. Very convincingly that she’s serious about what she’s saying, even though you’re beginning to believe this is all just play for her.

“Woah! Hey! Enough, V. This is sounding like a serious argument. How about we just calm down and—” Tanya tries to take control of the situation for you, but you know that’s not what’s going to get Viv to stop.

“Enough.” You say, channeling all the times you had to talk to Stella like a parent to get your delivery to be as authoritative as possible.

“You want me to take control? Fine. Bedroom. Now.” You command her, and Viv immediately has a naughty smile on her face, and a sparkle in her eye. Viv does as you command and enters your bedroom ahead of you.

“Wait, where are we sleeping?” Stella asks you.

“I didn’t tell you guys to leave.” You answer your daughter, and the three of them all have knowing smiles after hearing your response.

“I bet she likes being teased, right? How about you do her last? Show her what you can really do first!” Cassie suggests, and Stella immediately laughs.

“You just want to cuck Viv. Don’t pretend.” Stella teases Cassie, laughing boisterously as she does so.

“I wouldn’t laugh too hard, baby. Cassie’s cucking you too.” You tease your daughter, making Cassie the one that’s laughing now. Stella’s eyes widen as she tries to decipher your expression, trying to see if you were being serious.

“What’s taking so long, Junior? Already pussying out?” Viv goads from inside the bedroom.

“Baby, can you ask Viv to shut up… or make her. Up to you.” You instruct your daughter. Stella gives you a nod and enters the bedroom; leaving you, Cassie, and Tanya outside.

…

“Okay. Real talk. I have no fucking clue what I’m doing.” You admit to your girlfriends, in a bit of a panic.

“Could’ve fooled me, papi.” Tanya tells you with an amused smile.

“Yeah, Jay.” Cassie agrees.

“If all else fails, just do what feels natural to you. It hasn’t let you down with us.” Tanya assures you.

“I just know I need your help tonight.” You admit.

“You’ve got it, papi.” Tanya assures you once more. “I can help order Viv around. I’m used to being controlling in the bedroom anyway.” Tanya adds.

“I can help tease Viv and Stella. If nothing else, at least I’m going to enjoy myself.” Cassie jokes, and you and Tanya laugh at that. You take a deep breath to calm yourself down, before looking at Cassie and Tanya who give you reassuring smiles.

“Ladies? After you.”