Tara wins

After a minute or so, you really need to get off, so you pick a winner. "We have a winner, and it's.....Tara!"

"YES!" said Tara and she runs to you and puts her tongue in your mouth.

After a long, wet kiss, you push her off and turn to the other girls who are all sad; in fact, Megan is crying. "Well, I'll fuck another one of you before school tomorrow. Whoever can send me the sexiest pic to my cell phone tonight. But right now, the rest of you really need to practice your french kissing, so have at it until I've fucked Tara."

As the girls pair up, you lead Tara to the shower. You both strip, and you kiss again as your hands explore each others' bodies. After a while, you turn her around, and she braces herself against the shower wall. You enter her sopping wet pussy from behind.

You smack her ass a few times before grabbing her hips. You fuck away and make sure that Tara has been on the pill and using it correctly, and this is the greatest fuck of her life.

Tara orgasms multiple times and cries of "Yes! Yes! Yes!" over and over again. You're having a ball too, and it helps that you know the girls in the locker area can hear Tara.

Soon you cum long and hard. You both are panting and sweaty, so you turn on the shower after you pull out, and Tara washes your body.