Sure, might as well fix her unfair scores

Maybe it would be refreshing to branch out a little, but it was pretty mean to score Caitlin like that. After all, as your older sister, she did always look out for you. This was no way to pay her back. Plus, you have to admit fucking her felt incredible. Even now, after blowing two loads in less than an hour, you felt your pants grow tight as you thought of that blowjob.

Your mind made up, you make your way to Caitlin’s room, finding it empty. “Caitlin?” you call out. “We’re in the bathroom!” she answers. You take a seat on the bed to wait before suddenly jolting up. “We? Who else is there?”

“Dana! She’s helping me shave!” You cross the hall to the bathroom, cracking the door open to find Caitlin nude and bent over the sink countertop as Dana carefully maneuvers a razor across her outer lips. You step in as Dana looks up and smiles. “We already shaved the front, we’re just finishing up here.” After a few more strokes she puts down the razor and gets up. “All done!” Dana says cheerfully. “Nice and smooth. This should get your pussy up to a 5 or 6.”

“What do you think, bro?” Caitlin asks nervously. You run your fingers across her vagina, spreading her lips open as you take a look. “Much better. It looks way more fuckable now.”

“So you’ll bump me up?” Caitlin asks, anxiously looking back at you. “Please John, I don’t want to just do anal and titjobs forever.” She was practically wailing by the end of that sentence.

“Well, it’s not that simple,” you say. “I can’t just fix a score like that. We’d have to do an entire re-inspection.” Seeing the disappointment in her face, you carry on. “But… I suppose I have time in my schedule to re-evaluate you right now.”

Caitlin’s face brightens. “You’d really do that for me?” “Sure,” you reply. “You’re my sister, after all. We have to look out for each other.” Caitlin starts to turn around. “Thank you so much! I can blow you again, but Carter always said he loved my pussy the most anyw-“

You push her back over the counter, cutting her off, before ripping off your pants and lining up your cock with her pussy. “Wait a second! L-let me get warmed up before you put it in, or else I won’t get an accurate score!” Caitlyn shrieks, one hand reaching down towards her clit. You agree, rubbing your cock on her pussy instead as you wait for her. You take a moment to appreciate how soft and smooth it is before you remember Dana, who’s been watching her sister with a supportive smile on her face.