Stay.

You really hoped that you wouldn't have to deal with this for a while, but you don't want to weird Paige out any more than you have already today. It seems you have **** but to suck it up and get fucked—which, in reality, wouldn't be something you'd complain about before...funny how your new reality has changed your mindset.

You look back to Paige with a small nod. "Yeah, it is. Small world, I guess."

Sensing your shift in mood, she frowns. "Are you okay? You seem not so happy to see her," she comments as a small dribble of the guy's cum drips onto her lips. Reflexively, she licks it up as if she wasn't even thinking about it, still concerned about you. You do your best to ignore it and smile with a shrug.

"Nah, it's good. She's just a virgin, you know? I was hoping I wouldn't have to deal with that kind of business while spending time with you." She smiles back with an understanding nod as she finishes her cumstained sandwich.

"I guess it would get tiring, yeah," Paige agrees. "But why haven't you taken her virginity already? Surely you've seen each other recently enough?"

You blink, coming to the realization yourself. What if she's right and you have fucked her already in this world? Just like Paige's relationship with her supervisor changed, what if your relationship with your sister changed? One way, you look like an idiot in front of your new girlfriend—not that that's anything new with how today has been playing out—and the other way, you're **** to fuck your sister.

"Hey, John!"

You look over your shoulder, and see your sister and her friend's smiling faces...