Sarah

"GUGUGHHUFFFFFF~"

Sarah cried out, seeing stars as she felt your warmth, your thickness, your presence inside her.

You had leaned forward on your childhood bed and thrusted upwards into the beautiful cheerleader's warm and inviting folds. The girl you'd feared for so long, the idol of the entire school, now squirmed under you like a slut while biting her lip to hold back her moans. A selfish part of you didn't want her to hold back so you began rubbing her body even more while you fucked her so her voice would come out. Your spine shuddered from happiness and your mind reeled from relief. Her walls clamped down on your intruding cock as you slowly drew back, and Sarah no longer held any sense of decorum as she squealed in abject delight. Every fold was pushed and pressed out as she felt every throbbing inch of you fill her up. She moaned, humping her hips up at you as you picked up a rhythm inside her pussy.

*PLAP-! PLAP-!*

Your hand reached over to grab hers, fingers lacing together. Something about the warmth of her hand as your fingers fit snugly against hers, the gentle pull as you pumped into her and let loose a moan that shows just how much you’re enjoying yourself, made her chest tighten and head spin in the best way. Your own mind was blank from rapture as you continued to swing your hips with no small amount of ****. Sarah's perfect breasts bounced against Nancy's with each meeting of your hips, her inner walls tight and wet, coaxing more and more intense response from your pleasure-addled brain.

Knowing that you are taking her, and that you chose to fuck her first, caused Sarah to smile from ear-to-ear. She laid back and enjoyed the feeling of your shaft thrusting into and filling out her precious place over and over.

"You are so hot, Sarah, y-your pussy is trying to melt me."

"God, it feels! So! Good! John!" She meant it, and she wasn't sure if it could get any hotter for her. You were currently slamming into her as hard as you could, and boy was it feeling good. A real rising star in the field of fucking, she thought. "Sarah…" you groaned as you pumped away into her, slamming her hips with each strike. "Y-you're so t-tighhhtt..."

The sounds coming from her body and lips sounded so odd to her ears, coming from a place of pure, raw lust and the desire coursing through her body from the way you fucked her in an almost animalistic vigor. It felt like she was going to die.

Well, if she was going to die from so much pleasure, then let it be so.

"Oh! Ohh! John! Ohh! Yes! Yes! I love you! Yes! YESSS!" You exhaled sharply as she began quivering around you, clenching down onto your shaft and loosing a spray of juices on you as you continued pumping into her, fucking her until she was satisfied.

With a loud "ahhhh…" Sarah collapsed as you pulled out of her cunt. You were beginning to feel exhausted and knew that the tightness wound inside you was building and would soon split, spilling your seed.

Before you could stop and think for too long, you once again found yourself captivated, enthralled, mesmerized and hypnotized by Nancy's incredible green eyes, your thoughts melting in your brain and dripping away, unneeded, down your spine as you waited for orders from your love.

She had turned around and stared deep into your eyes, past your thoughts, past your secrets, her eyes bored a green drill straight to the core of your being. "John, dear." Her voice was silky and melodious, like listening to it was the easiest, most pleasurable thing in the world. Your gaze still trapped behind her eyes, your brain felt like it was on fire, her words echoing and rattling in your mind, the act of recalling them granting a similar level of enjoyment as hearing her speak. "I need to be fucked. By you. Right now. " It was a wonder she hadn't made you cum just by speaking.

You dragged the head of your cock along her slit, then pressed it right up against her entrance. “I can f-feel you trying… to pull me in…” you said, as you let yourself slowly push inside of her. It was hot, scaldingly hot. Every time you had sex, you forgot what a shock the heat was until you experienced it. Nancy was like velvet inside, silky and clenching around you, and you groaned deep in your throat.

Neither of you could move after the initial thrust. Your eye lines drifted to somewhere indistinguishable as your worlds were rocked to their cores. You could have sworn you had never had anything so pleasurable surrounding your penis and that the textured folds of Nancy's vagina were the hottest and wettest item in the whole world. Conversely, Nancy felt like she had never been fucked so fully, so perfectly. The pure, blossoming pleasure of something so big and thick stretching out her sensitive folds was making her whimper and squirm under you. Your eyes regained focus as the image in front of you came into sight. Nancy bent over in front of you. Your cock plunging into her depths, her pussy lips tight around it, squeezing it. The full roundness of her ass, spread apart and ground under her fingers. The wide childbearing hips and how they contrasted with the smallness of her waist. Her head, thrown forward in ecstasy and pressed against Sarah's comforting pillows. Sarah's own head, askew as she looked blankly ahead, through you despite your eye contact. Sarah's red tresses laying in every which way, strands sticking to her spit-soaked face, which Nancy periodically leaned to nibble and lick absentmindedly.

A shuddering breath slips past her lips as you sank further into her, thick cock stretching her apart in the most delicious burn. It had her tummy tensing up, fingernails digging into her own thighs until you spot the indents in her smooth skin and grab her hands in your own instead. A shared gasp is passed between you when you finally bottom out, sinking to the hilt and freezing when her walls tighten around you.

“Fuck, you’re so big,” she mindlessly babbled, gripping your hands tighter while you let yourself get used to her tightness. After what's happened at school you could use the ego boost and it just sounds so right coming from her, looking absolutely delectable underneath you, eyes glazed over and the cutest pout on her lips. You want to hear more of those pretty sounds she makes, slowly inching back out, feeling the glide of her walls against your cock before thrusting back into her.

*SMACK!*

It sends a shock down your spine, sparking up your skin, as you repeat it again, low grunts leaving your mouth until you're fucking into Nancy with fluid hips, skin slapping together each time. A smirk pulls at your lips when the head of your cock curves just right inside of her and she arches her back.

You thrust into her with long, deep thrusts. You liked this angle, liked how it let you penetrate that much deeper, liked the way you could pull back and watch yourself. You held her ass open, squeezing it with one hand and watched your cock slide in and out of her. She was small enough and tight enough that her cunt was actively trying to suck you back inside.

"Uugghhh… it is for this reason-ugh! that a man will leave his father and mother and be JOINED to his wife. And the two… will… become… one flessshhhhh. Can you-ah! see John? This holy lovemaking is God's plan for sex! Isn't it amazing?!"

Your fractured mind was splitting into countless pieces as the pleasure grew exponentially and you had no idea how she could still speak. You couldn't, and grunted bestially.

Her back still arched, you reached forward, fingers running over her flat midriff towards her tits. You cup a tender breast in one hand and feel the delightfully soft flesh bulge in your palm, squeezing it as the luscious melon spilled between your fingers. The other took hold of her chin and pulled her into a deep, sweaty, tongue-filled kiss while you railed her. *PLAP PLAP PLAP PLAP* went the wet sounds of meat colliding with meat as you once again pressed against her face.

You feel a rising tone in Nancy's throat as it vibrates, intensifying as it rattles through your hand on her chest and lips on her mouth. Her inner walls, already tight, attempt to constrict you as if to ****. And then, with a high squeal that slowly descends, she begins convulsing and coating you with her juices, cumming and cumming again as you continued to press into the slick hotness of her snatch. With each slippery thrust into her cunt your sense of touch was completely overwhelmed by the mouthwatering pleasure of fucking this girl, using this girl, loving this girl.

Afterwards, you thought it wouldn't have been able to feel this good, this intimate, if she hadn't taken you on dates and engineered an emotional connection between you.

"NAN…CY!" you growl in two thrusts, finally reaching your breaking point as the building pressure inside of you, that ball of tension in your core, magnified and increased beyond what seemed possible from the edging, came undone and your balls began to unload their entire supply up your shaft and spray it from your cock head, drenching Nancy's insides as you gasp and shudder from the best orgasm yet.

You both continue kissing and making out as best you can, but once you have been drained to the last drop and her pussy has stopped quivering and clenching around you, you both fall forward onto Sarah, exhausted. Sarah, for her part, had become more full and satisfied than she had ever been in her life, and was content to bask in the afterglow as she lay beneath Nancy and heard your fucking, sometimes reaching a lazy finger to graze a smooth curve that looked particularly appetizing, or pinch a small nipple that looked lonely, or languidly press a tongue against Nancy's if their faces met.

You lay together, a mass of bodies and limbs splayed in every direction, for some while before rolling off the girls and finding an empty spot. You run your hands aimlessly over the sheets, feeling the sweat and pussy juice coated fabric under your fingers as you try to take in and believe what just happened, your brain desperately racing to convert the otherworldly sensations your nervous system had received and process them as events that had happened to you.

"So? Who won?" Nancy said, poking you as you drooled onto the sheets.

"I, I, I, I… I don't know," you manage to stammer out. Your thoughts spill from your head before you can consider what they are as you say "That was the best sex of my life. You are just both so beautiful. Sarah's tits, Nancy's ass, Sarah's red hair, Nancy's green eyes… I've never felt so fulfilled and satisfied before and it's all thanks to both of you."

Ever the diplomat, you are a fucking idiot.