Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by emx2064 emx2064

Who was on the other side?

Sam, the college-aged mistaken babysitter

Slightly disgruntled at having her soothing bath interupted, Jenn clutched her towl around her and opened the door to the sight of a woman's bare midriff.

Jenn's eyes traced up past the woman's toned stomach to the massive bosom barely contained in a red crop top, and radient smile peeking over the two mounds.

"Awwwww" the taller woman cooed, crouching down to eye-level with Jenn, her long strawberry blonde hair cascading down her sholders, and a draw-dropping amount of cleavage practically bursting out her top. Jenn also noticed her carrying a large pink suitcase, "You must be little Jenn, right! I'm Sam" she smiled, extending her hand to Jenn.

"Um, yeah thats me" Jenn responded puzzled.

Jenn looked on a bit confused as to why this attractive college girl, who didnt look that much younger than she was, had turned up at her door at this hour in morning and somehow knew her name. She was also a annoyed at being called "little", but seeing her guest's warm unoffending smile made her decide to just let it go.

Assuming that she was a neighbour trying to meet the new arrival, she reached out her hand with trepidation to Sam, which promted a gentle handshake.

"So, um as you can see" Jenn said gesturing to her towelled body, "I appreciate the pleasantries, but Im a bit busy at the moment, you can stop by later if yo-" before getting cut off by Sam patting her head. "Wha-"

"Your parents warned me about your unwillingless to have a babysitter, young lady" she remarked curtly.

"Huh? Parents? B-babysitter???"

"I understand, when I was your age I used to think I was all grown up too.." Sam trailed on.

"I AM GROWN UP!" Jenn fired back, smaking Sam's hand off her head "I dont know who you think I am, but Im 22 years old and I do NOT need a babysitter!"

Her retort caused Sam's cute face to forrow, before unexpectedly breaking out into a fit of giggles,

"HAH, that's a new one alright!" Sam laughed, wiping a tear from her eye "You can surely do better than that, kid! No point lying about who you are when you litterally just admitted to being Jenn like 5 seconds ago, and I mean cmmon, 22? You couldnt pick a more belivable age to pretend to be? Im only 21 yknow" Sam laughed, as Jenn turned bright red and practically steaming , her fists bunched to her sides.

"I dont know what mixup this is but I AM JENN, AND I AM 22" Jenn said, tears almost welling in her eyes.

"Oh there there sweetheart" Sam cooed, her stomach hurting from all that laughing, as she hugged Jenn into her prodigious bosom "I didnt mean to make you feel bad, Im sure your plenty mature for your age, but your parents are out for 2 weeks and we cant leave a little cutie like you left unattended now can we" she said squeezing Jenn's rosy cheeks.

Jenn figured arguing back wasnt going to work right now, and decided to cooperate until she could show her ID or anything to get to the bottom of this mixup.

Noticing the snivelling had stopped, Sam pulled the now calmed down Jenn away from her bosom and wiped her tears from her face. "See its okay now, I'll dicipline you later for that little outburst of yours, but I'll play nice if you promise not to lie and scream any more" Sam spoke soothingly, to which the defeated Jenn nodded slowly.


Unknown to both girls, Sam had confused Jenn's house for that of her neighbors who lived 2 streets down.

The Parkers, who had just moved in with their 10 year old daughter, ordered Sam, who was babysitting as a part-time gig to get through college, to look after their daughter coincidentally also named Jenn (although it was short for Jenna not Jennifier), whilst they went on a work trip for 2 weeks.

They had warned her about Jenna's notorious streak of pathological lying, and her knack for coming up with elaborate stories and ideas, especially to get out of being babysat, and given Sam strict instructions not to entertain any of them.

The trip had got cancelled last minute, and the wealthy couple forgot about telling the babysitter which they had already paid for, a combination of that and Sam's poor direction skills, had lead to the current mixup.


"Now." Sam added, looking at Jenn's small towelled body, as she lead her into her own house, dragging in her large suitcase in as Jenn sulked dejectedly. "I can see you were getting ready for a bath, but your parents clearly told me you're not properly capable of that yet, but dont worry, I've got plenty of experience bathing my little siblings!"

"Huh?" Jenn responded mortified.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)