One of His Stepsister's Friends

John opened the door to see, disappointingly, one of his stepsister's friends and classmates outside.

He had been hoping it would be one of his MILFs, but he supposed he could work with her.

"Oh, hi...John, right?" the girl asked. "I'm Alicia Sloane. Is Melody around? We were supposed to study for a project together today."

"She is," John said. "Come on in, and remember: stripping nude is proper etiquette."

"I know that!" Alicia snapped as she disrobed. Lisa looked on, seeming both appalled and upset that a younger woman was stripping naked for John.

"Lisa, that goes for you too."

Lisa promptly stripped, allowing John an eyeful of her mature curves.

"Now," John said once he had both Alicia and Lisa's attention. "I know both of you want me to fuck you and be your boyfriend, but of course I can only pick one of you. So who's it gonna be?"

"Me! Me!" both women said at once.

"Pick me, John!" said Alicia. "I'll have sex in any position!"

"No, pick me!" Lisa said. "I'm far more experienced!"

John looked between both women.