Take her to a club

You take your date to a club that is supposed to have a good reputation, after partaking in weed, booze and alot of partying you and May call it for the night and make your way back home your god like abilities allow you to sober up enough to drive home.

Once you arrive home you walk in to find Dawn with a smug smile passed out in your bed, "I take it she was well taken care of" you say to Elaine "yes of course master" after putting May to bed being she passed out on the way home you walk to Elaine's room where you find her waiting for you.