Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 3 by SCALLYWAGMUNCHIES SCALLYWAGMUNCHIES

Who was I going to pick?

Billie

I got onto my knees and began to tease her pussy with my cock. She began to grind herself on my cock and Peyton's pussy. She was getting really intense. I decided that enough was enough, and my reward needed to be claimed. So I grabbed hold of the base of my cock, gave Billie a firm slap on the ass, and entered her pussy, filling it with my cock.

She moaned loudly, but Peyton began to kiss her again to prevent anybody else from hearing us. Me and Billie began to fuck vigorously since our sexual frustrations were being released. I could hear Billie's moans from Peyton's mouth. I decided to pull out shortly afterwards and push myself into Peyton. I had to admit, she was a lot tighter than Billie was. This didn't stop me from fucking her with the same intensity.

It was Billie now who was trying to muffle Peyton's moans as I continued to fuck Peyton as hard as possible. Billie decided to intensify Peyton's sensations by crossing one of her legs over Peyton so they were basically scissoring. This didn't take long before Peyton had an orgasm. The vibrations of Peyton's orgasm caused Billie to also have an orgasm. I continued to fuck Peyton as my waist smashed against Billie's incredible ass.

Shortly after, I felt my own orgasm coming, so I pulled out of Peyton and ejaculated over both of their pussies. They couldn't help releasing each other to moan at the feeling of my hot cum splashing against their pussies. Once I had finished, I managed to pull myself onto the bench I was sitting on and spectate the scene.

Billie had spun herself round so herself and Peyton were in a 69 position, licking eachother out, tasting the mixture of our juices.

"Mmm... this was fun, John. Hopefully it won't be too long until we're on the main roster with you." Billie said as she eventually got off of Peyton.

"Yeah, I hope so too." Peyton added, panting heavily.

We all carried on making small talk whilst we were getting dressed. I had put my black suit on, whilst Peyton had put on a burgundy crop top and dark blue skinny jeans. Billie had put on a lacy black crop top with some black leggings. Before we left, Peyton had asked for my phone number. I obviously gave it to her so we could contact each other in the future.

We all walked to the parking lot and drove home to our respective houses.

The next morning.

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)