Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 43 by adam17017 adam17017

Tonight?

An interesting night

Everyone at the cabin was preparing to head to bed, and extra blankets and pillows were provided for Lisa. Lisa would be sleeping on the couch with Hannah and Taylor, while Chloe will give sleeping with Kurt another shot. Zack and Heather were getting ready for bed awkwardly, as non of them had even spoken to one another since Zack spoke to her on the couch. Zack looked over at Heather, he still had feelings for her, though he had tried to bury them already to no avail. Having feelings for Heather would be the end of him, Heather was a free spirit he knew that, but knowing she goes around sleeping with other guys at the cabin sent a dagger into Zack's heart every time. Sometimes the results of which can hurt the people he loved like what he had said to Heather in the heat of the moment. "Heather. I'm sorry for what I said on the couch." He said as he finished brushing his teeth and he looked back at her through the mirror as she was just slipping her pajama shirt on, preventing Zack from seeing anything that he wanted to. As soon as Heather's head appeared out of the shirt, she caught Zack's glance from the mirror and smirked at him.

"That's ok Zack. I know we were in the heat of the moment."

"Thanks Heather, that means a lot." Zack said as he finished rinsing his mouth and Heather finished changing, and they both got under the covers. "Good night Heather." Zack said as he switched off the light which was at his bedside. They both lay there in silence for a little until Heather slung her arm around Zack's waist and kissed his neck from behind.

"I missed you so much Zack. You can't even imagine. That makes me angry, you know why?" She asked as Zack turned around to face her.

"Why?" He asked as he moved the hair in her face behind her ears.

"Because I knew that you weren't missing me. I knew that you were enjoying yourself with Lisa, that you had given up on me, on what could've been."

"Heather, you know why I gave up on you, I had feelings for you, heck I still do. You took advantage of me, I had sex with Ashley, I know I should be feeling excited and happy about that, but I'm not. I went to the cave with all of you thinking I could get you all alone, I thought maybe we could've continued where we left off when we fell into Chloe's room and were interrupted. That's why I wanted to go to the cave, I thought I had lost you, so I fucked Ashley, now I feel bad for her too, she deserves more than a jealousy fuck. I like you, Heather, I like you so much, but I know we can never be together." Zac said as he stared into her eyes, as she turned away from him and Zack was staring into the back of her head.

"I like you too Zack." She said so quietly that Zack couldn't hear her

"What was that Heather?"

"I need to go to the washroom."

"Yeah, sure. Of course." He said as he watched her walk right past their own washroom and walk out of their room. Zack slammed his fist down into his pillow and screamed "Fuck!" into his pillow to muffle the sound.

Heather exited the room and heard Zack's muffled scream from the other side of the door. She leaned her back against the door and closed her eyes. Why am I doing this? On the other side of this door is a man who I know will love me for who I am, why isn't that ever good enough for me? Whenever I get too attached to a guy, I always run away to the next one. I don't know what it is about attachment that scares me so much. If I continue this, I'm only going to keep pushing the people I love away from me. I'm sorry Zack, give me some more time. Wait for me!

Heather walked down the hallway of rooms until she saw Ashley's room door open, she peeked her head inside but she couldn't see anything. "Ashley, are you in there?"

"No, she isn't." Grumbled Brandon sleepily. Brandon! Ashley's not here, I'll have a quickie then head back to my room. Yeah, let's do that.

"Well Brandon, looks like it's your lucky night." Heather said as she closed the door behind her.

Ashley, Hannah, Lisa, and Taylor were all in the living room watching as Heather walked into Ashley's open room. "She took the bait." Said Ashley

"Are you sure about this Ashley, she's going to fuck your boyfriend." Taylor asked

"Yeah, it's fine. I just hope we can have an open relationship like Lisa and Zacky here."

"I'm sure he'll do whatever you ask from him after this." Hannah assured her sister

"He already basically told me he's open to it. I'll hold this above his head so he can let me sleep with Zack again. If you don't mind that is?" She asked Lisa and Taylor

"I don't mind. Zack knows our agreement."

"Why would I mind? I'm only his sister." She said flustered.

"Hey Taylor, I'll make an addition to our rule. You know how because you fucked Brandon, the rule said you could only fuck him for the rest of our stay and I could fuck everyone?"

"Yeah?" Taylor said sullenly

"I'll say that you can fuck an extra guy, so you can only fuck two guys for the duration of our stay, and one of them has to be Brandon. I don't care who the other guy you choose is, that's up to you, just tell me who it is when you choose." Hannah said as she winked at Lisa, both girls had an idea who Taylor would choose.

"Ok girls, let's get the plan moving, you two keep Zack busy for a while so Hannah and I can discuss our plan for tomorrow night, I told Brandon to take his time with Heather. I know that Heather is torn between Zack and running away from her feelings, so she'll probably want to be quick with Brandon then run back to Zack." Ashley said.

"Ok, we're on our way." Lisa said as she took Taylor's hand. "Oh wait! Taylor, walk ahead, I forgot something in the kitchen"

"Ok?" Taylor said as she walked towards the Lake Room at the end of the hall. Lisa was quickly beside her again, and led her to the door. "What are we going to say to him?" Taylor asked Lisa. Lisa put her hand on the door knob turned it and planted a quick kiss on Taylor's lips.

"Whatever you want baby." She said as she pushed Taylor gently into the room and closed the door behind her and locked with the key she got from the kitchen. Taylor was still in shock from what Lisa just did, she's like a sister to me, and she just kissed me! Damn, I'm already having impure thoughts about my brother, now Lisa comes along and muddles me up some more? Oh shit! Taylor thought as she realized where she was. She was in Zack's room, and by the click she heard from the door, she was locked in. Zack hadn't heard Taylor entering his room because he was too busy jacking off to the taboo thought of Taylor jacking him off. Zack was getting close now, he had never thought about Taylor this way before, but when he had started, Taylor came to his mind and he just went with it. When he saw Taylor's face above his, he thought this was all part of his fantasy. When she leaned down to kiss him, he thought that it felt incredibly life like, as if it were actually happening, but he discarded the thought and took advantage of the only time he would ever be able to make out with his sister without getting a black eye or worse. Zack continued to jack himself off as he made out with his 'fantasy' sister, until her hand rested on his, stopping him from jerking himself. She pried his hand loose, and once it was off his thick, long cock, she spit into her hand and placed it on his shaft. This whole time, Zack was staring into the incredibly life like vision of his sister, in his lust filled mind. When she placed her lubed hand on his shaft, he took the initiative and continued to make out with her once again. As Zack reached his orgasm, he fired the largest load he had ever ejaculated as five full ropes of cum sprayed out of his head and into her hand, and some flew through the gaps in he fingers and landed on her shirt. Finally when Zack had settled down, he opened his eyes to see Taylor still sitting there.

"You're not a fantasy are you?" He asked resigned to the answer.

"If it makes it easier for you, I can be what you want." She said "You're huge load got my shirt dirty Zack, looks like I'll have to take it off if you don't have any objections?"

"Who put you up to this Taylor?"

"This was my idea, Lisa just gave me the push I needed."

"Lisa." Zack said with a smile "In that case, I have no objections whatsoever."

The plan in action?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)