If I'd have kept my mouth shut I'd have never wrote this song

Dawn’s heart thumped in her chest. The current situation was difficult for her to quantify, and she had good cause to be nervous. As excited as she was about having sex with Nick, she also needed to consider that Dani was here, as well. Unlike with her previous threesomes with Rose, she couldn’t just sit back and let Nick pleasure them both- Dani wouldn’t want to do anything with Nick, which meant that it was her responsibility to keep the tomboy involved, even if she wasn’t attracted to women.

At least, as far as she knew, anyway.

The fact that she wasn’t exactly opposed to getting involved with other women in threesomes made her conviction a little shaky.

If that was the extent of her concerns, Dawn probably wouldn’t be worried like this. But not only did she need to take Dani’s feelings into consideration, but there was a fourth person joining them on the bed- and that person was Cinder.

When it came to sexuality, Dawn wasn’t certain that there was anything she could do that would be right in Cinder’s books, and she knew Cinder wouldn’t want anything to do with Dani.

So, again, it was going to be up to her.

The irony that Dawn’s Poser transformation made her more interested in being used by her sexual partners instead of taking an active role was not lost on her.

On that note… Dawn took the first move. She walked towards the bed, waving her ass and making her tail wag behind her. She turned and looked back, making sure that the others were watching- but especially Nick.

My ass isn’t as good as other girls, but it’s still my best quality, she thought. Why couldn’t I have gotten a repeat on my transformation from last round, and enjoy using my butt to please Nick? That would be better than my feet.

She couldn’t imagine anyone finding feet sexy. And yet, thanks to The New Thing All the Kids Are Into, she actually was thinking that way, which made her feel very strange.

But she pushed those thoughts out of her head and flopped down onto the bed, and turned her head back to look at the other three. “Well? What would you like to do now?” She asked, cracking a smile. “I’d prefer not to be kept waiting!”

Dani cracked a grin. “That’s the spirit,” she said, nodding in approval. “Come on, Nick. …Cinder.” It was her responsibility to take the lead- she couldn’t let Dawn handle everything!

This was her night. And she was going to make the most of it.

Nick glanced over at Cinder. She hadn’t moved from where she was standing, and when their eyes met, she glanced away from him. He was hesitant to go further than that- he knew that this was difficult for her. Should he reach out to her? Or not?

He decided that he should.

“Cinder,” he said, extending his hand out to her. “If you want to join in, then you can. We’re all willing to help you out.”

She bit her lip and balled up her hands into fists. He could see the hesitation in her eyes, even as he noticed the yearning desire, as well. Her emotions were warring with each other, and she clearly didn’t know how to settle the division.

So… he did something that was incredibly risky, and could wind up ruining the whole night, seeing himself having no other choice.

He leaned forward and kissed her.

“Oh?” Dawn raised her eyebrows and her ears stood up.

“Wow, didn’t expect that,” Dani said as she joined the cat girl on the bed. She covered her mouth in surprise.

Mary and Holly stopped clearing off the dining room table. They shared a worried look, but both silently agreed to trust Nick’s judgment.

They trusted his judgment more than he did, anyway.

Cinder herself was probably the most shocked person in the room. Her eyes widened and her whole body froze. Her mouth was hanging open and she let Nick kiss her without fighting back, but even though she loved the feelings going through her body, it was such a shock that she didn’t know what to do about it.

It took a couple of seconds for her brain to catch up to the rest of her body. “H-hey!” She stammered out, pushing back against him. Her cheeks reddened and she wiped her wet lips, struggling to catch her breath. Her body shook and trembled with pleasure and she tried to control herself, but the force of Nick’s kiss, it was just…

“…Ahn…!” She squeaked out, her thighs clenching as she withstood a mini-orgasm.

That was enough of a sign to Nick that he had made the right choice. Cinder very clearly had enjoyed that.

Would she accept it?

He took her by the hand and led her to the bed while she was still dazed from the pleasure of kissing. It was possible that he could keep her under control with more kisses, but he was worried about how she would feel about that when everything settled.

So, he decided that the best course of action was to lead her to the bed, then let her handle whatever she was comfortable with.

Nick guided her to the bed, and as she fell onto the golden mattress, her eyelids fluttered and her sense of awareness returned.

“Wh-what… what did I…” Cinder reached up and brought her fingers to her lips. Memories of the kiss lingered on her body, and she squeaked out another moan.

“Pretty saucy,” Dawn said, trying to encourage her friend and keep her from going overboard and lashing out at Nick. Dani watched her cautiously from her side of the bed, and then glanced up at Nick, hoping he knew what he was doing.

“…I’m fine,” Cinder muttered, shaking her head. She still looked a little dazed, but that was to be expected. Shocks from the collar, alcohol, the pleasure of kissing, it was all overwhelming her so much, and she was doing everything she could to continue maintaining her composure.

She raised her head, and looked up at Nick.

The longing in her eyes relieved him, and he moved down, and joined the three girls on the bed.

Dawn was the first to act. Her hand reached out and wrapped around his wrist, and she used the momentum to pull herself up to his chest. Immediately she leaned in and took a deep breath, getting a good whiff of his pheromones, and a burst of pleasure surged through her body.

“Mmmf… yeah… th-that’s it,” Dawn moaned, biting her lip. “That’s the stuff…”

“You… you can’t be serious,” Cinder muttered in disbelief. “How is… how does that even feel good for you?”

“It’s her transformation,” Dani informed the other girl. “She gets turned on when smelling his pheromones, remember?”

“Mm, oh, yeah,” Dawn said, bobbing her head up and down. Her eyes glazed over and she licked her lips. This was going perfect. She’d received such a great dose from the scent of his collar that she had almost forgotten the purpose of this.

It wasn’t just about her pleasure, it was about Dani, and Cinder, as well. …Oh, and Nick.

She couldn’t forget about him!

Giggling, Dawn flopped backwards, and landed on top of a surprised Dani.

“Hey, whoa!” Dani let out a yelp and almost shoved the other woman off of her out of surprise. “Dawn, what-? What are you doing?” She asked.

Dawn giggled again, and turned to look up at the other woman. “I’m just trying to have a good time, that’s all,” she cooed to her friend. “That’s why you invited me up here, isn’t it? So we could all have a good time together?”

Dani couldn’t exactly deny that. “Well, yeah,” she said, her cheeks turning red. “But, well… I was kind of expecting, um…”

She’d agreed to Dawn’s request because she’d been looking forward to seeing the other girl get played around with and used as a toy by Nick. The idea of such a small, agile girl getting used as a sex toy to please him? It was really arousing.

But, if Dawn wanted to have some fun with her, then she wasn’t going to complain. “Are you interested in girls?” She asked, reaching out a tentative hand and touching Dawn gently on the collarbone. “If so, I might be able… to accommodate that…”

It was awkward, and clumsy, and certainly not the sexiest dirty talk she’d ever come up with before. But it wasn’t exactly her fault. Dawn was cute, but when it came to being sexually desirable, she wasn’t exactly at the top of Dani’s list.

…At the same time, however, she was very interested in seeing how Dawn would respond to her touch. Seeing Dawn’s nod of approval, she moved her hand lower, down to the other girl’s small breast, and gave it a ginger stroke.

Dawn let out a gasp of passion and threw back her head. An even louder moan escaped her lips and she twitched. “Oh! That… that feels so good!” She moaned out.

Cinder squeaked. Her eyes widened in shock and her mouth fell open. Even Nick was surprised by the sudden outburst of pleasure from his lover.

Dani yanked her hand back so fast she almost pulled her shoulder out of its socket. She stared incredulously at Dawn, and raised her eyebrow.

“Whoa,” Mary murmured from the table. “You think that’s her Showing Off transformation in action?” She wondered. She hadn’t been present at the last transformation vote- she had been filled in on the details after the fact.

Holly shook her head. “No, you weren’t there,” she whispered back, unable to hide the gleeful smile on her lips. “The actual text of her transformation is different.”

She pulled up the text of Dawn’s transformation to clarify it for her friend.

• Showing Off: It isn’t enough to just be better at sex than the other girls (which she isn’t) she has to prove it, too. Whenever Dawn is having great sex with the master, she will be compelled to let everyone in earshot know it, losing all filter and being as loud as possible, and loving every minute of it. (Competitive)

“See?” Holly pointed out. “It only compels her to be loud like that when she’s having sex with Nick, not anyone else.”

She raised her voice just loud enough to let everyone on the bed overhear.

Dawn immediately shut her mouth. Her flushed face slowly turned even redder, getting so hot that her glasses almost started to steam up. She averted her eyes and chewed awkwardly on her lip, not sure what to say.

She’d been caught.

“…Dawn, you don’t have to do that,” Dani said, struggling to keep the amused smile off of her lips. “Playing things up, that’s a little…”

“It-it’s not like-!” Dawn wanted to argue, but she couldn’t get her mouth to work properly. Her face continued to burn. “I just thought, um… that… that you would, uh… a-appreciate, me, if-if I, um… …You know.”

“What, if you sounded like you were moaning your brains out at the feeling of a hand on your boob?” Dani crudely asked, laughing out loud. “Come on, that’s flattering, but I’m not that good.”

Dani shook her head. “Besides, if I wanted to make you cum from a touch, there’s an easier way to that,” she continued, reaching up and stroking the cat girl’s ear.

Dawn stiffened up like a statue and her eyes bulged in surprise. She let out a squeak as her legs tightened up, and she squirted a little into her panties.

The pleasure that she got from Dani touching one of her erogenous zones blew what she’d just felt before out of the water.

Dawn pulled away from her and nearly tumbled off the bed. “I-I should get out of these clothes!” She stammered out, hastily stripping herself down. She didn’t care that Cinder and Dani were still dressed, or that Nick was still dressed, she felt like if everybody was looking at her, then at least she could give them something to look at!

And, if she got naked, then maybe they could move things along to a point where she wasn’t the only one doing sexual stuff. Dawn would very much like to get to that point, if she could.

Once Dawn finished stripping, she felt three pairs of eyes on hers.

The pair she noticed first belonged to Nick. She could feel how much he desired her in the way he looked at her, and that made her feel pretty good. A tiny smile touched her lips and she straightened up, presenting herself just a little by leaning forward even if she didn’t have anything up top to catch his eyes.

Cinder was stunned.

How the fuck can she do something like that!? Just… just get naked in front of other people!? Cinder was wearing a maid costume right now, probably the most clothing out of anyone in the room, considering the tight fit of Dani’s outfit. And she still felt underdressed, given how much her clothes had been ruined from her multiple orgasms.

So, for Dawn to just strip down to nothing like it was no big deal at all, and pose for other people to look at her…

Cinder couldn’t imagine ever being comfortable with something like that.

It’s not like she even has anything to show off, anyway! Mean, unfair thoughts seeped into her brain as she looked over Dawn’s petite frame. Even I have bigger breasts than she does. I’m taller, as well! The only thing she has going for her is that her butt is a little bit tighter than mine, and even then, mine’s bigger than hers!

…Wait, what was she doing?

She wasn’t actually comparing herself sexually with another woman, was she? And in such a cutting and venomous way, too?

Cinder could be mean and cruel, but the thoughts flowing through her mind were particularly spiteful and vindictive. It almost felt like she was resentful of Dawn for posing naked in front of Nick! As if the cat girl should be ashamed of showing off to him like that!

If Cinder didn’t know any better, she’d almost think that she was jealous that Dawn was getting attention and she wasn’t, even though she had the objectively better figure. But the second that notion occurred to her, she felt like throwing up in her mouth.

No! I don’t think like that! I don’t care about that sort of thing! She chastised herself. The only reason I’m upset right now is because the idea of ANYONE showing themselves off to him disgusts me, that’s all! It has nothing to do with jealousy!

She just… didn’t understand it. How Dawn could be smiling so widely while he was staring at her. And it confused her just as much why Nick kept staring at her.

If he should be checking out anyone right now, it should have been Dani. Even Cinder could acknowledge that the tomboy was muy caliente. She had wide hips and a rounder butt than Cinder’s, and breasts that made Cinder look as flat as Dawn! Not to mention gorgeous features and soft, silky skin that seemed to glow bronze, unlike her own muddy complexion.

Nick was ignoring all that… to check out some scrawny little nothing? Just because she was showing off to him?

It didn’t compute with her. The logic that Cinder based her worldview off of said that this was an irrational fact of life.

And that was because Cinder fundamentally did not understand Nick, or Dawn, or the relationship that they shared.

Nick didn’t care about the size of Dawn’s breasts. He didn’t compare her body with Dani’s, or with anyone else’s. His feelings towards Dawn and his attraction to her had passed the realm of the physical ages ago, before he had even met Cinder.

Regardless of his fetish for breast expansion, regardless of how much he liked tomboys, he liked Dawn for who she was, and seeing her pose like that, trying to please him and entice him with her slender, fit gymnast’s body was getting him going the same way it would as if she were a tall and buxom brainless bimbo.

That was something Cinder just didn’t understand. Not only did she not understand it, she couldn’t even begin to understand it.

Maybe she would, someday, if she ever managed to understand what it meant to love someone. But right now, trying to suppress her feelings and projecting all of those sappy, romantic urges onto her other self?

Cinder didn’t have a prayer of understanding what it was that Nick found so attractive about the woman who was climbing into bed with him, draping her naked body over his as she sank down into his lap and wrapped her arms around his neck.

“What do you think?” Dawn whispered into his ear. Her tail flicked behind her with excitement and Cinder watched with rapt attention, her intrigue and curiosity overcoming her usual hostility towards sexual congress.

Dawn finished with a throaty purr, “Ready for a fun night?”

“Hey, what’s wrong?” Dani called. “I make you feel good, and no loving for me?”

It was a bit daring on her part, especially considering that things had just taken an awkward turn with Dawn not too long ago. But she still tried her best.

Dani’s heart thumped a little when Dawn slowly dragged her eyes away from Nick and met her gaze.

A sly smile crept up the cat girl’s lips.

“Well, if you insist,” Dawn murmured, getting off of Nick’s lap with an exaggerated reluctance, as if there was nowhere else she would rather be than straddled on top of him. “I suppose I might be able… to accommodate that…”

The playful way that she’d thrown Dani’s own words back at her was also lost on Cinder. She just watched as Dawn crawled right past her, moving around the confused latina to return to Dani’s corner of the bed.

When Dawn climbed into Dani’s lap, Cinder’s mouth actually fell open. She wasn’t sure what she had been expecting, but it definitely wasn’t this.

And yet… she couldn’t take her eyes away.

Dawn leaned in and took a deep whiff of Dani, the same way that she’d done earlier with Nick. Unlike her Showing Off transformation, Like Catnip did work with the other contestants.

And, unlike Nick, Dani hadn’t actually taken a bath after their hike so she had plenty of pheromones baked into her shiny skin.

“Mmmmfff!” Dawn let out a small gasp and smiled. Her transformation would get more arousing the longer she spent in proximity to Dani’s scent, and hopefully there would be plenty of time this evening to get accustomed to it.

After all, Cinder was too stunned by what she was seeing to raise any objections, and Nick and Dani certainly weren’t going to stop her.

Dawn had every right to enjoy herself a little bit, too, didn’t she? Especially if she wouldn’t get a chance to be used as a sex toy tonight.

It was only fair!