The surprise

"Wait right there," she said, disappearing into her bedroom. When she came back, she wasn't alone.

"This is Lily," Mia announced, pulling her friend forward. Both of them wore matching black lace lingerie that barely covered anything. Lily's tits spilled over the cups of her bra, and the thong she wore disappeared between her ass cheeks. "Lily, this is Ethan. He's the one who fucked my throat at the Halloween party while his girlfriend is out of state. He just left his church group."

Lily's eyes lit up as she looked me over. "Is that right? Mia told me all about you."

"I did just came from church group. It was my first time going," I admitted, my cock already straining against my jeans at the sight of both women.

Mia laughed and pressed against me from one side while Lily moved in from the other. "Still trying to be good? That's adorable." Her hand found my crotch again. "But we both know you're not going to say no to this."

Lily's fingers worked my belt open while Mia whispered in my ear. "Your girlfriend Sarah would be so disappointed if she knew you were about to fuck two girls instead of going home to pray."

They stripped me quickly, pushing me onto Mia's bed. Lily crawled between my legs first, taking my cock into her mouth with a hungry moan. Mia straddled my face, lowering her pussy onto my tongue as she reached back to stroke Lily's hair.

"That's it, church boy," Mia said, grinding against my mouth. "Eat my pussy while your new friend sucks your cock."

Lily pulled off my shaft with a wet sound. "He tastes good and his cock is so hard. Does Sarah know how much he loves sluts on his cock?"

"She has no idea," Mia answered for me, her thighs tightening around my head. "She probably thinks he's studying right now."

They switched positions. Lily sat on my face while Mia took my cock deep into her throat. Lily was already wet, her pussy grinding against my tongue as she reached down to play with my balls while Mia sucked me.

"Fuck, he knows how to use his tongue," Lily moaned, rocking her hips. "Sarah's missing out."

Mia pulled off my cock and climbed on top, sinking down onto my length with a satisfied sigh. "God, I've been thinking about this cock for weeks." She started riding me hard, her tits bouncing in that tiny bra. "Tell us how much better we are than Sarah."

"So much better," I groaned against Lily's pussy. "Both of you."

Lily shifted so she could lean forward and kiss Mia while I ate her out. Mia kept bouncing on my cock, her pussy gripping me tight with each thrust. "Sarah probably doesn't even ride you like this, does she?"

"No," I admitted, my hands gripping Mia's hips as she fucked herself on my cock.

They switched again. Lily took my cock while Mia moved to sit on my face. Both of them were vocal, moaning and talking dirty while they used me. Lily rode me reverse cowgirl so Mia could watch my cock disappear into her friend's pussy.

"Look at that," Mia said, reaching down to rub Lily's clit while she bounced on me. "Your girlfriend has no idea you're balls deep in another girl right now."

Lily leaned back against my chest, grinding her hips in circles. "Maybe we should send Sarah a picture. Show her what her boyfriend really likes."

The thought made my cock twitch inside her. Mia noticed and laughed. "Oh, he likes that idea. Maybe Ethan isn't as reformed as he thought."

They kept switching, taking turns on my cock and my face. Lily sucked my cock while Mia rode my tongue. Then Mia took my cock while Lily sat on my face. Both of them kept talking about Sarah, about how disappointed she'd be, about how much better their pussies felt than hers. I felt conflicted. Their comments made my cock twitch with pleasure, but I still had guilt for doing this to Sarah

"Cum inside me," Lily demanded, bouncing harder on my cock. "Fill me up while Mia sits on your face."

I came with a muffled groan, my cock pulsing as I emptied into Lily's pussy. She kept riding me through it, milking every drop while Mia ground against my tongue.

"Good boy," Mia praised, stroking my hair. "Give us a call whenever you feel like sinning again little church boy."

I leave silently