Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by SeniorGooner SeniorGooner

What happens when Rick gets home?

Eve takes over

Just after 11pm, Ethan’s phone lit up again.

Rick: On my way home now, shorty. Been edging this fat cock for you all damn day. Get that pretty PAWG ass ready.

Eve’s excitement buzzed through Ethan like electricity. He should have been asleep already. Susan was already upstairs, door closed, lights out, deep in sleep. The house was dead silent except for the low hum of the fridge. But Eve refused to let him rest. She paced their shared mind, whispering every dirty thing she wanted Rick to do to her.

The moment the front door clicked open upstairs, Eve took over completely.

The transformation hit fast and smooth. Ethan’s body swelled in all the right places — hips widening, ass plumping into thick, heart-shaped perfection, platinum blonde hair cascading down her back, heavy tits and soft curves replacing his lanky frame. Eve stood up in nothing but one of Rick’s old work shirts that Ethan had taken from the laundry room earlier, at Eve's insistence. The hem barely covering the bottom of her fat ass. She was already dripping.

She padded quietly up the basement stairs and met Rick in the dimly lit living room.

Rick’s eyes darkened the second he saw her. For a split second he looked almost charming — a tired but hungry smile tugging at his lips as he locked the door behind him. “There’s my girl,” he murmured, voice low. Then the animal took over.

He crossed the room in two strides, grabbed Eve by the back of the neck, and shoved her down to her knees right there on the living room carpet.

“Open that mouth,” he growled, already unzipping.

Eve obeyed eagerly, lips parting wide. Rick didn’t ease in. He fed her his thick, veiny eleven-inch cock in one long push, stretching her throat until her nose pressed against his pelvis. He held her there, groaning quietly as her throat convulsed around him.

“Fuck yes… that’s it, baby girl. **** on Daddy’s dick. Been thinking about this throat all day.” He started slow at first, long, deep strokes that made her gag and drool instantly. Thick strings of spit ran down her chin and dripped onto her heavy tits. “Look at you… already making a mess like a good little throat slut. You love this, don’t you? Love getting your face fucked while your boyfriend sleeps downstairs in the basement.”

For the next thirty-plus minutes, Rick used her mouth like a toy. He fucked her face with deep, steady strokes, one hand tangled in her platinum hair while the other occasionally slapped her heavy tits or pinched her nipples through the shirt. He pulled out every few minutes just to slap his wet cock across her cheeks and tongue, smearing her own spit everywhere.

“Deeper. All the way. I want to feel your throat squeezing every inch.” He pushed back in, hips rolling lazily. “That’s my good whore. Swallow around it… yeah, just like that. You’re getting better at this already. Gonna train this throat till you can take me balls-deep without even gagging.”

Eve worshipped him sloppily — gagging, drooling, tears streaming down her cheeks as she sucked his heavy balls, licked every vein, and begged with her eyes for more. Rick’s dirty talk never stopped.

“Gonna cum down this throat soon… but not yet. I’m gonna use you till your jaw hurts. You’re just a set of warm holes for me tonight, shorty. My personal cumdump.” He sped up, short, brutal thrusts that made her tits bounce. “Fuck… your mouth feels even better than your pussy sometimes. So wet and sloppy. Keep those pretty blue eyes on me while I ruin your face. Imagine if your boyfriend woke up and came upstairs right now… seeing you on your knees like this, throat bulging around my cock. Bet that loser would cry.”

When he finally came, he buried himself to the hilt and unloaded straight down her throat — thick, heavy ropes that she swallowed greedily, **** and moaning around his pulsing shaft until he was spent. He held her there for a long moment, cock twitching as the last drops leaked out.

“Swallow every drop, slut. Don’t waste it.”

Rick pulled out with a wet pop, still rock-hard, a string of saliva connecting her swollen lips to his cock. He dropped onto the couch, pants around his ankles, and yanked Eve on top of him.

“Ride me. Now.”

She straddled him, lining up her soaked pussy with his massive cock. The first few inches stretched her open beautifully. She sank down slowly, gasping at the familiar fullness, her thick ass settling against his thighs.

Rick gave her maybe two seconds to adjust.

Then he gripped her wide hips with both hands and started slamming her up and down his length like she weighed nothing. The wet, obscene slap of her fat ass against his thighs filled the quiet living room. Eve’s heavy tits bounced wildly under the shirt as he pounded her relentlessly, using her body like a fleshlight.

“Fuck, look at that ass bounce,” Rick groaned, eyes locked on where they were joined. “This pussy is gripping me so tight… you been thinking about this dick all day too, haven’t you? Greedy little PAWG slut.”

Eve’s moans started getting louder. Rick clamped a strong hand over her mouth, muffling her cries. “Quiet. Be a good slut and take this dick without waking anyone. You want your boyfriend coming up from the basement and seeing you getting fucked like a cheap whore on my cock? Bet he’d lose his mind watching you bounce on Daddy’s dick like the slut you are.”

Oh fuck… Eve moaned inside their shared head. The image hit her like lightning — Ethan creeping up the basement stairs, eyes wide with shock, watching his own girlfriend getting brutally used by his step-dad. The humiliation, the risk, the sheer wrongness of it… it turned her on so much her pussy clenched hard around nothing. Yes… let him see. Let him watch how I take this cock…That filthy thought sent her spiraling. Her first orgasm crashed through her without Rick even touching her clit — a sudden, violent wave that made her thighs shake and her pussy gush slick down Rick’s shaft as she rode him.

Rick felt it immediately and laughed darkly, slamming her down harder on his cock. “Already cumming just from the thought? You really are a nasty little slut.”

He fucked her through two shattering orgasms in cowgirl — her pussy clenching and squirting around his cock as her eyes rolled back, body shaking violently in his lap while he kept her mouth covered. Each orgasm made her squirt messily, soaking his balls and the couch cushions beneath them.

Still buried inside her, Rick stood up, lifting Eve effortlessly with him. He carried her to the back of the couch and bent her over it, her thick ass presented perfectly. Keeping his cock deep in her spasming pussy, he reached into a small plastic bag he’d brought home.

“Stopped at the sex shop on my lunch break just for you,” he growled, pulling out a large, thick double-ended dildo and a bottle of lube. “Figured it was time to really wreck both these holes.”

He poured lube generously over her tight asshole, then worked the fat head of the dildo against her lips first, making her gag and slobber on it while he slowly fucked her pussy. “Suck it, whore. Get it nice and wet for your ass.”

After a few minutes of that, he pressed the slick toy against her asshole and started pushing it in.

Eve’s brain nearly melted.

The stretch was obscene — Rick’s thick cock filling her pussy completely while the heavy dildo slid deeper and deeper into her ass. Rick poured even more lube, working the toy in and out until both her holes were stuffed full and stretched wide.

“Fuck yeah… look at you. Double stuffed like a proper slut. Two holes and both of them full. You feel that? My cock in your cunt and this fat toy wrecking your ass at the same time.” He started thrusting harder, alternating between his cock and the dildo. “This is what you were made for, isn’t it? A dumb, cock-hungry PAWG cumdump. Gonna keep you like this every night — stretched and leaking.”

He clamped his hand over her mouth again as she started to cry out. “Shut the fuck up and take it. You don’t get to scream like a porn star. You’re my secret basement whore now. Quiet while I ruin you. Wouldn’t want your boyfriend sneaking up those stairs and seeing his girl getting both holes destroyed at once, would we?”

Eve came hard almost immediately, squirting messily around his cock as her ass clenched rhythmically around the dildo. Rick didn’t stop. He started switching holes — pulling his cock out of her pussy to thrust into her ass while the dildo filled her cunt, then back again, alternating with deep, punishing strokes.

“Pussy… ass… pussy… ass. Feel that, slut? Both holes getting used like cheap fuck toys.” His voice was rough, degrading. “You’re just a set of warm, stretched-out holes for black cock now. Gonna keep switching until you can’t even think straight. Look at you squirting everywhere like a broken faucet. Pathetic… but so fucking hot. Your boyfriend has no idea what a nasty little cumdump you really are.”

He kept going, faster and meaner, the obscene wet sounds of both holes being fucked filling the living room. Eve lost count of how many times she squirted. Her legs shook violently, juices running down her thighs and soaking the couch.

Finally, Rick buried his cock deep in her ass and came with a low, guttural groan — flooding her tight hole with thick, hot cum. Eve came at the same time, another powerful squirt soaking both of them as her holes pulsed and fluttered around the cock and dildo.

Rick stayed buried for a long moment, breathing hard, then slowly pulled out. He gave her ass a firm, stinging slap, watching his cum leak from her stretched, gaping hole.

“Good slut,” he murmured, voice rough with satisfaction. “You need to come around more often. This pussy and ass are too good to waste on your boyfriend."

He tucked himself away, grabbed his bag, and headed quietly upstairs to bed, with Susan none the wiser.

Eve stayed bent over the couch for several minutes, legs trembling, cum slowly dripping from her well-used ass while her own squirt glistened on her thighs and the cushions. Her mind was blissed-out mush.

In their shared headspace, Ethan’s voice was faint, overwhelmed, and more than a little terrified at how much he had felt through her.

Eve just purred contentedly.

See? This is what we were made for.

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)