Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 16 by Nightowl005 Nightowl005

What Happens Next

An Old Friend of Trevor’s Comes Back

Liz remembered the first time she and Rachel had explored. They were clumsy, awkward, unsure of what they were doing, but enjoying it anyway.

Now, Liz had a better idea of what she was doing as she knelt down between Rachel's folds. Rachel blushed, whimpering as Liz smiled, bringing herself closer. God, Rachel was so wet!

Rachel covered her mouth with a hand as Liz started licking. She tasted just like she did before, and she had the same reaction too, her back arching off the bed slightly. Liz chuckled, and she felt Rachel shudder throughout her body.

Soon, they switched places. Liz was surprised when Rachel suddenly pounced on her. Liz could have easily fought back and overpower her, but... damn ****, this is really hot! Rachel grinned, her eyes gleaming as she sank lower, her tongue tracing its way past Liz’s abdomen until it got to her pussy.

Liz had never cried out so loudly before.

---

It was almost half an hour later when Liz left Rachel's house, blushing furiously as the memory of what they'd done together was still fresh in her mind. She checked her phone, not surprised to see Susan has posted in the group chat:

Susan: Yo

You guys come up with a plan?

Rachel: Not yet

Susan: wth were you guys doing after I left?

Liz wasn’t sure whether to laugh or cringe. No way am I going to put that down. She messaged Susan directly, saying she and Rachel simply talked about some personal matters and that they’ll try to come up with a plan tomorrow. She wasn’t surprised when Susan replied with the suspicion emoji. I’ll tell her later. Liz thought with a smile, putting her phone away.

She was content to simply walk back home in silence until she noticed someone walking towards her. Liz blinked, Is that? It was Naomi Walker, someone Liz would have been very happy to avoid and never have to speak to. Guess I’ll just ignore her and hope she doesn’t say anything. That was the plan until Naomi waved to her, God damn it.

Liz stopped walking and fixed Naomi with a glare that could rival even Olivia’s look of disgust. Unfortunately for her, Naomi seemed comfortable with being glared at since all that resulted in was a slight smirk, “I’m not exactly happy to see you, either, Elizabeth.” Naomi greeted.

Liz scoffed, “You didn’t need to say hi then,” she took a breath, promising herself not to let Naomi get to her. She knew that was going to be hard though. “What do you want? Did Olivia finally get sick of your bullshit?”

Naomi smirked, “No, and between you and me, I think she’d get sick of Wren first, but that’s neither here nor there. I have something important I need to tell you actually.”

Liz rolled her eyes, “What?”

“I’m sure you heard of the… incidents that happened today in the girls bathroom.”

Liz always thought she had a good poker face, usually not many things could get her to break it. Unfortunately, more and more things from the past few weeks have shown her things she otherwise wouldn't have thought possible. Naomi grinned, covering a chuckle with her hand. Whatever, just laugh it up. “I have,” Liz replied slowly, “are you…” she managed to regain her fire and stepped forward, “you have anything to do with it?”

Naomi choked back a laugh, “Oh please, no. But I know Rachel knew it was Trevor, although I’m not sure if she was able to tell you that.”

“Of course she did, why wouldn’t she?”

Naomi’s smile faltered, and for a moment, Liz saw something flash behind her eyes, Naomi’s smug expression softened, but it was still there, “Because… that’s not Rachel.”

Liz’s heart stopped. “What do you mean?”

"I was there,” Naomi explained, “I had been following Trevor as much as I could. I saw him possess her, and trap her in her body while he stayed in control.”

This has to be a sick joke… Liz swallowed, losing some of the strength in her legs. No way this can be real. “P-prove it!” Liz challenged, she’s just trying to mess with me.

Naomi frowned, and sighed, “Think about it? Did Rachel seem off in any way to you? Maybe she was more flirty? More touchy? I can’t imagine Trevor was great at pretending to be her and I doubt he wouldn’t go too long without getting naked at least once.”

Does Elizabeth Believe Naomi?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)