I chose Sarah

I took a deep breath. She was the love of my life. She was everything I could ever dream of. She made me so happy. Despite that new lustful lifestyle (well, new for me), I couldn't help but choose Sarah.

I slowly closed the gap between us, to the excitement of the trio. My heart was beating so fast in my chest it even hurt. I was sealing a way of life I could never share with anyone, one I had never even considered, but which was keeping my cock so hard.

The twins got closer to me, and like fairy godmothers, they swiftly took off any remaining piece of clothing from my body, then they sat next to Sarah. I gently grabbed my girlfriend's knees, as she was keeping her legs up and spread for me. It was such a gorgeous sight, as Sarah was smiling the sweetest I'd ever seen her. Her large breasts slowly raised and lowered as she breathed with anticipation, sending a slight jiggle down her whole body. She was perfect.

I felt an intense heat from her crotch. Her pussy was still leaking her cousin's semen, and it looked... Intriguing. I moved my hips closer to her. Despite the difference in size between my dick and her cousins', I didn't have any trouble finding her hole. It was like some weird magnetism pulling me towards her insides. The moment our bodies touched, we both moaned, and we did again once I slid my cock inside her.

It was glory. She was incredibly hot and unbelievably slimy. I pushed my cock, bathing it in her pussy juice and her cousin's semen. I leaned forward over her, and she received me so lovingly with a hug, a sweet kiss, and a leg lock.

"I love you, Liam. Nothing can change that." She said.

"I love you too, Sarah. Yeah... Nothing can change that either."

We kissed more passionately as I pushed as deep as I could. I could feel the mess the futa's cum was making between and under us. I could feel Sarah's large breasts pressing against my chest. I could feel her whole body vibrating.

I had been dreaming of our first time for so long. I had imagined it would be a romantic and intimate moment, only the two of us and the bed. Instead, I'm losing my virginity in front of my girlfriend's cousins —who had just started jerking off —, with a sloppy second on my girlfriend, who's full of their seed already. However, I realized that didn't mean it was not romantic. Sarah loved her cousins, yeah, it was a kinda twisted, forbidden incestuous love, but love nonetheless. And we were declaring our love for each other. Yeah. It could be romantic, despite the lewdness.

I started going faster, and she moaned louder into my mouth. She broke the kiss to start whispering.

"Liam... I also have to confess I've been a little naughty..."

"Oh, I know."

"No, I mean... I've been with... Other futas."

"What?" That caught me off guard, but her legs kept me in place. "With who??"

"Remember the club? And the wristband?"

"The horseshoe wristband?"

"It's not a horseshoe, dummy, it's a C!" Katia said, smirking. "C for Cuckold!"

"What? What does that mean??"

"Men are only allowed to go in" Brenda explained "uhm... If they agree to... Share their girlfriends or wives..."

"What?? So that means that... While I was dancing...?"

Sarah nodded with a slightly ashamed, but very playful smile.

"I was getting fucked by futas upstairs..."

"No! Fuck!"

Maybe it was just the situation, but I couldn't control my cock: it got harder and harder, and my hips moved faster and faster.

"You like that, right? Gosh, Liam, you're so hard, yes!!"

"I... I don't know... Fuck... Did the whole club take turns on you??"

"Yes! Probably! I had so many loads inside me I felt I was gonna explode! I came so many times! It was the best night out, thanks to you!!"

Now I understood why the ladies were all so friendly when they saw my wristband, and why Katia had led her upstairs when the bathrooms were downstairs. I got upset. Angry. Frustrated. And I channeled all that into harder thrusts against Sarah. If I had been told two days ago I'd be getting so hard just to know my girlfriend had been a slut, I wouldn't have believed it. I couldn't believe it right there and then. I couldn't believe how much I was liking it.

"Liam! Oh, Liam, yes!" Sarah screamed in pleasure. "Fuck me! Fuck me like all those futas did! Love me like my cousins do! Make me cum, please!!"

I couldn't hold it any longer. I had the best orgasm ever as Sarah shivered and arched her back and screamed my name. I held her close to me as I released a couple more ropes of jizz inside her. Yeah, it was an insignificant load compared to her cousin's, but it was as meaningful. I hope so, at least. We remained together for long, kissing, pressing our bodies together.

"Don't worry..." She said after a while. "I'll always be yours, no matter how many futacocks I ride."

"I believe you" I said.

Was I being incredibly gullible? Was I accepting a cuckold life that easily? Was I agreeing to her doing it with her own cousins? I didn't really know for sure. I only knew I had the best time in my life.

Then I just passed out, incredibly tired.