Chapter 202
by
Samus1001
What's next?
The Game part 3
"Holly!"
"Oh shit!" Holly exclaimed. She looked extremely nervous as she walked to the center of the room. She clutched her robe and said, "I... I don't know what to do. I can't think of anything."
Katie stood and rushed to her saying, "I'll help her. When you get to my name just draw again. Let me see what you've got on Holly, and I'll think of something."
Katie peeked inside her robe and said, "OH! Okay. I got it."
Katie stepped out of her own robe and dropped it at her feet. She was wearing a parody of a softball uniform. A tiny blue skirt that barely covered her butt and a low cut jersey that showed all her cleavage and barely covered her nipples. Knee high socks and softball cleats finished the look.
She moved behind Holly and kissed her neck as she opened Holly's robe and let it puddle on the ground at their feet. Holly wore a baby blue crotchless lace teddy with a corseted top. Katie pushed her toward Caleb and said, "Master, Holly has fulfilled the requirements to join the harem a day earlier than you asked. It's time you claim her."
Kathy wanted to jump up and protest, Cora was the one being claimed tonight. But as she began to rise to her feet, Cora pulled her back down.
Kathy gave her a puzzled look and Cora said, "Give this to her. She's waited long enough, and she's earned it Kat. I can wait another day if I have to. I've barely been with any of the harem women. It's not fair to make her wait and jump me to the front of the line."
Cora hadn't spoken softly, and most of the harem heard her. They all knew she was supposed to be claimed tonight. Caleb smiled at Cora and rose to his feet. He walked around Holly as if inspecting her. As he passed around behind her he lifted Katie's skirt and said, "Lose the panties."
Katie's panties got tangled in her shoes briefly, but she managed to get them off and kicked them across the floor. Caleb pulled them back toward his seat and pushed Katie down onto it. "On your knees Holly. You're going to eat her pussy before I claim you. She's going to be your roommate, and your girlfriend."
Katie slid down the couch until her ass was hanging off of it. Holly hurried between her legs and kissed her thighs as Katie spread her pussy lips and tapped her clit, a silent instruction for her new girlfriend. Holly replaced Katie's fingers with her tongue. Katie let out a soft moan as Holly licked and sucked her orgasm button.
Caleb didn't waste any time. He got down on his knees and lined his cock up with Holly's dewy flower. Holly shouted, "Holy fuck!" as Caleb began to ease his cock inside her.
He pushed her head back down and said, "If Katie doesn't cum before I do, you'll have to wait even longer before I claim you. I suggest you use your fingers too. Katie has a very sensitive G-spot."
Holly's concentration was completely broken as she tried to lick the clit in front of her. As Caleb's bat worked its way into her, she was already on the verge of her own orgasm from the hot action she'd already watched that evening. She dug two fingers into Katie's snatch, but had no idea how to find a G-spot. When the softball team had sex they usually used their tongues or vibrators, strap-ons, and dildos.
Katie came to her rescue by guiding her, "A little deeper babe. Yeah, that's good. Now rub right there. Up and down just like that... Oooohhhh YEAH! Now lick my clit side to side. MMMPH!"
Caleb chuckled as he pressed his cock deeper into Holly on each thrust. She had a nice tight pussy, tighter than most of the harem. Thanks to what the other girls had already done to him, he knew he was already close. The short breaks in between sessions helped a lot though. He kept his pace slow, keeping Holly right on the edge. He wanted to give her a chance, but he also wanted to paint her face and tits white, and he couldn't do that in the doggie position.
He glanced over at Brandy and almost burst out laughing. Not only were her jeans soaked with her juices, she was beginning to leave a spot on the couch. She shifted and whimpered as her eyes watched his cock disappear into Holly. He called out, "Hey Kat. I think it's time we added Brandy's name to the bag, don't you? The poor girl looks like she's going to have an aneurism."
Brandy's eyes grew wide and she shouted, "Oh FUCK!" as an orgasm rocketed through her. Her already ruined jeans got noticeably wetter. She twitched and shuddered as she finally got the release she craved. Her orgasm set off Katie's. The busty teacher grabbed Holly's hair and squealed in joy. Her pussy clamped down on Holly's fingers as her juices splashed out onto her hand.
Kathy got off her couch and asked Chloe for a spare robe. She walked over to Brandy and looked down on her as Brandy continued to shudder through her orgasm. Kathy was so very proud of Caleb, he hadn't even touched Brandy and he made her cum so hard she squirted in her jeans. Kathy's own juices were running down her legs, but she was used to that by now. No woman stayed dry around her King.
When Brandy had finally stopped twitching, Kathy said, "Come on sis. Let's get you cleaned up a bit."
Kathy helped Brandy to her feet and guided her to the closest bathroom. Once inside she said, "We don't really have time for you to change into any lingerie, so you'll have to play our game naked. Don't worry about cleaning up too much, just rinse off. You'll just get wet all over again."
As Brandy shed her clothes she panted, "How do you live like this? Being near him all the time. I think I might go insane."
Kathy laughed and said, "Honestly, you get used to it. It will get better once he's claimed you. Right now, your body is screaming for his cock, but once you've had it a couple of times, and your body knows you'll get it again, you'll calm down."
Brandy got under the spray of the shower and said, "I don't think I can Kat. I don't think I can stay here. I've never felt so attracted to a man before. It's... It's like I need him inside me or I'll die."
Kathy smiled and said, "That's my fault. One of the powers of a Harem Queen. I want him to claim you. That's why I wanted you to sit next to him during our game. You'll feel compelled to be with him until he does. You can't escape it sis."
Brandy turned the water off and said, "You... You want me to be with him? You... You want all of us to be with him..."
Kathy held a towel out to her sister and said, "That's right. I thought about introducing him to some of our aunts and cousins, but none of them are as beautiful or busty as Mom and my sexy sisters. They aren't really Caleb worthy like you are. It wouldn't be fair to the rest of the harem either. Gabbie has an older sister that we haven't met yet. And there are a bunch of other family members of the harem that he might want to claim. My girlfriend Chris's mom is a very nice woman, she's pretty and has a nice body too. He should at least give her a stretch and breed her, even if he doesn't claim her. She's married and her husband is a very nice man, so he probably won't."
"How many women will you let him claim? How big of a harem is too big?" Brandy asked as she finished drying herself.
Kathy cocked her head to the side and wondered aloud, "You know, I haven't really thought of that. As big as he likes I suppose. He says the harem is almost too big now, but I don't believe that. There are a ton of women out there that would be perfect for him. Although, I hope he keeps it under a hundred. If he fucks three or four of us per day we should all get him at least once a month. Then again, he has his duties to perform... Maybe I should ask him to keep it under fifty? Of course, if the harem gets that big, we'll need a bigger house... or maybe we could put king size bunk beds in the harem wing rooms. Then we'd still have the family wing to put the children in. But then he would be limited on how many children he could have at a time. I don't like that at all. A bigger house may be the only solution. Thank you Brandy. You've given me some things to think about."
She opened the bathroom door, knowing that Chloe would be outside waiting with a robe. She passed it to Brandy and said, "Come on. We're missing all the fun."
Kathy squealing in glee when they reentered. Holly was a beautiful cum covered mess. Kathy didn't need the normality that made women love to be covered in Caleb's cum to want it herself, and she loved to see others that way as well. Hazel, Tina, April, June, Amelia, Katie, and Linda were licking the cum off of her and sharing it in cum kisses. She sat back down next to Cora, with Brandy sitting on her other side. "What did I miss?" she asked.
Mary answered, "Caleb had Holly sit on Katie's lap so he could alternate between their pussies. He really fucked them hard after he asked Holly to join the harem. Her duties are to love everyone of course, but she is also to help Katie teach our children about sports and exercise. He didn't breed her obviously, but he decided that anyone that had already had their turn got to lick up all the cum. He drew Heather and Lu's names and here we are. I started their timer for you."
Kathy looked over at Caleb. Heather and Lu were cleaning Caleb up. Heather swallowed the cum in her mouth. She looked up at Caleb from her position on her knees between his legs and said, "Master, would you think about taking Lu as a pet? I really like her and she would make a good roommate for me."
Caleb was scritching Lu behind her ear as she swirled her tongue around his cock head. Her tail tip twitched back and forth and she was purring loudly. He asked, "Would you like that Lu? Would you join the family as one of our pets?"
She swallowed the cum she had licked up. Her enthusiasm was obvious as she said, "I would love to, Your Holiness. Your family and harem are so much better than the others I've worked for. This place is a paradise in comparison. Please, I'd love to raise my hukittens here."
He had forgotten that he had bred her before the normality that made her a hucat. And April would give birth to hupuppies. The timer went off just then, but he held up is hand as he said, "I already have April and Heather as my pets, and Kathy has Amanda and Melissa. Who would you chose to be responsible for you? Whose pet would you like to be?"
Lu looked around the room. Any of the harem women would make a good owner. She had a hard time deciding. Mary would be great to help her raise her babies. She was already lactating so she could breastfeed when Lu was on duty. Sonia or June were also good choices. They were both pregnant and their milk would come in around the time her babies were born. The fact that Sonia was a priestess of their religion was another plus. But June was a Holy Mother, and an excellent mother herself, while Sonia was pregnant with her first child.
Amelia finished her cum kiss with Holly and announced, "I'll take her. Heather is my daughter now, so it's only right that I take responsibility for Lu too. Would that be acceptable for you Lu?"
Lu grinned and Heather shouted, "That's perfect Mom! Lu, now we're like sisters!"
The two embraced and kissed. Caleb laughed as they forgot his cock. He told them, "Go on. Go play with the others. Once you've all finished licking Holly clean, you can play amongst yourselves."
Heather began to tug Lu towards the women on the other side of the room, but Caleb grabbed Lu's hand-paw and said, "Hold on a second Lu. I just had a thought."
Lu couldn't keep the grin off her face as she said, "Yes, Your Holiness?"
Caleb smiled at her, but his tone was neutral as he said. "You'll still be one of our maids, but you're also a Lotus Sister, and officially they are bodyguards. So, I have another job for you. Whenever me and Kat are apart, you are going to be her personal bodyguard. Whenever she leaves the mansion, and she isn't with me, you go where she goes. I want someone I trust keeping her safe, and as a member of this family, that's now your job."
He looked over at April as he said, "That includes the school. I don't give a damn about their rules that don't allow armed guards on campus." He turned back to Lu and asked, "You'll do that for me?"
Lu felt her chest swell with pride at the level of trust he was placing her in. She knelt before him and swore an oath. "Yes, Your Holiness. I swear to all the Gods and Goddesses, before any harm comes to our Queen, I will already be dead, a bloody puddle on the floor."
Caleb pulled her close and kissed her on the nose. "Just remember you've got a baby inside you. Don't do anything that would get your little one hurt. Okay, now you can go play."
Heather couldn't yank her over to the other ladies fast enough.
He looked around for the bag and noticed it had been moved. Chloe said, "Your Holiness, I took the liberty of adding Brandy's name to the contents."
"Thank you, Chloe," he responded.
He reached inside and rummaged around before removing the next name. "This one is Katie's. I'll try again."
He went back for another, read it, and laughed out loud. "Kathy, Mary, and Cora!"
Cora was suddenly very nervous. Caleb's cock was the biggest she had ever seen, much bigger than she had ever had inside her. She realized that Kathy was pulling her hand to get her to stand. Mary held her other hand and rubbed it to settle her nerves.
They guided Cora to the center of the room. It did not help her nerves that the girls that had been playing with Holly had stopped to watch. She covered her face in embarrassment but Mary tugged on them and whispered, "It's okay baby. There is nothing to be afraid of. Soon you will be one of us. A member of the harem, and carrying our lover's child."
As Mary gently eased Cora's hands back by her sides Kathy announced, "My love. I present to you my sister Cora. She is the perfect addition to your harem. I know she will love you as much as I do. She will love the rest of your harem as well. Come and claim her as yours."
Mary pulled Cora's robe off and Caleb grinned at the sight. The corset she was wearing was cinched tight, giving her an exceptional hourglass figure. Her enormous tits sat on a shelf at the top of the corset, her large hard nipples begging to be chewed and sucked. Attached to the garters at the bottom of the corset were black thigh high fishnet stockings, making her legs look fantastic. He could see rivulets of dew running down her thighs. As nervous as she appeared, she was obviously horny and needed to be fucked. Her thighs were not as thick as Mary's, and her boobs were a little smaller than Kathy's, but she looked perfect. The family resemblance was obvious. Mary looked more like an older sister rather than the mother of these two gorgeous women.
Kathy and Mary dropped their robes next. Kathy was wearing a sheer black negligee while Mary wore the same design in red. Both colors looked great against their alabaster skin. He loved the sight of the veins upon their breasts, letting him know they were working tirelessly to produce the delicious milk he had grown so fond of.
He advanced on Cora. She was shaking like a leaf, she was so nervous. She jumped when his hard cock poked her in the belly. He caressed her cheek and said, "You look absolutely perfect. Are you ready to become mine?"
She opened her mouth but no words came out. Instead she nodded her head. Kathy and Mary went to their knees, attempting to pull Cora with them to give Caleb a triple blowjob. He held her up and said, "No. I want to taste you before I claim you. Lay down right here. Don't look at the others. Close your eyes if you need to, but you'll cum on my tongue before you get to cum on my cock."
He lay her down in the center of the room. As he got down on the floor he had to adjust his cock, it poked the carpet as he lay before Cora's spreading flower.
Cora shouted, "EEEPP!! as his tongue licked her honey hole. She tasted like a strawberries and cream milkshake. He knew that the harem sometimes used favored lubes with each other, but this was the first time he had tasted one. They didn't need lube with him, and he wondered why Cora had used it. He wasn't going to complain. She was delicious.
"Mary, feed your daughter while I eat her. Kathy, hold her legs open for me."
He licked around her labia as Mary's nipple entered Cora's mouth. Her squeaks became muffled and soon stopped as she drank her mother's milk. Caleb was slightly regretting the normality that made him an expert pussy licker. Cora was delicious and already near orgasm. When he went to focus on her clit her legs slammed shut, trapping his head, but they did not prevent him from continuing to lick her orgasm button. She went off like a firecracker, her hips jumping up and down, taking his head with them. He felt the strain in his neck, and stopped licking long enough for her orgasm to cease and Kathy to pry her legs open.
"I'm sorry my love. She's stronger than I expected."
He laughed and said, "Sit on her belly and hold her legs that way. I wanna make her cum again. She tastes every bit as good as you do."
Kathy felt her heart flutter, proud that her sister's pussy had impressed her lover. She leaned over to try and watch him, her boobs coming to rest on Caleb's head. Her view was completely blocked by her own bountiful breasts so she looked around the room. She caught Brandy with a hand in her robe and grinned. Brandy blushed but did not stop her fingers from flying over her kitty.
She looked over at Chris, who was also masturbating to the scene before her. Cora started bucking again and Kathy struggled to keep her legs open. "Chris my love... could you... help my... sister Brandy... please..."
Chris walked over to Kathy and kissed her saying, "Of course babe, but I want you before the night is out. Eventually I'm going to want all three Daniels sisters in my bed at the same time."
Mary overheard and said, "Don't forget their mother, Chris. I'd love to take turns on you with my daughters."
As Chris walked away she said, "I'd love that Mommy."
Cora had stopped struggling while they spoke. Kathy watched her girlfriend drop to her knees in front of Brandy and pull her hand away from her kitty, replacing it with her head. Then her vision was cut off by Caleb as he leaned in to kiss her and give her a taste of Cora's honey. She could smell and taste the clit sensitizing gel on his lips and tongue. The strawberries and cream flavor was her mother's favorite, and Kathy had grown very fond of it as well.
Caleb said, "Go ahead and let her go, Kat. I'm going to fuck her now."
Kathy moved off of Cora as Caleb lined his cock up. Kathy said, "Wait! Let me do that. Please my love. I want to be the one to guide you into her."
Mary also moved out of the way. Cora had a blissed out expression on her face and she moaned as Kathy pulled Caleb's cock into Cora's slit. Kathy lay to Cora's side and held one of her legs as Caleb worked his huge cock into her. "Mom, hold Cora's other leg. We will never get another chance to be a part of Cora losing her virginity."
Cora moaned and laughed at the same time, "Kat, I'm not a virgin."
Kathy kissed the side of her sister's huge tit and said, "Yes, you are. No other cock could ever do to you what is happening now. You will never want another man inside you, and all the ones you've been with before will pale in comparison to our master."
"Fuck her my love. Fuck her, claim her, and breed her," Kathy said.
Once again Caleb felt the joy of stretching a woman on his cock for the first time. She was tight, very tight. Her pussy gripped him like a vice as he worked his way inside her. When he reached her cervix the suction on his cockhead was amazing, every bit as strong as Kathy's the morning her bred her, but Cora's velvety tunnel pulsed rhythmically. Cora certainly wanted to be bred.
Caleb ran his hands along Cora's body, feeling her as he took a closer look than he ever had before. Cora was thicker in the middle than Kathy, but not by much. As he pushed her womb back and rearranged her guts he wasn't surprised that she did not develop the belly bulge that Kathy loved.
Her tits didn't sag nearly as much as Kathy's had before he cum covered them. But he remembered Kathy saying that Cora's mammoth tits grew slower, over the course of half a dozen years. He leaned down and bit one of her fat nipples. He loved fat nipples and the Daniels women all had them.
Cora's pussy clamped down on his shaft, making him struggle to keep fucking her. She began to buck her hips in what he figured had to be something genetic with her family since they all came the same way. Then her pussy began to spasm, getting even tighter, her hip thrusts more violent.
Cora cried out, "Caleb! Ah! Take me! Make me yours! I already love you! I can't get you out of my head! PLEASE!"
Even though he had cum recently, the suction of her cervix and tightness of her grasping pussy were rapidly bringing on his own ejaculation. He slowed his pace a bit to prolong the exquisite sensations. Lifting up a bit he looked down at the mother and daughters. Cora slumped back to the floor, a blissed out look upon her face. Kathy and Mary smiled up at him, snuggled into Cora's sides.
Their love for him was clear on all three faces. Mary had emulated her daughter and was cuddled up on the other side of Cora, holding her leg spread. Three gigantic sets of tits smashed against each other was a sight to behold.
He moaned, "FUCK!" The sight of these beautiful women staring up at him was too much. "Cora! I'm claiming you as mine. You will never be with another man. I will breed you and love you, and you will love me and my harem. When I marry your sister, you will take her place as my girlfriend. You will belong to me forever. Do you accept?"
He felt his cum racing up his shaft as her cunt clamped down on him. Cora screamed out, "YES!" as a new orgasm exploded inside her.
The pressure of her spasming cunt was intense, the tightness of her fuck tunnel actually slowing the speed of his cum. She jerked as the first blast hit her sucking cervix. He cried out as the next two left his cock. He struggled to pull himself out, but her pussy did not want to let him go. He tried again, needing to complete her transformation.
His cock sprayed like a firehose as he finally freed it from her griping snatch. Mary and Kathy giggled as cum rained down upon them. Cora was too far gone into her orgasm to notice. He scrambled up her body as Kathy and Mary rolled out of the way. They knew what he needed to do next and did not impede him. He jammed his cock into Cora's mouth and filled it with cum. She coughed but swallowed what she could as Caleb turned and sprayed her tits. Mary was already there ready to rub it in even as they began to swell, indicating that Cora was now pregnant. Kathy grabbed Caleb's cock and stroked it to get every bit of cum out that she could.
When his emissions slowed to a dribble Kathy took him into her mouth. She sucked hard to get everything she could out of his tube as her tongue bathed him. She eased him out of the way when she went to cum kiss her sister, tears of joy in her eyes.
Their tongues swirled his cum around and their lips popped as Kathy pulled away. "Oh Cora! I'm so happy for you. I didn't know he was going to make you his next girlfriend. That's perfect. You're perfect for him."
Cora smiled brightly but asked, "What about Brandy? I don't want her to feel left out. She needs to feel special too."
Caleb looked over at Brandy. Chris had stopped eating her out so she could watch Caleb bath Cora in cum. Brandy lay back with a blissed out expression on her face. Her robe was undone, completely exposing her body. She had the smallest breasts of the Daniels women, even before he bred them, but nice thick thighs like her mom, and a plump butt like Kathy.
He grinned and said, "Well, I could always take her as my mistress."
Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001
What's next?
The Normality Dial
Changing reality with a word
This story is based off a branch of Murakami's Normality found here. https://chyoa.com/chapter/Introduction.174576 In this story, our hero Caleb Anders, finds a watch that allows him to change reality, with certain rules based on the time the watch is set at. A special thanks to BiBiComte and CrossC for allowing me to reprint their own chapters here. I have credited them for each of their chapters at the start of those chapters. I may have made a few minor changes and grammatical corrections, though I am by no means perfect myself.
Updated on Jun 11, 2026
by Samus1001
Created on Jul 20, 2025
by Samus1001
- All Comments
- Chapter Comments

