Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 99 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

A Climactic Climax

Victoria and Lottie continued to pass Caleb’s cock back and forth as they licked and sucked him off. Over by the loveseat, Kathy had her head between Amelia’s legs. Kathy’s ass was in the air and he could see her rubbing her clit as her flower winked at him, almost as if it were begging for his attention.

His mother was laying on her back, an arm behind her head, as if she were asleep. She had a cute smile on her face as the juices of both Amelia and Kathy dried upon it. From what he could see between her slightly spread legs, his mother's poor abused pussy was swollen and red.

In the middle of the room Sonia was still raring to go. She was watching him receive the double blowjob as she played with her pussy. Meanwhile Evelin was nearly comatose. Her body lay twitching from her last orgasm.

He chuckled to himself as Victoria and Lottie French kissed around his cock head. He might have overdone it with the pleasure increase normalities.

Evelin would just have to come back another time. He wasn’t going to impregnate her when she was too out of it to enjoy it.

He looked back over at Sonia and said, “Would you come play with Vickie for me?”

Sonia crawled over to them and slid her head between Victoria’s legs. Sonia gripped her around the waist and pulled Victoria's pussy down to meet her tongue. Caleb backed his dick away from the two cocksuckers. They released him and began to kiss as Sonia snacked on Vickie's creamy pussy.

He patted Lottie to get her attention and said, “Come on, I wanna see something.”

He led Lottie over to Kathy, got down on his knees and slid his cock inside her juicy honey hole. Kathy’s head shot up off Amelia’s crotch as she screamed, “Oh God Yes!”

She had been on the verge of an orgasm already and Caleb sliding into her set her off like an explosive.

Amelia lifted her head and said, “Oh thank god, my poor kitty needs a rest. Kathy is insatiable. She already bout killed your mom."

Amelia scooted out of the way and lay next to June. As Kathy came down from her orgasm she said to Amelia, “Awww. Poor little kitty. That’s what you and Mommy get for stealing me away from this fantastic cock. Fuck my pussy Caleb, make me beg for mercy.”

He pulled his cock out of her instead. When she whined, he growled, “That’s what you get for letting them take you away. Don’t forget who you belong to.”

She spun around and begged, “I’m sorry, it’ll never happen again. Please fuck me. Pretty please with sugar on top.”

He couldn't keep pretending to be mad. Instead he grinned, “I’ve got a better idea. I wanna see your tits mashed up against Lottie’s so I can fuck both of them at the same time.”

“Oh, I like that idea. But you are fucking me before the nights out, mister. That cock belongs to your harem. You can fuck all the women you like, as long as you remember it belongs in us." Kathy's cheery tone turned gruff as she made her demand, though the smile on her face cut away the harshness. Caleb chuckled as Kathy knee walked around to Lottie, who was already hefting her breasts in anticipation.

The two women mashed their tits together, and to Caleb it was a beautiful sight. Any single breast was bigger than either of their heads. Seeing four of the gigantic knockers pressed together made his dick hard enough to pound a hole through concrete.

Still slick from Kathy’s pussy, and the double blowjob, he easily slid his cock in between their chest pillows. The two women hugged each other tightly and kissed as he slid his cock between them.

The sensation of ultimate softness on his cock was wonderful. He could tell Kathy’s breasts were the firmer of the two, but the contrast made the double titty fuck even better. It was like having his dick between a pair of giant light pink marshmallows and two big black foam pillows.

He took his time and fucked their fun bags slowly, angling his cock upwards so that the head popped out on each thrust. Both ladies began to lick and suck on his cockhead, as if it were a melting ice cream cone.

He wanted both of them to orgasm from the normality that caused their nipples and clits to feel stimulated whenever his cock was licked or sucked. He wondered if they would notice, not knowing that the normality he created had affected the past. Kathy's memories of the night she gave him her first blowjob were now considerably different from his own. She remembered being in the middle of a massive orgasm when he covered her in his cum. All of the women that had sucked his cock experienced a similar changed reality.

He listened as their ecstasy slowly grew in volume. He smiled when Kathy moaned between licks, “Oh god... Your cock feels... so good... against my titties... You’re making... my nipples tingle... It’s sending shivers... all the way down to my clit... Fuck... I’m... gonna... ah shit... gonna cum!!!”

Lottie exclaimed, “Me too! Cum with me Kathy!”

Lottie dug her hand into her crotch and rammed four fingers into her quim as her body once again erupted. She released Kathy and the two fell away from his cock in mutual bliss.

He was close to his own eruption so he looked around the room for the best place to finish himself off. Amelia was cuddled up to his mother, both appearing either asleep, or resting with their eyes closed.

Victoria and Sonia were also cuddled together but they were softly kissing. Sonia had a hand on Victoria's boob, gently kneading it, while Victoria ran her hand up and down Sonia's huge ass cheek.

Finally he spotted Evelin. She had come out of her orgasmic stupor, fingering herself while awaiting her turn.

As he approached her he said, “Looks like you won’t be going home with an empty womb after all.”

She smiled up at him, timidly laughed and said, “I never in my life thought I would say this but, please put your cock in me."

Caleb positioned himself over her and said, “Since you said please, I guess I must oblige. But I should warn you, I’m already pretty close to cumming. Kathy and Lottie almost had me there. If they hadn't cum first, I would have covered them in baby batter."

Evelin smirked, "Yeah, that's an odd thing about you Anders men. Your mother warned us about what happens to women that give you or your dad blowjobs."

Caleb frowned in confusion at her words. He thought back to how he worded that normality, not realizing the watch was set to affect the past. He was even more confused to learn that blowing his dad had the same effect.

Evelin saw his frown and misunderstood his reasoning. "Oh that's funny. You didn't know. Your mother said that when she gives you or your father a blowjob, it's like her nipples and clit are stimulated, as if they were being licked. Apparently it happens to all women that suck you off."

Caleb was still confused when Evelin impatiently said, "Not that I'll ever know. Sucking cock isn't what I came here to do."

He shook his head to clear his thoughts. "Sorry. I... didn't expect you to. Sorry."

She grabbed his cock and pulled his tip into her tight little kitty, “That’s ok Mr. Stretcher King. I only need your dick for one thing. If the stories are true, I’ll cum when you do anyways.”

He pushed himself inside. She was tight but he’d had tighter. As he started sliding in and out he could tell she was not feeling much pleasure. His belief that she was a lesbian may in fact be true. With the pleasure increase normality he created, she should be feeling something at least. “You know, this isn’t a business transaction. You can enjoy it if you try.”

She smiled up at him as he continued to plunge his cock deep inside her, “It’s nothing against you, I’m just not attracted to men. Or real penises for that matter.”

He said, “Wow, thanks for giving my ego a reality check. But then, that could be a problem. If you’re not enjoying it, then you may not experience the spontaneous orgasm and ovulation that occurs when I cum in you.”

“Crap, well that sucks. But what can we do? I really want to get pregnant. It’s not like I can just stop being gay.”

Caleb thought of the night he added Chris to his harem. She must not have been a complete lesbian when we had sex, since she orgasmed pretty easily. Then again, Kat was right there with us. And it is Kat that Chris really wanted. If not for Kat, I'd never have gotten Chris in my harem.

He looked around the room. It seemed Kathy had finally had enough for now. She was laying beside Lottie, slowly stroking Lottie's slit, but seemed in no shape to help. Lottie had Kathy's nipple in her mouth, but she too seemed orgasmed out.

Amelia and his mom were still cuddled up together, both appeared to be asleep. Looking over to the couch he spotted the answer to Evelin's problem. Victoria lay on her side with a goofy grin on her face. But Sonia was watching him, the fingers of one hand pinching a nipple, while her other hand was between her legs strumming her clit.

He called Sonia over and explained the problem.

“So what I need you to do is distract her. Kiss her, whisper sweet nothings, whatever you want. Just help her forget a guy is fucking her.”

Sonia agreed to try, but Evelin said, “I’m not sure that will help.”

Caleb told her, “Trust me. It will. Sonia is a priestess of the Sisterhood. She is the perfect woman to help us. Aiding a Stretcher King in performing his duties is exactly what the Sisterhood is meant to do.”

He looked over and ordered, “Sonia get over top of her. Don’t even let her see me. I want you to pretend you’re the one fucking her. When I thrust, you thrust. Try to stay with the rhythm. I’ll hold your hips and try to guide you.”

He started out slow but he could already tell it was going to be awkward as hell. His cock was at a terrible angle, with him practically sitting while trying to shift in and out. Evelin's tightness wasn’t helping. The worst part was he wanted to pull Sonia’s hips toward him when he thrust, but instead he had to push her away.

He looked down at Sonia's huge ass and her winking starfish gave him an idea. He swiped up some of her pussy juice and teased her butthole. He pressed on her balloon knot whenever he thrust in and eased the pressure when he pulled back.

This was working. He could hear Sonia whispering encouragement while telling Evelin how tight she was. How good her pussy felt. Evelin began to moan. He built up a good rhythm with Sonia as his finger began to open her back passage. He swiped up more of her juices and even spit on her hole.

Soon he was passing the first knuckle on his finger when Evelin’s legs began to shake. Sonia was putting more and more pressure against his hand, trying to get his finger deeper up her butt. When Evelin’s cunt clamped down on his cock, Sonia rammed her ass back embedding his finger fully up her ass. Caleb could hold out no longer and flooded Evelin’s womb.

Evelin screamed out and he could feel her womb sucking his load deep inside her. They had done it. She had orgasmed. He just hoped there was an egg traveling down to meet his swimmers.

He pulled out of her while Sonia moved off of Evelin and spun around, hugging him tightly. She had an enormous smile on her face as she grabbed his hand and sucked the finger that had been in her ass clean.

“Wow. You are a dirty girl, aren’t you? Sucking the finger that was just in your fantastic ass.” he chuckled.

She smirked at him, “For you, Your Holiness, I'll be as dirty as you want. I'm YOUR free use fuck toy, first and foremost.” She then proceeded to lick his cock clean as well.


Caleb came back into the living room wearing the new robe his mother bought him. He was feeling refreshed after his quick shower. His watch had cooled considerably and was once again back on his wrist.

The ladies were in varying stages of dress when he returned. June and Amelia were just finishing cleaning and were wearing satin nightgowns. Sonia had put on a pajama set. Kathy had donned panties and a spaghetti strap camisole. Lottie was once again fully dressed. However, both Victoria and Evelin were struggling. Evelin couldn’t get her blouse buttoned properly, and Victoria kept trying to adjust her breasts in her bra.

A button popped off Evelin’s blouse and she exclaimed, “What the shit? This damn thing fit when I got here. How the hell could it shrink in two hours!”

Victoria stood upright and said, “I’m having trouble too. This is my favorite bra. It should fit me perfectly, but now I've got quad boob.”

Caleb struggled to keep a straight face as he watched them. Neither one had yet realized their breasts had gotten bigger after he impregnated them. Evelin’s blouse had already been tight when she arrived and now it had no hope of properly fitting. Meanwhile Victoria’s boobs were spilling out of her bra, although her new size wasn’t effecting her loose sun dress, it just looked even better on her.

Kathy spoke up and said, “They taught us in health class that a woman’s breasts can swell when she is aroused. Maybe that’s the problem.”

Sonia remained silent as the women struggled with their clothes. She had noticed Caleb watching them. He had an odd expression and she saw he was clearly aroused.

To Sonia, the two women’s breasts did appear to be bigger. In fact, Evelin’s breasts looked larger than they had been when Sonia was pretending to fuck her less than 20 minutes ago. She had spent the majority of the orgy with Evelin, so she knew how aroused the woman had been. But this swelling occurred after Caleb came inside and impregnated her.

It was not lost on her that the two women Caleb impregnated were the ones struggling with their suddenly larger breasts. Coupled with the breast reshaping miracle he had repeated on Lottie, this latest Stretcher King was turning out to be quite enjoyable and entertaining. Once she reported on this latest development, the Sisterhood would be even more interested in this young man.

The Stretcher King had chosen her to assist when he had nearly faltered in his holy mission. Sonia was both honored and overjoyed. She had been useful to a holy Stretcher King, quite possibly the most important one ever born.

When he proclaimed aiding him was what the Sisterhood was for, Sonia nearly reached her own orgasmic height. Like most of the Sisterhood, she had dedicated her life to the belief that they should help the Stretcher Kings breed and heal the women of the world.

The fact that his twin sister obviously had a crush on her as well, well that was just icing on the cake. Hazel had shown a great interest in the sisterhood, and had approached Tina to help her understand. Tina had turned to Sonia, which is how the three of them developed a sexual relationship. Sonia was elated at the growing relationship she was developing with Caleb's mother and sister. She was eager to become closer to Kathy as well. Sonia saw her as the perfect woman to become Caleb's wife and Harem Queen. She didn't have a jealous bone in her body, eagerly guiding him to bed other women, and add more to his harem.

Sonia was quite happy with the way events were playing out. But what truly pleased her the most, Caleb had called her huge ass 'fantastic'. Sonia had always felt it was too big, but now that the Stretcher King had shown approval for it, she loved her big fat ass. She only wished her breasts were bigger too. He clearly had a preference for large ones.

She resolved that if he should ever ask, she would allow him to take her anal virginity. The Sisterhood's belief was that a penis belonged in a pussy or a mouth, where a man's cum will do the most good. While anal sex did not carry the stigma that other religions had for it, it wasn't encouraged either. She had never taken a man in her back passage, but she would make an exception for him.

Kathy and Lottie exchanged phone numbers. Lottie promised to take Kathy to the seamstress that made her custom bras and Kathy was excited, to say the least. Their embrace became so passionate Caleb was afraid that they would get naked all over again.

When they finally broke apart, he hugged Lottie and said, "I hope when you get home your husband enjoys your boobs as much as I did."

Lottie smiled at him sadly and said, "Oh, my Nathan died 7 years ago. Nowadays it's just me, my eldest daughter, and my grandson."

Embarrassed for his faux pas, Caleb apologized, "I'm sorry. When you mentioned him earlier I had the impression he was still alive. Your love for him came through clearly in how you spoke of him."

She patted him on the shoulder and said, "Thank you for the sentiment, and your kind words. But it has been long enough the sting has dulled."

She hugged him again and indicated Kathy, "Now you take good care of this girl. You're very lucky to have her."

He pulled her in for a final hug and said, "I know I am. She reminds me every day."

Lottie moved on to say her goodbyes to the others and Evelin was next in front of him and Kathy. Their goodbyes were more unobtrusive. She thanked him for breeding her, but he doubted they would ever have anything more than a cordial relationship. She had come over with one purpose in mind, and had achieved it. He did promise her that if she wasn't pregnant, she was welcome to return, and they could try again.

When it was Victoria's turn she hugged him tightly and lingered in the embrace as if she didn't want to let go. She also exchanged contact information with Kathy. Their kiss and grope goodbye was less passionate than Lottie's but no less sincere.

Victoria promised to send them an invitation to the wedding. Kathy then told her that they would definitely attend. She laughed when Kathy promised her an invitation to our first planned orgy. Victoria told them that she and her future husband had discussed having three children, and she was hoping Caleb would do the honors when the time came. Before he could respond Kathy enthusiastically accepted, on the condition that Kathy got to join them.

As they went to bed that night, Caleb made a pit stop in the bathroom and hastily changed the normalization that effected the pleasure of the women he had sex with, which in turn effected the other women in the room. Three to five times was simply too much, all of the women had been more than a little worn out. He decided two to three times the pleasure should be enough.


Kathy pushed Caleb onto his bed and climbed on top of him. She propped herself up with one hand and grabbed his cock with the other, stroking it to get him hard.

Caleb laughed, "Damn woman. You haven't had enough yet?"

Kathy had a determined look on her face as she vented, "Do you realize you've only fucked me one time since we've been together? Sticking your dick in me for a couple seconds while I was licking Amelia doesn't count. Blowjobs don't count either, no matter how many orgasms they give me. I've had to watch you put your cock in other women over and over again. I'm your girlfriend, yet you've had sex with Holly more than me. And I've had sex with your mom more than I have with you."

Caleb stammered, "Shit. I'm sorry Kat. I didn't mean to neglect you. I won't have sex with Holly anymore if that's what you want."

Kathy rose up and slotted his cock in her slit. She sighed as she hilted him deep in her wet slit. She looked down at him as she began to slowly ride his dick, her womb gently sucking his cockhead. "I didn't mean that, doofus. I'm not mad about Holly. And I don't feel neglected. Not yet anyway. Keep having sex with Holly. When she goes off to college, she might not ever see you again. I'm not going to tell you who you can and can't have sex with. But as leader of your harem, I have to speak up if I see a problem heading our way. You need to remember that you have five women in your harem, and we need your love too. The only one of us that you've had sex with more than once is Katie."

"I am sorry." Caleb humbly stated.

"Apology accepted, so long as you remember to fuck your women." Kathy said as she grabbed his wrists and brought his hands to her tits. "NOW you can pinch my nipples. When I get close to cumming you can really crush them too. It felt great when Amelia and your mom did it to me earlier."

Caleb tugged her nipples and listened to her hiss in pleasure. Her mentioning his mother reminded him of a question he wanted to ask. "Hey Kat, what's up with that Mommy roleplay you were doing with my mom?"

Kathy bit her bottom lip, making her look both super cute, and hot as hellfire. She continued to slowly slide her cunt up and down his shaft while she decided what to say to him. Finally, she sighed and said, "I might as well tell you, since you'll find out eventually anyway. Hazel's not the only one that watches pornos with Angie. I've spent the night at her house a few times. We get under the covers and masturbate while we watch them on her laptop."

Kathy giggled as she felt Caleb's cock twitch. His reaction made her decide to tell him everything. "Angie got me into mother daughter stuff. She's not the only one with a thing for her mom."

Caleb stopped pulling Kathy's nipples for a second and said, "You mean..."

Kathy leaned forward, resting her tits on his chest as she slid her lower body back and forth on his dick. "I mean, I want to have sex with my mother. That's why I've been telling her everything about the sex everyone's been having here. That's why I want you to give her a stretch. Every woman that enters this house eventually has sex with other women. Look at Lottie. I heard what she said when you asked her to play with Victoria. Her resistance crumbled in seconds. I want you to stretch my mom, and then I'm going to make my move."

Caleb chuckled which made his dick twitch inside Kathy. "So the roleplay with my mom is sorta a surrogacy from your own mom?"

"Well... Yes and no." Kathy explained. "I really like your mom. I mean, aside from the fact that she's freaking HOT! She accepted me as your girlfriend without any fuss. And she treats me like my opinion matters. She cares about me. And for someone that is used to being bullied, that means a lot. She's a lot like my mom. I could easily see myself loving her just as much as I love my mom."

"Awwww. That's really sweet." June said from the doorway.

Caleb and Kathy both looked over at her. June stepped inside and closed the door behind her. She pulled her nightgown off as she walked towards the bed. "You two need to roll over and let Caleb be on top when you two have sex. Chris warned me that Kathy can't be trusted to get off of you before you cum. Baby Girl, your mother will be very upset with me if I let you get pregnant when you sleep over, and I haven't even met her in person yet. Go on now, make room for me."

Even as the two lovers shifted and changed positions, Caleb grinned at his mother. "So are you gonna sleep with us to make sure we are being good? Won't that mean Dad has to sleep alone?"

June laughed as she got in the bed with them. "I sure hope he isn't sleeping alone."

At Caleb's confused look June laughed even harder. "Caleb honey, didn't you notice your father isn't home? He is spending the night at Cindy's apartment. I told her that since she didn't get to come over to give Harold his first threesome, and you and I got to give him his first foursome, Cindy and her roommate could give him a threesome tonight. They were giving him a double blowjob when I called a little while ago."

Kathy had her eyes closed while she reveled in the pleasure Caleb was giving to her from their slow lovemaking. "That's awfully nice of you, June."

Caleb thought back on all the changes he'd made to reality and asked, "Yeah Mom, are you sure you're okay with that? I mean... I never thought..."

June finished his sentence for him. "That I'd let my husband sleep around on me. Oh Caleb, Honey, I don't mind at all. I trust Cindy. I've known about her crush on your dad for years. I'm okay with them being together. I mean, I'm having way more sex than he is, and with more people too. Just this week I've been with you, Hazel, Kathy, Amelia, Sonia, Katie, Grandma Daphne, and your father. And I already know Tina and Angie want to have sex with me. Remember, I'm free use as long as your father isn't home."

Caleb wasn't sure which of his normalities caused his parents to become so sexually open, but they seemed happy, so he didn't think too long on it. He returned his focus to fucking his girlfriend while his mother watched and made sure he didn't impregnate her. Kathy's womb never stopped sucking his dick.

He had only begun to speed up his thrusts when Kathy moaned, "Mommy! Come suck my titties!"

June smiled at her son as she shifted over and said, "Yes, Baby Girl."


Thank you for reading. Please leave a comment and tell me what you think. If you like the story, and would like to show your appreciation, please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)