Guess Who

The cock guessing dare was about to start. All five of the women had blindfolds on and every was satisfied that they could see anything. Jennifer Turner was the first in the line of girls, so she would be going first everytime.

“Okay, Jenn. The first guy is in front of you. You get a minute, starting now.” Josie said from behind her.

Jenn reached out and finally found the cock that was in front of her. First, she stroked it until it was hard in her hand. She thought she knew who it was already being that she had sex with all of the guys in the room at some point. It was nice and long but not very thick with a bit of a curve to it. If she had to guess right now, she would say that she is pretty sure she would be right. She had one more thing that she wanted to try, so she leaned forward and took the cock into her mouth and bobbed her head a few times and finally she heard a quiet moan come from the guy's lips. She knew exactly who it was now.

“Time. Okay, it’s your turn, Kelly.” Josie said from behind the blonde teacher.

Kelly reached out and took the cock in her hand and being that she had sex with all of the guys in the room before she got with Patrick, it didn’t take her long to figure out who it was either. Kelly continued to stroke the guy and she wasn’t going to go any further than that out of respect for Patrick and Sasha. Soon enough, the minute was over and it was now Sabel’s turn.

Sabel took the cock into her hand and stroked it a few times, but she wanted to make sure that she knew who it was so with 45 seconds left, the girl leaned forward and took the cock in her mouth. Being that she had a good amount of time left, Sabel went about giving the guy the best blowjob that she could for the time she had. She took the cock deep down her throat and made the guy moan a few times as she repeated the move until time was up.

“Okay, Deb. It’s your turn.” Josie said from behind her daughter.

Debbie took the cock in her hand and she realized that it wasn’t one that she had before, so she had no choice but to do what she heard Sabel doing, so she leaned forward and took the cock in her mouth. She didn’t want to give the guy a great blowjob, so she took the head of his cock into her mouth and just swirled her tongue around it until she got a moan or two and then she was pretty sure that she knew who it was. Soon enough time was up.

“Okay, now it is your turn, Kate.” Josie said and Kate reached out tentatively and took the cock in her hand. This was the first time she had ever done anything like this, so she wasn’t sure what to do exactly, so she just wrapped her hand around the cock that was in front of her and stroked it for the whole minute of time that she had. She had hoped for a moan of some sort, but the guy had been able to hold it in.

“Time’s up. It is time for your guesses now girls.” Josie said.

“I think it was Greg.” Jenn said.

“Me too.” Kelly said.

“I agree with that.” Sabel said.

“That was my thought as well.” Debbie said.

“I think it was Chad.” Kate said.

“Okay, everyone was right but Kate. You can take the blindfold off and come over and join us.” Josie said and Kate did as she was told.

The next round was about to start and a guy walked up in front of Jenn and she took the cock in her hand. She didn’t even need a moan from the guy to know for sure who this one was, but she wanted to torture the guy a little bit so she took his cock into her mouth and gave him her best blowjob. The guy was doing good holding his moans in, so she wasn’t getting any more information from him, but that was fine. She was almost 100% who the guy was.

“Times up.” Sherri said and the guy moved on to Kelly, and just like Jenn, she knew exactly who it was. Kelly continued to stroke the guy and then finally time was called and the guy moved on to Sabel.

She wasn’t sure who it was, but she had a guess that she knew who it was. Sabel then took the guy's cock into her mouth and sucked him off for a bit and she didn’t get any information from the guy, so she was just as in the dark as she was before.

Finally time was up and it was time for Debbie again. Debbie went straight for sucking on the guy's cock this time and she had a thought that she knew who it was, but she wasn’t sure as the guy wasn’t moaning at all. Finally time was up and it was time for the girls to guess again.

“Okay, ladies. Time for your guesses.” Sherri said.

“It was Billy.” Jenn said.

“Yep, it’s Billy.” Kelly said.

“Mine was a complete guess, but I am glad I was on the right track. Billy.” Sabel said.

“Damn, I thought it was Kirk.” Debbie said.

“You’re out Debbie. You can take your blindfold off and go over with the others.” Sherri said as she saw the next guy moving to Jenn.

Jenn wasted no time in starting to blow the guy as she knew exactly who he was as soon as she put her hand on him. He was one of her regulars, so she didn’t have a doubt in her mind who it was. The low moans that she was getting were confirming her thought as well. Soon enough the minute was over and it was Kelly’s turn.

“Your go, Kelly.” Josie said as she and Sherri were standing behind the girls watching what was going on closely.

Kelly put her hand on the cock in front of her and she knew right away who it was as well. She decided that she was going to torture the guy though and she started to jack his cock off as hard and as fast as she could and she could hear him moaning from the pleasure that he was getting from her hand. That minute was over faster than the guy would have wished for, but he still had Sabel left.

“Your turn, baby.” Sally Green called out as she got up from her seat to come and watch her daughter do her thing.

Sabel took the cock in her hand and she wasn’t sure who it was. It had been a long time since she had sex with some of the guys in this room so her memory wasn’t that good on who this was. She leaned in and took the cock into her mouth and to her surprise, somehow the guy was able to hold his moans in, unlike the muffled ones that she heard when Jenn and Kelly were doing their thing with the guy. She had no idea who this was and she was just going to have to guess when the time came, but she knew that she was going to try and give the guy as much pleasure as she could before things ended.

“Times up. It is time to guess, girls.” Sally said.

“It was Kirk.” Jenn said.

“I agree with Jenn. It was Kirk.” Kelly said.

“Yeah, I’m out. I thought it was Chad.” Sabel said.

“That’s okay, come on over with the rest of us.” Sally said as she and her daughter walked over to the rest of the group.

“Alright, we are down to the last two. Let’s see who is the best.” Josie said.

The guy stepped up in front of Jenn and just like last time, she knew exactly who it was. It was another of her regulars. She took the cock in her mouth and the guy actually started to thrust into her mouth which started to cause Jenn to couch a bit as she wasn’t expecting it. Once the brunette got used to what the guy was doing to her, she was taking the face fucking like a champ. Soon enough, Jenn’s minute was over and it was Kelly’s turn.

Kelly knew who it was right away as well. She started to jack fast and hard and the guy started to really get into it and started to thrust into her hand. Kelly couldn’t help but smile as she always had this effect on this guy. Soon enough the minute was over and it was time for both of them to guess who it was.

“Okay. Time for your guesses.” Marsha Hammons said as she had walked over to watch what was going on better.

“Chad.” Jenn said.

“It was definitely Chad.” Kelly said in agreement.

“Okay. It looks like we have a tie. How do we want to break the tie as we need a winner?” Sherri asked.

“How about one of us let’s the girls rub our tits and try to guess who it is. That might make it hard enough for them so that the tie can be broken.” Hilary Dawkins said.

“That is a good idea. Let’s get together and pick who is going to do this.” Josie said.

Everyone got together and talked it over and came up with who would be doing this. The woman who was picked took off her shirt and bra and walked over to the other two women who were still blindfolded. Jenn heard the person approaching and reached out and started squeezing the tits in front of her. She had an idea of who this was, but she wasn’t positive. She didn’t think that Kelly had a chance in hell though. If Jenn was right, this was the woman who taught her how to pleasure a girl, so she had felt the tits before, but she wasn’t sure about that though.

“Time. Your turn Kelly.” Josie said and Kelly reached out to the tits that were now in front of her.

Just like Jenn thought, Kelly had no clue who this was. Whoever it was had some nice tits, but they weren’t ones that she had ever felt before. She knew that it wasn’t Marsha Hammons as they were too big to be hers. Kelly kept feeling the tits and nothing was coming to mind, so when her minute was up, she was pretty sure she had lost.

“Okay. Time for guesses, girls.” Sherri said.

“I think it was Sally.” Jenn said.

“I thought it was Sherri.” Kelly said.

“Jenn wins. What does Jenn get for winning?” Sherri asked.

Being that Chad and Debbie had come up with the dare, they had to come up with the reward for Jenn. They thought hard for a few minutes and then something came to their mind that both of them knew that Jenn would like. Debbie announced what it was.

“Aunt Jenn, we thought you would like this. All four of the guys that were part of the dare just now will fuck you. You and the guys get to decide how, whether it is one fucking you after the other or at the same time.” Debbie said.

“Let’s go boys. I am about to rock your world.” Jenn said as she got up from her seat and made her way to the guest bedroom of the Goldberg house with the guys following close behind.