Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 10 by newbeforeold newbeforeold

What Happens Next?

Fulfilling Fantasies

Tom had thought he might have some reservation about having sex with his stepsister’s body, regardless of whether his girlfriend (and his ex-girlfriend, and his high school crush, among several others) was also in there at the time. Maybe he was weak, but when his eager stepsister pulled down her bathing suit top to expose her incredible tits, then reached down to grab his extremely hard cock, no such reservations materialized.

“Mmm, he’s such a good boy,” crooned Lisa. She paused, then said, “Actually, you really were, as long as I’ve known you. Such a goody two shoes.”

“Let’s see what we can do about that,” said Vicki, and before Tom knew what was happening he was sitting on the side of the pool and Vicki was licking up and down his cock. It felt spectacular. The rest of the girls began to crowd around.

“Vicki never did this for you when you were together,” said the Marissa body, matter-of-factly. “She was afraid, really. But a couple of me are experts, so now she knows exactly what to do.”

“This is incredible,” said the Blair body, her tone one of wonderment, as she jumped into the pool bottomless and made her way toward Tom and the others. “I feel like I’ve know you forever. Wanted you forever.”

Lisa got up close to where Vicki’s mouth was still going on his cock, and moaned, “Oh God, I want to be every woman you’ve ever wanted. Each of them, giving themselves to you with all of their hearts. I want to give you that. That can’t be wrong, can it?”

Vicki pulled off of him, and said, “But first, let’s celebrate.” Immediately, the Lisa body took over.

Please log in to view the image

“I know it’s been a long time since you had Vicki’s pussy,” said Tally, “but you’ve never had your sister’s. So I’m thinking, first things first.”

Step-sister,” insisted Tom, as best he could under the circumstances.

“Oh, who gives a shit?” said Ashleigh. Then she grabbed Tom and pulled him into the pool.

*****

The next 36 hours or so then turned into one big orgy in Tom and Lisa’s house. Whatever had happened when she absorbed the new personalities seemed to have sent Lisa’s already constant horniness into overdrive. Tom couldn't keep up as much as she was offering, but that didn’t seem to bother Lisa. When he needed breaks or needed to sleep or eat or just to chill out, her bodies seemed more than capable of entertaining each other. At least 2 of her 8 selves were lesbians, after all (it turned out that Christie was, too).

Shortly after the scene in the pool, he found himself in the living room with Lisa and Ashleigh next to each other on all fours in front of him, plump asses in the air for his pleasure. He soon discovered that with plenty of bodies to go around, Lisa was particularly fond of this arrangement in various permutations. After all, it didn’t matter which pussy or ass he used, she would still feel it, and she eventually told him she liked the surprise of not knowing which hole he would use next.

Please log in to view the image

He chose to enter Ashleigh from behind, and she gasped at the sensation, her mouth making an ‘o.’” All of Lisa’s bodies did, in fact, though he couldn’t see them all at the time.

“You feel that tight pussy?” Lisa managed to groan. “Oh God, it’s been waiting for you. Do you remember when you walked in on her in the shower when you were 18?” He did. “She thought about that a lot alone at night. She still does. She used to watch porn with step siblings and pretend she was with you, did you know that?”

Tom almost came right then and there, but instead he kept pounding his stepsister’s pussy, the sensations building.

“Shit!” Ashleigh shouted. “Fuck me right there! Fuck! I did have fantasies, I did. But I… I was afraid. Now that’s gone. Now I’m, oh God, now… fuck! I’m a part of Lisa. Thank you so much for letting Lisa take me. Thank you thank you thank you. Oh fuck, I’m gonna cum, I’m gonna cum…”

Please log in to view the image

Ashleigh’s body tensed and quivered on his cock for several seconds, as did Lisa’s body next to her even though her pussy was empty. Tom pulled out and came all over Ashleigh’s ass, as they hadn’t actually discussed at any point whether she was on birth control.

Only later did it occur to him that he had no idea whether it was actually “Ashleigh,” whatever that meant at this point, talking to him in that moment, or whether Lisa was using her body to tell him what he needed to hear. Maybe there wasn’t a difference at this point?

*****

It wasn’t long after this encounter that Tom answered the front door and found the Cathy body there, ready to join the party after finishing up work.

After entering, she said, “Hi baby,” then immediately dropped to her knees, pulled her tits out of her top, and continued, “Here, let me get you hard again.”

She pulled his cock out of his pants and Cathy’s lips immediately wrapped around it and set to work. Soon he was ready for another round.

Please log in to view the image

Having done her job, Cathy sent him upstairs, where he found Blaire waiting for him on the bed, naked. She kissed him hard, and then he set out to slowly and carefully explore his old friend’s body. She leaned back on the bed and he first fingered and then licked her shaved little pussy. She made the most adorably little yipping sounds of pleasure as his tongue played over her clit.

Before too much of this, though, she managed to flip him over so she could ride him. “Ohhh wow,” she groaned, as she lowered herself down onto him. “Your cock feels so good in this body.” She started to push herself up and down on him, her movements getting faster and faster. “I’m so sorry I kept you in the friend zone all those years. It was a big mistake, I see that now. Everything is so clear.”

Please log in to view the image

She bounced her tight little body on him until she came, suddenly and completely. “Oh baby!” she cried out, and then she didn’t have any more words, just an intense yell as her stomach flexed. He wasn’t done yet, though. He flipped her over and they fucked missionary style for several more minutes, letting the sensations build again and looking into each other’s eyes. He loved Lisa with all of his heart, but Blaire would always have a place there, too. And now, he could look into Blaire’s eyes and Lisa looked back at him. Finally, he pulled out and came all over her beautiful D-cup tits.

Please log in to view the image

She laughed and said, “Be honest. When was the first time you fantasized about doing that?”

“I think it might have been when I was sitting next to you in Mrs. Hall’s math class,” he said. She laughed again.

What Happens Next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)