Mila and Alice.

I took a moment to let myself relax, let my arousal drop at least a little. I didn’t expect that to have the effect it did on the girls.

“Oliver, come on!” Mila urged.

“You’re stalling,” Alice teased.

I hadn’t done much yet other than fondle their butts. I had even taken my hands off of them while I took a deep breath. But even so, I saw their pussies grow wet from pure anticipation alone. They knew what was coming, they wanted it and wanted it now.

“Okay, okay… So impatient, geez.”

I slid my middle and index fingers up and down Alice’s slit, spreading the forming drop of her juices all over her labia. At the same time, I did something similar with Mila, only I was getting my thumb wet before I began to tease the entrance of her butthole.

“Mmmm…!” Alice moaned.

“Ooof! Ahaha, that first touch is always weird!” Mila said, giggling.

I pushed my two fingers inside Alice, gently rubbing my way up to her magic spot as she got wetter and wetter. For Mila, I began to put more pressure against her hole, not quite pushing it in yet.

Grace, Sarah, Noelle and Diana watched us, focusing mostly on Mila’s and Alice’s pleased faces.

“Alice looks so relaxed,” Noelle said.

“And Mila looks like she’s expecting something big soon,” Sarah teased.

“He has the best fingers, holy shit…” Alice said with a happy, drawn out moan.

“Oliver, push it in…” Mila pleaded.

I did. I pushed my thumb against her hole and inserted the very tip. Mila’s shoulders squirmed, but she did her best to keep her behind relaxed. But in her squirming, her hand brushed against Alice’s.

The two girls looked at one another and smirked. Alice put her hand over Mila’s and they interlocked fingers before their faces came closer. Soon enough they were sharing playful licks on the lips.

“You’re making such a lewd face,” Mila told Alice.

“Look who’s talking. You’re the pervert for liking butt stuff,” Alice teased.

“Mmm, you should try it. It’s… Ahhh…! Mmmm… so good!” I drove my thumb deeper inside Mila’s asshole, causing her to moan mid-sentence.

“I just might… Oh! Oooh, fuuuck!” Just then I also found Alice’s G-spot and began to rub circles on it.

Lost in their pleasure, both girls began to make out passionately, tongues darting inside the other’s mouth. Diana looked on, a small and excited smile on her lips. She took a sip of her drink and licked her lips from side to side twice.

“I expected it, but he’s quite the multitasker, isn’t he?” she said.

“Oh, you have no idea,” Sarah said. “He can use his hips, both hands and his mouth at the same time.”

“I bet he could use his feet, too, but we haven’t tried,” Grace said, laughing.

Noelle laughed with her. “Now THAT would be too much!”

I was moving by instinct, much like always, but I understood what I was doing. And, unlike Grace, being the generous soul that I am, I kept at it until Mila and Alice both came.

“Oh fuck! Oh FUCK!”

“Mmmm! Yes! Oh YES!”

Strong shivers shook them from head to toes. Mila and Alice screamed and grunted as the intensity of their climax rocked them and hit them with sweet aftershocks even after I had pulled my hands away.

I licked my hand soaked on Alice’s juices because I knew the girls found it hot. I didn’t lick the thumb that was inside Mila’s ass because I knew the girls would find it a bit gross.

“Fuck… Fuuuck…” Mila gasped. “I’m… I’m out for now. Play… the next round without me…”

“Same,” Alice said with a tired laugh. “Thanks, Diana. I needed that so bad…”

“No, thank you two for the show,” Diana said, smiling. “That was… enlightening.”

“Alright, I’m gonna wash my hands,” I said. “Play the next round and tell me how it goes. We know I’m gonna lose, anyway.”

I gave Mila and Alice a kiss on top of the head before I went to wash my hand. When I returned, I saw that Grace had won the round with… three 2s. Huh.

“Yeah, terrible hand but it doesn’t matter,” she said. Her eyes went from me to Diana and back to me. “Alright, I do feel bad for leaving you hanging like that, love. As an apology…” She smirked. “You and Diana lock yourselves in the bathroom and do whatever you want in there. With two conditions: 1) be loud, and 2) come out looking as closely as possible to how you went in.”

As happy as that order made me, the second condition… confused me a little.

“What do you mean?” I asked her.

“Your hair, your clothes… Stuff like that. You go in like that, come out like that.”

“Ah. You mean… as if nothing ever happened,” Diana deduced.

Grace winked at her. “Exactly.”

“Ah.” I understood, too.

“Any time limit?” Diana asked, standing up.

“Nope. Well, just don’t actually forget we’re waiting out here.”

Diana smiled. “Roger that.”

Diana came up to me, held my hand and led me to the bathroom, locking the door behind us.

I understood Grace’s orders, especially what she had truly meant. I was shirtless but still wearing pants. Diana, by virtue of the game going up a level when it did, was still wearing her pants, her white shirt and her underwear.

“Did I get it right?” Diana aske me. “What she really wants is for us to come out clearly looking like we just had sex but pretending we didn’t, right?”

“Yeah.”

Diana smiled and wrapped her arms around my neck. She then pulled me with her as she leaned back against the door with a loud smack. Grace did ask us to be loud.

“She’s a considerate girl,” Diana whispered.

I chuckled. “She is. It wasn’t hard to see you were getting horny.”

“This has been… more exciting than anything I’ve ever done. It’s strange to be intruding in a group where everyone is so much younger, but…”

“You’re not intruding,” I told her. “You’re a part of it. So long as you want to be, of course.”

“Give me some more time. I want to learn more about you all. Tonight has been great for that, but… I don’t want to rush.”

I nodded. “You know how I feel about you, but the girls like you, too. I hope we haven’t made you uncomfortable.”

Smiling, Diana shook her head. “I told you, this is more exciting and more freeing than anything I’ve ever done.”

“More than making out with Maria?” I teased.

She chortled. “Should’ve kept my mouth shut. Now stop talking and fuck me while your girlfriends listen!”

“Yes, ma’am!”

Please consider supporting the story on Patreon. It really helps me a lot.