Backtrack a bit

While you considered your words, your hand still remained firmly squeezing Lucy’s boob and after only a bit of light resistance did she give up and just let you have your way with her while you thought.

“You said that Sarah had…” you started to ask.

“Are you gonna stop with that?” Lucy asked, shooting a look at your hand.

“No. Anyway, you said that Sarah had been talking to you earlier. What did she wanna talk to you about?” you asked, quickly moving on so you could keep playing with Lucy’s tits.

She looked at you blankly for a second after you had blatantly ignored her but she took no action to remove your hand, giving you a light huff before she started talking. You even thought she might not answer as a form of getting you to stop but she didn’t even do that, as if her embarrassment over you seeing her cum had made her go back to her roots. Making her act like she had to put up some sort of fight even though she might actually be enjoying the attention herself.

“She just wanted to see what my plans were later. I said some old friends had messaged about catching up later while I’m in town so I’d probably be out but that was about it. You can just ask her if you want. She should be in her room” Lucy replied, not telling you much like you had hoped.

You briefly turned to look at your door and saw that it was still wide open. You had said that the family needed to be more open but the fact that you hadn’t even considered closing the door behind you meant that there was a chance Sarah had heard what you and Lucy had been doing even if you hadn’t meant for her to overhear.

Still, the conversation she had shared with Lucy seemed innocent enough but something was still nagging at you in the back of your mind. She’d been secretive ever since you had both gone next door so at this point you just wanted to know what was going on.

“Why’d you wanna know?” Lucy asked, now completely ignoring your hand still absentmindedly pawing at her chest.

“Just curious, she’s been a bit off today” you replied, deciding to get Lucy's opinion.

“She seemed fine to me. I mean yeah she left in a hurry after you were messing around at the door but when I saw her after school she looked like she was back to normal to me” Lucy said with a shrug.

Lucy was usually pretty accurate when it came to reading her sister so you didn’t feel the need to argue with her judgement, fully believing that Sarah would have been okay when she was talking with her.

“Fair enough. I’m hoping she’s fine so if that’s the impression you got then I guess that’s good. She also wanted to speak with Mom so I assumed it was something bigger than just a usual chat” you added, giving Lucy your thoughts on the whole situation.

“I’m sure it’s fine. It’s not like you’ve ever had a situation where you overthink it right?” Lucy teased, already smiling to herself before she could even finish her sentence.

“You’re the one overthinking your reactions in front of me. I saw you looking embarrassed when you lowered your top” you joked right back, poking her right on her nipple before finally removing your hand from under her tshirt.

It wasn’t the best comeback but it seemed to do the job and getting her back to her recent self.

She went to jab you right back but you lay down at the side of her in a rough attempt to dodge, letting her roll onto her side towards you so she could get closer to your face.

“You… Fine, I still have some issues with being as comfortable when we do stuff like this” Lucy admitted, lightly putting her fist down on your chest before letting her hand just rest there.

She had already moved closer in her attempt to hit you but she didn’t move away, keeping herself stuck to your side as your conversation continued.

“So even if you don’t feel the need to follow her lead, you could say that having Mom be more open might make you be more inclined to accept it yourself?” you asked, going back to mentioning your early idea.

“It’ll take more than just Mom to help me with that” Lucy replied.

“But it would help?” you asked again, getting a moment of silence that told you both what her answer was already.

“It wouldn’t hurt. But anyway, you’re already doing more to help me in that regard by just pushing me to do more things openly. Like the kiss this morning. I’ve never been someone to do PDA like that but it felt nice with you” Lucy admitted, the blush on her cheeks telling you she was struggling to be genuine.

“Well you deserve to have attention given to you. I know this might sound a bit insincere, especially given it’s coming from a guy splitting his attention over multiple women but you do mean the world to me and having moments like these are some of my favourite memories. Even without all the sex and stuff” you revealed back, each of you opening up to one another.

“The sex isn’t bad though” Lucy joked while she felt comfortable continuing to talk.

“Yeah, I do like this. I think I need moments like this. Maybe even just something like this as a family as well. Just an evening to ourselves where we can just lay around and cuddle up without any judgement” Lucy suggested, pushing herself even closer at the mention of cuddling.

“I’d like that too. Maybe sometime later this week when things are a little less hectic. Help to calm us all back down” you added, liking the idea enough to make sure it would happen at some point.

You lay there for a little while longer with Lucy and just enjoyed talking with her about anything that came to mind, sometimes drifting slightly into the dirty talk category but you both pulled it back before it got too far, settling for just teasing each other instead. Lucy kept her hand on your chest and you caught her moving her hand so that she could listen to your heartbeat, a small gesture that made you smile while you were lightly playing with her hair in return.

Neither of you seemed to want to move and ruin the moment but you were feeling like you needed to do something productive while you had some quiet time. You didn’t want to sound like an asshole either by just saying to Lucy that you were now suddenly busy either. Figuring out how to word it to her was now suddenly in the centre of your thoughts and even though it had just been a calm relaxing moment, you couldn’t help but start dwelling on your thoughts.

Author's note: Last chapter before the break. See you on the 20th when I'm back :)