Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 9 by triangletoast triangletoast

Sweet dreams, or twisted nightmares?

Restless Respite

I sat bundled up in my bed. Pillows pressed into my ears and the pale glare of my phone burning my exhausted retinas.

Thump Thuump Thump

I scrolled through message boards. Passing the same posts time after time. Hoping. Praying for something new and interesting to pop up.

Uhuhuughh fuuck

Headphones dead. Had I put them on charge when they first went out, they might have been back to full capacity. Instead I stupidly told myself not to bother. That they had to be finishing up soon.

Nuughhh worship that cunt my little fuck puppy

I checked my sent messages. 'You still up?' Sent 2 hours ago and unread. Well... at least somebody was getting sleep tonight.

Please Miss ahaahh Pleeeease fuck me harder!!

I flipped over and pressed my head into the mattress. Begging for the constant moaning, whispering, and creaking of their bed to stop. I was so damn tired. If they'd just shut up for five minutes I could-

A thud hit the wall so hard I was worried they'd broken it down. Followed by the blood curdling scream of my sister cuming for the third, no fourth? Fifth time tonight? It was especially insulting when I'd been denied that pleasure all night. Their constant gushing moans and squeals tainting any pleasure of the flesh I might have found.

It didn't help that I couldn't get the image of her out of my mind. The image of my naked sister lying on the couch right next to me. Glistening wet pussy within reach of my hand...

I shook the image from my mind. I didn't want to think about it. I didn't even want to cum anymore, despite spending half the night hard. I just wanted to sleep. To get through this hellish night and find some time tomorrow to rub one off to that picture of Candi's tits I saved.

I was feeling a little bad about doing that before, about jerking off to my sister's girlfriend. A sleepless night enduring the sounds of them fucking, her barking like a dog and a constant banging against the wall changed my disposition. It would feel soo good to jerk my cock to that picture, dump my cum all over her. I just had to get some sleep first.

Sleep. Yeah.... the bed was so warm and comfortable.... like I was resting my head between Candi's fat tits.... nuzzling them as I drifted off to sleep....

BZZZZTTTT

The buzzing against my skin jolted me awake. I groaned into the underside of my pillow, pulling my phone off my chest to check it. It was probably just Kay, responding to my message sarcastically in the middle of the night.

I blinked the sleep out of my eyes, getting them to focus again. The message wasn't from Kay.

'I want my reward.'

Candi. She'd fucked my sister for countless hours already, and she wanted more???

Well fuck her. She'd been blowing me off ever since she sent the tit pic, so fuck her.

'It's now or never.'

I stared at the message and let it sit with me. What did it even matter? Tandi seemed to like me, though she was a bit of a freak, but Olive was cool. I had a shot with either of them, maybe even both depending on just how freaky they were. I didn't need anything from Candi.

'Comr in here then.' I texted back.

'No.'

'You cum here.'

What creative wordplay, I sarcastic thought to myself as I got out of bed. Sneaking down the dark hallway and opening the door as softly as I could.

The smell of it hit me as I slipped through the open crack of the door. The deep harsh muskyness of raw and sweaty sex mixed with the floral sweetness of pure girliness. It filled the room completely and yet I wanted more.

"Get in here." Candi held the sheets to the bed open for me.

My sister liked to keep her bed in the corner of her room against the wall, right across from the door. Candi was on the side of the bed against the wall, leaving my naked sleeping sister lying between us.

"I'm not..." I whispered in a harsh tone. Trying to avert my eyes from my sister's lust marked naked body.

"She won't wake up after being fucked like that." Candi said, her voice barely lower than normal. Slapping her tit to further prove her point.

Sam just snorted a little, turning over to face me. Black lipstick, bite marks and light bruising covering her body. Mostly concentrated around her face, tits and crotch.

"Quit being a bitch and come make me cum." Candi taunted.

What the fuck was I doing here. Fooling around with your sisters girlfriend was already fucked up enough. Doing it in her own bed was a whole nether layer.

But doing it while she was sleeping in the same damn bed? This was definitely going to be the most fucked up moment of my life. Yet I couldn't help myself but move forward.

I climbed over my sister's naked body. Trying my best not to wake her, to touch her or to look at her. About halfway across Candi pulled me over to her, pressing her lips onto mine and diving her tongue down my throat.

She grabbed my hand and **** it onto her cunt, getting what she wanted out of me. Candi was just as warm as Tandi had been, but softer and tighter. Her wet lips creating a louder squelching noise as I fucked her hole with a single finger.

"Can you taste your sister's cunt on my lips." Candi asked, taking a break to lick across my face with her long tongue.

"Don't talk like that."

"Why the fuck not?" Candi reached around me and grabbed my ass. Pulling my pajama shorts down to my knees.

Her fingers teased their way across my hard cock. The light touch making me twitch violently after a full night of being denied.

"It's just fucked up." I rubbed my thumb in circles around her clit. Hoping that if I fingered her hard enough she might get distracted from this line of thought.

"No. This would be fucked up." She pushed me down onto the middle of the bed. Holding me still with one hand while the other tugged on my sister's arm.

Still completely knocked out, she flipped over and started clinging onto me. Mistaking me for Candi, snuggling her naked tits right into my arm. Cuddling me with an arm across my chest, dangerously close to my cock.

"Do you want her to touch it?" Candi asked. Stroking my cock lightly.

"What the fuck is wrong with you! She's my sister!" I hissed as harsh and softly as I could. All too away of my sisters soft perky tits pressing against my body.

"You wanted fucked up. So now you're getting it." Candi grinned wide. I wasn't even able to finger her like this, but she was getting off harder than ever now. "Just admit that you liked the taste of her fresh cunt on my lips. That you love her tight body clinging onto you while I jerk you off."

Shs leaned in closer. Hand gripping my cock tight while her thumb teased the tip. My precum leaking all over her.

"These sheets are drenched in our cunt juices you know?" She moaned the words out. "Maybe we should add some of your fluids to them as well?"

I started to talk, to beg her to stop, but she slammed a hand down on my mouth. Jerking my cock harder and faster.

"You're so close to cuming you pathetic stud." She giggled wildly. Drunk of the power she had here. "If you don't want to stain her bed.... maybe her legs would make a nice target?"

I shook my head. Staring her down, pleading with my eyes while I held back the hardest orgasim of my life.

"No? Maybe her tits then. Or her face?" She cackled. Removing her hand to let me speak.

"You're fucking psychotic!"

"And you're as hard as a rock." She purred. "And if you don't do as I say. I'll scream."

There was a chilling seriousness to her words. She stopped jerking me off and let the meaning sink in.

"Imagine her waking up right now? With me screaming ****?" She leaned over me. Her face pouting in mock sadness. "I was so scared Sam, he just jumped into bed with his cock out."

"I'll do what you want..." I couldn't hold back the bitterness of my words.

She smiled, leaning back up and running her hand down my chest.

"Men are so easy." She said. Slowly jerking my cock again. "So I'll be kind and go easy on you."

"Just...just don't make me cum on her..."

"Tch, like you're not aching for me to **** you to do it." She rolled her eyes. "No, I just want one thing from you tonight. Just a peck on the lips."

"Huh? We already-"

"Not my lips you fucking idiot." She wrapped her hand around my throat. Not **** me but holding me tightly. "Her lips."

I turned my head to my sleeping sisters. Her pert small lips open as if she was ready for me. The chills I had only intensified. A peck on the lips... on her lips.... well... it's not like I had a choice.

Candi slowed her grip on me as I leaned down to my sister's mouth. Reaching my hand over to softly lift her head up. It was astounding she hadn't woken up yet, but then again I was struggling to stay awake and I hadn't been fucked for hours all night.

"Just a peck?" I whispered back to Candi. Feeling the sweat drip from my brow.

"Just a peck." She confirmed. That wide impish grin on her face.

"Just two seconds of contact and a lifetime of memory.”

Awaken your darkest desires?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)