But if we're talking bodies

Carly and Dani both surged with anxiety as they rode up the elevator together towards the Master’s Suite. Carly had asked Sylvia once again to babysit Marley, and the former host was happy to do it- for the usual going rate, of course.

Carly: 7600 BP – 500 BP = 7100 BP

Sylvia: 500 BP + 500 BP = 1000 BP

“…Are you sure about this?” Carly was the first one to talk. “Look, if you’re not certain, then we can just call this off until you’re ready. The three of us can just hang around the Master’s Suite together, you know.”

Carly was anxious about Dani getting cold feet. Especially when she heard about what her girlfriend had arranged with Sylvia.

“No, it has to be tonight,” Dani said adamantly, shaking her head. “If it doesn’t happen tonight, then there’s no way I’ll know for sure. We can’t keep suppressing it, after all.”

Carly winced. But she knew her partner was right.

Earlier…

“Sorry, you want to do WHAT?!” Dani’s jaw dropped in disbelief and she stared at Sylvia, shocked and appalled.

Sylvia was completely ambivalent to that; her eyes were shining brightly at the great idea she saw in front of her.

“It’s simple!” Sylvia cried. “I can use my Fuck the Voters transformation, to veto your Just One of the Guys transformation! That way, when stuff happens between you, Carly, and Daddy tonight, you’ll know that you’re not being influenced by it! However you’re feeling, you’ll know that transformation or no transformation, that’s how you would feel! Or something like that!”

“Yeah, but…” Dani looked like she was going to throw up. “Then… if stuff gets sexual with me… I won’t have that filter… it’ll be just like Nick’s actually touching me, and looking at me…”

“Is that bad?” Sylvia asked, cocking her head to the side.

“Of course it’s bad!” Dani exclaimed. “Him and Carly being together is one thing, but doing stuff with me…”

“Wait, hold up, I’m confused,” Gina frowned. “Why would you be doing anything with him in the first place?”

Dani’s face turned red and she glared at Gina. “Because this stuff happens, you know! If I’m seeing the two of them going at it and I’m getting worked up, and then they try and rope me into their little mess…”

“You can just say no, right?” Gina gave her a blank look. “What, you don’t think you have the impulse control to turn down sex with a guy? You’re sure you’re a lesbian, right?”

Dani refused to dignify that with a response. Just a hiss.

“Alright, alright, geez,” Gina said, holding up her hands in surrender. “It was just a question.”

“Come on, Dani!” Sylvia begged. She grabbed the tomboy’s hands. “Look, I know I gave you a lot of rough transformations, but at least let me help you out, okay? You’re doubting what you want because of a mental transformation. But if I veto it, then you can be confident that your feelings are your own! …It’s worth a shot, at least, right? Just to be sure?”

Dani could see actual honesty gleaming in Sylvia’s eyes. It was a strange sight for sure.

“…No, we can’t!” She said, pulling her hands away and taking a few steps back. “Besides, you’d be getting my transformation permanently, right? No, I can’t do that!”

Sylvia rolled her eyes. “Who cares?” She pointed out. “I don’t mind if Daddy looks at me or touches me. For someone who’s already attracted to him, it’s basically a do-nothing transformation. This is what’s best for both of us.”

Dani bit her lip. She wasn’t sure if she should do it. She was already pushing the envelope by putting herself in a situation where she would see the girl she had feelings for sleep with her best friend. That transformation was her only safety valve; could she really give it up? Just to see if her feelings about the matter were her own or not? And if they weren’t, did it even matter, if the return to her normal mental state was only temporary?

But she had to know.

Dawn raised her hand. “You know there’s an option on the purchase sheet to just suppress a transformation temporarily, right?” She pointed out. “So you don’t have to use your veto transformation if you want to stop that. It costs 3000 BP in the store. Suppress the effect of a transformation for one day.”

• 3000 BP: Suppress the effects of one Transformation for one day.

Everyone stared at her.

“Oh, gosh!” Sylvia gasped, her eyes widening. “I totally forgot! Good thinking, Dawn!”

“Oh, uh… yeah, that… that works,” Dani nodded. “Okay then, I guess I could buy that…” She summoned her screen, but Sylvia stopped her.

“Not a chance!” The blonde declared, shaking her head. “Allow me!”

And before anyone could stop her, the transaction went through.

Sylvia: 3500 BP – 3000 BP = 500 BP

Present…

“…You already told Nick, right?” Dani asked, squeezing Carly’s hand.

“Yeah,” Carly nodded. “And Holly probably filled in the rest. I’m surprised he agreed to it, but… he really does want us to be happy together.”

Dani didn’t miss the way Carly smiled when she said that. It stung.

“…This is going to sound awful,” she said quietly, turning to fully face her girlfriend, “but it’s something I need to get off my chest. Before… we do what we’re going to do.”

“Oh?” Carly tensed, not sure she liked the sound of that. “…What is it?”

Dani took a deep breath, and exhaled.

“I’m a little bit happy that you couldn’t fall in love with a guy,” she admitted. “Because I think… if you could… then you would have fallen for Nick a long time before you fell for me.”

It might have been a shitty thing to feel, but Dani was honest. Some would say to a fault.

But Carly didn’t hold her words against her. She just smiled.

“I’m glad, too,” she admitted, scooting a little closer to Dani and kissing her on the cheek. “I don’t know where this is going to go… but it’s really, really important to me. You, and your feelings.”

Dani’s face lit up crimson and the elevator doors opened.

When the two girls entered the Master’s Suite, they were surprised to find that they weren’t the most uncomfortable ones in the room.

“O-oh!” Nick nearly tripped over a chair getting up to greet them. “H-hey. How, um… how are things? You guys… girls… ready?”

Dani sighed and rolled her eyes. “Come on, Nick, please, can we not be weird about this?” She begged. “This is really important, for both of us.”

Nick winced. “I know that,” he said, sounding hurt. “You think I don’t know that? I’m not just some penis here, you two, I’m a part of this also. And if this is what your relationship needs to work, well… I’m willing to play my part.”

He couldn’t keep his eyes off Dani, and he couldn’t keep the guilt off of his face.

“…But I don’t want to hurt someone I care about.”

Dani’s face burned. The awkward tension in the air was reaching critical levels. But Carly was still holding her hand, and that’s how she knew everything was going to be fine.

But nobody knew how to start this.

“Come over here, Dani!”

Holly’s chirp smashed through the barrier surrounding the three of them, and they realized they weren’t along. Dani whirled around to look at the diminutive girl, crouched in a cage with an eager expression on her face. She patted a spot beside her on the ruined mattress and Dani’s mouth twisted into a shocked “O”.

“Come join me in the cuck cage!” Holly urged the other woman. “We’ll have a blast together!”

Shame spread through Dani like wildfire and she had to bite back a scream.

“Holly…” Nick groaned.

“It’s not like that!” Carly snapped. Her outburst shocked all four of them. Her eyes widened in surprise. “I-I mean… this isn’t, like… a cuck thing.”

“That’s right,” Dani nodded, her confidence resurging. She’d doubted, for a moment, and wondered if she was like Holly. But when Carly said that, she realized that it wasn’t the case.

She wasn’t getting off on the idea of Carly being stolen from her. Or the thought that she “wasn’t good enough” for her lover. This was about all three of them trying to make a very strange and uncomfortable relationship work, for all their sakes.

Holly’s little statement did have one positive, though.

All the tension the girls were feeling had evaporated. Dani was almost starting to get impatient.

She let go of Carly’s hand. She had to do it first; it would have hurt too much, to have Carly be the one to leave her. Then, she turned to the woman she loved, who was staring at her with a face filled with a wide variety of emotions. Excitement. Worry. Affection. Desire. And doubt.

“I love you,” Dani said firmly. She leaned in a little closer, but didn’t kiss Carly like she wanted to. She wanted to see if Carly would be the one to-

Before she could react, Carly surged forward and slammed their lips together. Dani could feel her tongue scraping around the inside of her mouth, but before she could regain her composure to do anything about it, Carly pulled away from her, face flushed and eyes wide.

“So, uh… yeah,” she mumbled, looking a little dazed. “Me too.”

She turned back to Nick, and then it was just the two of them. Dani thought it would hurt, seeing Carly’s eyes light up when they met his, but… it didn’t.

Carly was glowing, and that made her smile.

Carly leaned up and whispered something into Nick’s ear. Dani couldn’t hear what it was, but he relaxed when he heard it, and nodded, giving her a smile. A few seconds later, Carly began to strip out of her cosplay, undoing the laces on her top and letting her dress hit the floor. She was slow about it, tantalizingly slow, especially when it came to the stockings. She bent forward at a 90 degree angle, something completely impractical, and with her back to Dani, the tomboy knew there was only one reason for it.

She’s teasing me! The little minx! The sway of Carly’s ass as she slowly pulled down her striped socks had to be intentional. Carly wasn’t just trying to seduce Nick with her little strip show, she was keeping Dani engaged as well.

Then she felt a pair of eyes on her, and her head snapped up.

Nick was staring right at her. He’d seen her leering at Carly.

Dani felt a surge of guilt in her chest, especially when he quickly looked away. It felt like he’d intruded on a private moment between the two of them, and while Dani should have been upset with that, it didn’t bother her at all.

It almost felt like she should have expected it.

I don’t have my transformation right now, she thought, considering what that meant for her feelings towards Nick looking at her. He wasn’t checking her out, or looking at her in a sexual manner, but Carly standing naked between the two of them made the situation sexualized regardless. But it didn’t bother Dani as much as she thought it would.

Then, Carly leaned forward, and she started kissing Nick. And right away, Dani could sense a tangible difference there. Sure, Carly’s motions may have been the same, between the two of them, but she seemed hungrier when she kissed Nick. As if she’d kissed Dani for Dani’s sake, but was kissing Nick for herself.

And when he reached down and grabbed her ass, giving it a squeeze, the way her body flinched and the tiny moan that escaped her lips made it clear how turned on she was already.

Dani leaned in, eager to see more. Her heart raced in her chest and she found herself taking tiny, excited breaths as she realized just how damp she felt, watching Carly in action like this.

She’d seen Carly in a lot of sexual situations before, and even been on the receiving end of them once or twice. And that didn’t even get into all the pinup photos she’d viewed as one of the cosplayer’s top subscribers back on earth!

But this was different. This was Carly in her natural element, sleeping with a guy. Getting him worked up, cajoling him, whispering steamy, hot nothings into his ear as her hands ran all over his body, just caressing him, feeling him up like she couldn’t get enough. It had never been something she’d did with Dani, but with Nick…

Then, she latched onto the prize. While she slowly undid his belt and zipper with one hand, the other cradled the back of his head, running her fingers through his hair as they made out, and she slowly fished out his cock.

Dani winced. There it was. Nick’s penis. She’d seen it before, and it was just as hard now as it had been back in the sauna. And unlike at Mary’s wedding, she couldn’t politely look away. After all, this was for her sake. She had to prove she could do it! She’d been dreading this moment, and now that it came… It wasn’t as bad as she’d feared, actually?

Sure, there was nothing at all attractive about it. It was a cock, attached to a guy that she’d known for years. He was probably her closest friend, now that she and Carly had moved past that stage into a relationship. But she’d been expecting to be more… repulsed. Like when she had those dreams every night, or when Morgana gave her that fantasy.

But now, with Carly touching it all over and caressing it like it was the most precious thing in the world to her, it didn’t seem intimidating or threatening. It was just… a dick. And like it or not, she’d seen her fair share of them over the years.

Huh. Maybe I was so freaked out by what happened back then, that I built up the idea of Nick being sexual to be so much worse in my mind. Putting things into perspective like that helped Dani relax a little.

“Ooohnnn…”

And then there was Holly, who was practically orgasmic just by looking at it. Dani tore her eyes away from the sordid sight before her to look down at the caged little nymphet beside her, and honestly, she found that to be a lot more repulsive.

But… she understood. Seeing Carly get so sexual was getting her worked up too, and she rubbed her thighs together to try and fight off the heat building up in her nethers. It didn’t help that she was wearing such a provocative outfit, either. With her transformation temporarily removed, Dani knew that she’d react to Nick looking at her naturally; so she’d tried to **** it. She’d worn a bright blue dress, her very favorite, the one that showed off an amount of cleavage that could be considered obscene while also clinging to every curve of her body. If she could put up with his stares in that, she could put up with just about everything.

Nick wasn’t even looking at her, though. Why would he, with a hot and eager Carly Granger right in front of him, giving him everything he could ever want?

Knowing that no one was paying attention to her made Dani a little bolder. Her hand slowly inched down her waist, towards her pussy, and for a moment, she was tempted to indulge in her worst impulses, and pull her dress up right now to start playing with herself right there in front of everybody.

She didn’t though. Because they had already made it to the bed. And the sight of what was happening was more tantalizing than anything Dani could do to herself.

“Oh! Yes! Yes, please! Right there!”

Nick was sitting, and Carly was in his lap. But she’d gotten turned around somewhere along the way, because now she was arching her back up against his chest while her head rested on his shoulder, her body on full display for Dani’s viewing pleasure. She watched in rapt amazement as her breasts jumped about like water balloons as she bounced up and down on his cock.

Dani feasted on the sight before her eyes, and slowly sank to the floor. The strength had left her legs, and the urge to pleasure herself had never been stronger. But she continued to refrain, knowing that if she indulged, then it would be like admitting she really was a cuck. But she wasn’t! Nick barely entered her thoughts; Carly was the only thing her eyes captured, and for all it mattered to Dani, she could have been playing with a plastic dildo.

“Yeah, fuck, grab my tits!”

…A dildo with hands that could squeeze Carly’s funbags so hard they bulged, and fingers that could rub against her erect nipples.

A moan escaped Dani’s lips, and she realized, to her shame and embarrassment, that though she’d kept from dipping into her honeypot, her hands had other ideas. Right now, she was tweaking her own nipple, imagining it was her hands all over Carly’s tips… or Carly’s hands all over her tits… whatever, there were a lot of hands involved, and they were all bringing her pleasure, and that was what mattered!

Dani wondered, as she watched her lover’s face twist with ecstasy, if she could ever make Carly feel the way she was feeling right now.

Nick increased the pace, and Carly’s body began to shake even harder. Her head whipped around, smacking him in the face with her pigtails, and he reached up to grab one of them. That’s when Carly really screamed.

Dani winced in sympathy, knowing now how much it hurt to have her hair pulled (something that had never been a problem with her old style) but when Carly raised her head, she saw the glazed-over expression of bliss on the other woman’s face, and remembered one of the cosplayer’s other transformations.

Oh, that’s right! Her hair is an erogenous zone now, like Dawn’s tail! How could I have forgotten!? Realizing that brought a whole new level of naughty to the scene playing out before her. With red hair and pigtails, Carly could have easily been mistaken for Mary, especially with how full the farmgirl’s tits had been getting with milk recently. But now, Dani could only see them as a set of reins to pull on, to drive Carly to even greater heights of pleasure.

Dani wondered how Carly would react if she had tugged on her hair like that. Would it have felt good? Or not? Dani had never enjoyed it when boys touched her breasts or her vagina in the past. If Carly wasn’t attracted to her sexually, would she feel the same way?

That’s when inadequacy started to blossom in Dani’s chest, and she began to wonder if this was how Holly felt.

That’s right, no matter how much we like being together, Carly’s into guys. I could never make her feel as good as Nick does. But I knew that already, didn’t I?

With that epiphany, everything changed in an instant. Dani couldn’t block Nick out anymore. It wasn’t just Carly pleasuring himself with his body, they were taking pleasure in each other. And no matter how much Dani tried not to look at him, she couldn’t separate the two any longer.

Nick was pleasuring Carly. He was making love to the woman she cared so deeply for, and Carly had never looked more radiant in her life.

Then, she felt two pairs of eyes on her, and she froze. She realized in that moment, as the couple looked at her, just what state she was in.

One hand had been in the process of giving her boob the fondling of its life, while her other had grown more daring, taking part in that taboo pleasure that she’d been able to resist for so long. But feeling the sticky wetness running down her fingers, she understood shamefully well that she’d finally given in.

If Dani thought that the two of them remembering she was there would have caused them to stop, or even slow down, then she was dead wrong. In fact, Carly sped up, moving even faster up and down Nick’s shaft as he thrust deeper inside of her, and if that wasn’t bad enough, she was moaning even louder than before, shouting at the top of her lungs about how good this felt and how much she loved getting fucked this hard, when she wasn’t just grunting out incoherent moans.

Then she cried something that would stick in Dani’s head forever.

“DANI!” Carly moaned, throwing back her head.

Her name.

Carly was calling out her name.

It took Dani a second to process that. It couldn’t be the case, right? There was no way that Carly would be calling out to her, not while Nick was fucking her like that.

But then, Carly lowered her head and her eyes met Dani’s again, and in that moment Dani knew. She could see it in the other woman’s heated gaze, and while Carly couldn’t get out the words, her lips spelled out a plea that her heart registered in an instant.

“Come here,” Carly mouthed, and Dani’s heart skipped a beat.

Like a woman possessed, Dani rose shakily to her feet and stumbled forward, almost in a trance as she approached the bed. It was like she was still a spectator, watching her body go through the motions as she stood in front of the fucking couple and basked in their gazes.

It didn’t feel strange or awful to have Nick look at her, not like she’d feared. Not when she had Carly there as well. While her lover’s eyes lacked the heated desire that she aimed towards Nick, she felt something deeper in that stare, something more sensual and intimate.

Dani watched herself lean forward and press her lips against Carly’s in a sensual kiss. In an instant, she was dragged back into her body, and suddenly she was a part of it, all of it. She felt her own hands meet Nick’s over Carly’s breasts as they loved her together, and she heard Carly moan into her mouth as Nick bucked up into her. Her girlfriend leaned forward, supporting herself using Carly’s body as Nick pushed forward, and it felt as if he was fucking Carly into her almost.

Then Carly’s hands started to wander. They were cautious, for a moment, as if she wasn’t sure if she should go through it or not. But whatever reservations she may have had were quickly pushed aside as she started caressing Dani’s breasts, buttocks, and thighs, running her hands over every surface she could touch.

It wasn’t supposed to go this way. Dani was just supposed to watch. She was just supposed to be a witness, so she would know for certain whether or not this was a dynamic that she could live with.

Screw living with it. Dani had never felt hotter in her life! Knowing that Carly wasn’t sexually attracted to her, but still couldn’t keep her hands off of her brought a strange sense of vindicated triumph to the energized tomboy, almost like she was stealing her back from Nick somehow. But that was insane. Carly wasn’t something to be stolen or won. She was a woman who took pleasure where she could find it, both romantic and sexual, and as their lips parted and Carly slumped into Dani’s chest as she moaned out another orgasm from Nick’s cock, Dani looked past her lover and met Nick’s eyes for the first time.

He was as worked up as she was, and if his expression was anything to go by, he was just as shocked. Neither one knew what to make of the situation, and but as they fucked Carly between the two of them, they realized that something important was happening here.

What that important thing was, though, was something neither of them could figure out in their current state of mind. So Dani said “fuck it” and grabbed Carly again, forcing the kiss onto her this time, as the three approached their climax together.

And when a burning “I love you” touched Dani’s ear, she didn’t know if it had come from Carly’s lips, Nick’s lips, or her own.