Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 319 by Exarch-of-Sechrima Exarch-of-Sechrima

Nice to know a good time is approaching!

Where the kisses are hers and hers and his

Nick had been waiting for a long time.

“What’s taking them so long?” Holly asked. Her anxiety was clear on her face. “They’re supposed to be here by six! Promptly! And it’s past six already, right?!”

Nick glanced at the golden grandfather clock in the den of the suite. The minute arrow was getting awfully close to 6:30.

“Something must have happened,” he said, frowning. “That’s the only explanation.”

There was no way Dakota would allow Carly to be late for her night with him. Not Dakota. She was punctual to a fault.

If his partner for the night wasn’t here, the only reason that could be was because Dakota allowed it. And Nick wasn’t sure if that was a good thing or not.

Right now, there was a lot on his mind. He could sense tension between Dani and Carly; it had been present for days! And the siren hadn’t improved matters. And now, Carly just happened to be late? No, that couldn’t be a coincidence. The events had to be tied together.

Did Dani agree to let the siren stay with us? Is this a result of that? Nick couldn’t help but wonder. Dakota had promised risks and consequences, but then again, she could have just been bluffing and manipulating.

He honestly didn’t know.

Then, a knock on the door dispelled his worries. He and Holly glanced at each other, and sighed in relief.

“That must be them, now,” Nick said, getting up and walking over to the door. He was stunned by who greeted him when he opened it.

Nick had been expecting two women; after all, Carly never went anywhere without her sister.

But it wasn’t Marley standing at Carly’s side when the door opened.

“Bonjour,” Rose greeted him with a sly smile, sashaying into the Master’s Suite. She put an extra bit of sway into her hips as she entered, giving him a hot wink.

Nick was at a loss for words. All he could do was turn to Carly, who could only offer him an awkward shrug in place of an explanation.

So he decided to verbalize his confusion.

“…Why’s Rose here?” He asked, peeking over Carly’s shoulder to try and spot her sister. “And where’s Marley?”

Carly sighed. The expression on her face caused Nick to completely reevaluate his position.

“Carly? Is everything alright?” He asked, concerned.

“It’s… this whole thing,” Carly said. “I upgraded my transformation tonight, letting me assign another contestant to… well, I guess ‘babysit’ is the word the transformation used, so…”

Nick blinked. “…Babysit?”

Carly nodded.

“Well… isn’t that good, then?” He asked, trying to improve the atmosphere with a smile. “You’ve been wanting to have some time to yourself without Marley for a while now, haven’t you? So now you two can finally be on your own!”

“Yeah, I know, it’s great, it’s just… the reason for it isn’t so great,” Carly mumbled, sighing again. Then, she realized how her attitude was dragging things down, and **** a smile. “Okay, look, so it’s like this, alright? Dani and I, we… we sort of confessed our feelings for one another.”

Nick’s eyes bulged out of his head.

“What?! Really?” Holly gasped in surprise.

“Carly, that… that’s great?” Nick wasn’t sure what to make of that, honestly. “I-I didn’t know, that you two were…”

“We’re not,” she said quickly. “I mean, it’s complicated… look, the thing is… I really like you, Nick, really, I do. Out of all the guys I’ve slept with, you and I, we just… we click, you know?”

“Um, thanks,” Nick said, feeling happy to hear that, but still very confused.

“But we both know, I don’t like you that way,” she continued. “You’re a special guy to me… but Dani’s more special. I really, really like her… I think I love her. But… I’m not attracted to her. Physically, I mean.”

Nick tried to wrap his brain around that.

“So, wait, you want to date Dani, but you don’t feel like having sex with her?” He asked. “Is that… does that sound right?”

Carly nodded. “That’s it, basically… but no, it doesn’t sound right, does it? It sounds really, really weird.”

Nick could definitely agree to that.

“That’s why I invited Rose,” Carly said, looking over Nick’s shoulder towards Rose, who was busy making herself at home. “Because… I wanted to see if I could be with a woman. You know… sexually. I mean, I have before, but I didn’t get anything out of it… and I really, really want to try. For Dani’s sake. So… could we? Have a threesome, I mean.”

Holly let out a little joyful squeak from her cage.

Nick was at a loss for words.

“A… a threesome?” He stammered.

“Y-yeah, look, you don’t have to do anything special,” Carly said quickly. “I’m going to try to make sure that all three of us are enjoying ourselves, it’s just… with Rose in the mix, her transformation should do a lot of the heavy lifting.”

Rose licked her lips. “I sure hope so.”

“Ah, so that’s why she’s here,” Nick said, glancing back at the blonde.

Rose’s jaw dropped, and she held her hand over her heart.

“Come now, Nick! That’s not a nice thing to say!” She pouted. “I want to have my fun too, you know!”

Nick rolled his eyes and smiled in exasperation. “Uh-huh. Definitely no ulterior motives there, huh?”

Rose offered a cheeky smirk as her only response.

Nick looked back and forth between the two girls.

“…Well, obviously, I’m okay with this,” he pointed out. “But don’t think it’s on me to know how to start one of these. This isn’t exactly something I have a lot of experience with.”

Carly cracked a smile.

“That’s fine,” she assured him, reaching back and undoing the zipper on her dress. It fell to the floor, revealing that she wasn’t wearing anything underneath it but her stockings. “We can all have some fun together.”

She stepped forward and pressed her lips against his, kissing him before he had a chance to respond. Nick’s eyes widened in surprise but he sank into the kiss, grabbing Carly by her shoulders and holding her close.

“Hey!” Rose pouted, storming over to the kissing pair. “This is a threesome, remember? I want to get in on this, too!”

She grabbed Nick’s chin and pulled him away from Carly, taking her opportunity to kiss him next. And now that Rose had gotten involved, her transformation sparked, and a wave of pleasure surged through both of them, putting an abrupt end to the kiss as they both let out a sigh.

“Wh-whoa,” Rose stammered, turning red. “That was…”

“Yeah…” Nick couldn’t really say anything else. He was hard as a rock just from a few simple kisses.

Rose’s Marital Aide transformation didn’t mess around.

“Oh, fuck…” Holly whimpered from her cage, cutting through the haze of confusion that covered the trio. “That’s so hot…”

Carly and Rose shared a look, and both knew exactly what the other was thinking. They each grabbed Nick by one hand, and brought him over to the bed. He wasn’t exactly resisting.

Nick lay down on the bed while Rose stripped off her clothes, getting fully naked in contrast to Carly who left on her stockings. The two topless girls crawled all over him, wearing wicked expressions as their fingers danced across his trousers.

“So what now?” Rose asked, her playful voice mixed with intense desire. “How should we start this?”

She was excited, but surprisingly bashful. After all, she’d only had sex once, a few nights ago. (Well, it may have been a few times…)

It was up to Carly to take the lead with this.

Carly swallowed, feeling a little antsy. Staring across at Rose with Nick between the two of them made this feel a lot more real.

But this was the kind of stuff she was made for! The sensuality, the passion, she wasn’t about to let any hesitation stop her, not now! She felt charged with excitement!

“To start, I want to thank my favorite guy here for being so nice, and helping me out with my little experiment,” she breathed, slowly dragging down his zipper. The sound of metal sliding against metal filled the room as everyone waited with bated breath. Before long, Nick’s pants were down, and his cock was up.

Carly and Rose both eyed it with a hunger that would make Gina blush, but neither wanted to seize the initiative from the other.

Nick cleared his throat, capturing the attention of both girls.

“I’m a little surprised,” he teased. “I thought if anyone would be eager to get started, it would be the two of you!”

Rose made a face. “Oh, really?”

“That sounds like a challenge, to me,” Carly said, cracking a smile. She had nothing but appreciation for Nick, breaking the tension like that.

She shared another look with her blonde partner in crime, taking a second to admire her curvy figure. This was about more than just pleasing Nick, after all, she was trying to see if she could be attracted to women. And they didn’t make ‘em more attractive than Rose. With her tight waist, model good looks, and heavy chest, Rose looked like she’d stepped right off the cover of a magazine.

It was that “heavy chest” that gave Carly her first idea.

Nick watched as Carly leaned over and whispered something to the other woman. He was growing a little impatient. His dick was exposed in the cold air, and Holly seemed to be giving it more attention than either of them, judging by her hot pants of excitement.

Then, the two girls turned their playful eyes his way, and he felt his cock jump.

Oh, yeah, he was excited to see what they came up with.

“Rose and I were just talking,” Carly purred, slipping down a little lower until her face was right next to Nick’s throbbing erection. “About how we could please this monster together. She thought that a double blowjob would be a good place to start.”

Nick winced, and nodded eagerly at the idea, feeling her hot breath tickle against his shaft. It felt like his dick was getting harder every second she stared at it!

“…It would be something, wouldn’t it?” Rose smirked. “The two of us, our tongues lashing all over the place… and you’re certainly big enough for us to both handle at once!” She reached down and gave his head a teasing flick. It would have hurt under normal circumstances, but due to her transformation the amplified pleasure more than overpowered any potential pain. Nick groaned and arched his back.

“Fuck, that sounds so hot,” he groaned.

“Oooh, I think he likes the idea!” Rose tittered.

“Of course he does,” Carly chuckled. “But… then I got to thinking. Why just a blowjob? Any girl in your harem could do that, and Gina gives you, what, five a day? So I was thinking, what about something a little more special? Something only a couple of girls built like Rose and I could- would do for you?”

Nick’s cock throbbed. He liked where this was going.

“Oh, really?” He asked coolly. “Like what?”

Carly leaned up a little more, taking her teasing breath away from his erection. Then she cupped the sides of her giant breasts and gave them a nice shake.

“Well… I know how much you like my tits,” she moaned, not expecting touching her breasts to feel so good. Rose’s transformation was really doing a number on them. “And Rose might not be as big as me, but she’s certainly not lacking in that area.”

It took everything Nick had to tear his eyes away from Carly’s chest to look at Rose’s. No, she definitely was not.

“So how about… a double boobjob?” Rose suggested with a sly smile, moving down to match Carly’s position. “Your hard, throbbing cock… and two pairs of large boobs… sounds like a match made in heaven, to me.”

Nick couldn’t agree to that fast enough. He nodded his head so hard, for a second he was afraid it might fall off.

That was enough for the two of them.

Carly and Rose sandwiched Nick’s cock between their breasts, and a burst of pleasure shot through all three of them.

“OH!” Rose moaned.

“Fuck, yeah…” Carly grunted, clenching her thighs together.

“Fucking god, fuck!” Nick’s pleasure overshadowed both of theirs by a lot. It was a minor miracle he didn’t cum right then and there!

The sensation was too much to bear. He had two sets of breasts pushed in against his penis, surrounding his erection on all sides.

It was transcendent! Boobjobs were a rare pleasure that he’d only gotten a few times before. But those had always been one on one with the girls. Right now, he was dealing with twice the amount of boobage, and that wasn’t even considering volume! Mary’s massive milkers could compete with Carly’s on a good day, but throw Rose in the mix as well, and it was just overwhelming! Her more modest endowments fought for space against Carly’s gigantic gazongas, pushing insistently against them to get around as much of Nick’s cock as they could! And while this was happening, two sets of nipples continued to brush up against one another, spurring both girls closer and closer to the edge.

But no matter how much pleasure the women were getting from the titjob, Nick was getting more. His penis throbbed and shook, trembling as if it couldn’t believe the pleasure it was getting to indulge in. No matter where it tried to escape, there was just more hot, sticky flesh to press against it, like the two women were trying to smother the fire in his loins with their cleavage!

Finally, it chose to run in the only direction it could: up. The head of Nick’s cock, angry and throbbing reddish-purple, broke out of the pile of titmeat a warrior rising up for one last battle. And no matter how hard the girls tried to squash it back down, molding and pressing their chests as hard as they could to try and bury it again, it refused to settle. Not until it bathed its surroundings in a sea of raging sperm.

Of course, there was nothing either girl would like better.

“It’s sooooo hot!” Carly moaned, bucking her hips. She practically humped the bed as she molested her own chest, trying to maximize the pleasure for both of them.

Rose had an idea of her own, through her hazy moans.

“H-hey…” She said, turning to look Carly in the eye. “What if we… increased the pressure… oh!” Her head jerked back as her hips twitched. She’d nearly cum, without even touching herself! Fuck, why does my transformation have to feel this good!? She wailed internally. I’m supposed… supposed-! I’m- fuck! I’m supposed to be the sexy seductress, fuck! I can’t-fuck, mon dieu, I need to… I’m going fucking crazy!

Rose couldn’t verbalize her thoughts at this point, she was too overwhelmed by the pleasure raging through her. So she had to express herself with actions. She let go of her tits, reducing the pressure on Nick’s cock to the disappointment of all three of them, but then leaned forward and wrapped her arms around Carly’s back.

It took Carly a second to figure out what was going on in the heat of the moment, but when she felt Rose hugging her, she got it.

The idea brought a wicked smile to her lips, and she did the same, hugging the blonde girl back.

As the two held each other close, the resulting pressure from their tits completely changed. Instead of using their hands to mold and press them into Nick’s cock, the **** of their hug mashed their chests into his dick instead. It was the kind of maneuver you could only do if you were suitably gifted in this area; someone like Sylvia or Kim never would have been able to manage it, it would just hurt. But Rose had just enough titmeat to pull it off, and of course, Carly had no problems whatsoever.

The only person who had a problem was Nick.

“Fuck, you two… that’s-! Fuck, you fucking evil genius, Rose!” He cursed, digging his fingers into the sheets. His dick felt like it was vacuum-sealed inside of their tits! The pressure right now was nothing compared to before, there wasn’t a scrap of flesh below his glans that wasn’t completely smothered in boob! He never would have thought of something so sinfully pleasurable in his life! Roaring with madness he bucked his hips, fucking up into the tight seal like a pussy. His dick throbbed angrily, only getting hotter and more **** with each passing second.

Needless to say, he couldn’t last long.

SPUUUURRRTT!

Semen sprayed out of Nick’s cock like a juice box getting crushed. He doused both girls in white, covering their faces, their throats, and as much cleavage as his seed could reach.

Boobjob! (Carly) +3 VP!

Boobjob! (Rose) +3 VP!

Facial! (Rose) +2 VP

The two women pulled back from each other, taking a moment to catch their breath. That had been more intense than anyone had expected. That double boobjob could have replaced the sex they would be having later, and no one here would have complained!

And it looked like that might end up happening, because once Nick’s cock was released from the prison of titflesh, it dropped down, worn out and flaccid. But nobody complained. They were too busy focusing on the amazing pleasure that the three of them had shared.

“Mm… fuck… that was so hot…” Rose moaned, licking her lips and feeling the taste of Nick’s seed flood her mouth.

“You’re telling me…” Carly reached up and wiped some of his semen from her cheek. “I’ve given titjobs before, but that was a whole other world…”

“So what did you think?” Nick asked. “Sharing it with Rose, I mean? Was it… did you enjoy it?”

“I-I did,” Carly admitted, her face heating up under the coating of semen. “But then… I expected that, right? Since I was pleasuring you… I’d have to do something with her as the focus, in order to…”

Both girls were busy scooping up Nick’s seed and moving it towards their lips. Rose tried to be more surreptitious about it to preserve her dignity, but Carly just went all-in.

Seeing the two of them enjoying his semen brought a rather perverse idea to Nick’s mind, and one he was excited to share with the girls.

“How about this?” He suggested. “Why don’t the two of you make out? That way, you can try and see if any sparks flare up. Plus, I’m not exactly fully recovered after what just happened…” He gestured to his softening cock, which was making a great effort, but clearly not succeeding.

“…Men,” Carly scoffed, rolling her eyes and grinning from ear to ear. “Should have known he’d suggest that.”

“Well, I mean…” Rose blushed, more out of embarrassment than desire, though. “I haven’t really done much kissing with other girls… but I guess we could try it?”

“Sure thing,” Nick encouraged. “Just think of it like acting! You’re playing the part of a bisexual girl in a threesome, **** to taste her lover’s seed off her other lover’s mouth!”

Now it was Rose’s turn to roll her eyes. She was about to call Nick out for such a dumb proposal (although she definitely still would have gone through with it) before it was taken out of her hands completely.

Scenes From a Hat: I Kissed a Girl, and I Liked It

Rose’s jaw dropped. She’d almost forgotten about that little gem, it had been so long since the last time it triggered.

Still, it wasn’t a big deal. It wasn’t as if Rose wasn’t going to agree in the first place.

“Well… I guess we don’t have a choice, eh?” She smirked, turning back to Carly. The other girl blushed, and nodded.

“Let’s do it, then,” Carly agreed, hoping that she was hot enough to actually enjoy herself.

The two girls leaned in, their lips getting close. Nick leaned in as well, eager to get a good look at what promised to be a very sexy scene.

Carly said that she didn’t find women attractive, and Rose had made it very clear that she was straight. But you certainly wouldn’t be able to tell that by watching them kiss.

Rose initiated, which was a surprise, given she was the more chaste of the two of them. But then, Rose was the actress here. She used all of her skills to put on a performance, showing the audience, and Nick, exactly what they wanted to see. (And Holly, too, judging by the moans coming from across the room.)

Her tongue slipped past Carly’s lips, and Carly allowed it. She closed her eyes and let it happen, allowing Rose to make out with her for a couple seconds before starting to reciprocate. The taste of Nick’s semen was traded between the two of them as their hands reached up to touch each other’s chests. Rose went first, again, clearly leading the scene, while Carly was far more ****. Then, Carly reached up to Rose’s cheek, and wiped off a strand of semen before bringing it to the gap where their lips met. Rose did the same, and they cleaned each other as they made out, which only seemed to work them up even more.

Nick studied the two of them closely. Purely for intellectual reasons, of course. Because he wanted to see if Carly would really respond to the kiss of another woman. If it would feel pleasurable for her. That was why they were here, after all!

And regardless of what his hardening cock had to say about the matter, it was NOT because he wanted to watch two of the sexiest women he’d ever been with pleasure each other.

…Wow, didn’t they need to breathe?

After what felt like a dozen minutes at least, Rose and Carly finally separated, gasping for air. Their faces were both flushed, and cleaned of just about all traces of Nick’s ejaculation.

“So… that was… something, huh?” Rose said, not sure what to make of it.

“…Yeah…” Carly had a dazed look on her face that reminded Nick of when her sister was a slime girl. “Yeah, it was…”

Both girls clearly needed a moment to process what was going on, and Nick was the only one currently “present”. Which wasn’t great, because his erection had come back with a vengeance, and he really needed somebody to take care of it.

He was about five seconds away from going to get Holly out of her cage when Rose came crashing back down to earth first.

“Okay! So… that just happened,” she said, shaking her head and making her curls bounce. They had been matted to her nape from sweat. She glanced hotly over to Nick, and licked her lips. “But I think somebody’s back in action, if you know what I mean…”

Carly swallowed and nodded. “Y-yeah,” she agreed, the playful spark soon returning to her eyes as she admired Nick’s cock. “I think we need to get started with the fun stuff.”

Nick was all for that. But now that they’d moved past the foreplay, they’d arrived at a math problem not even Dawn could derive a solution for. Two hot girls ready to fuck, and only one hard cock to split between them.

These were the conundrums that kept the ancient philosophers up at night, Nick was sure.

“How do we determine who goes first?” Rose asked. “Flip a coin?”

“We could do rock-paper-scissors for it,” Carly suggested.

“How about you, Carly?” Nick suggested, pointing his dick towards the cosplayer. “After all, tonight IS your night. It only makes sense that you get the first go, right?”

“Oh, so I’m just an afterthought, then?” Rose pouted, crossing her arms over her chest. Before anyone could respond, she quickly grinned. “I’m kidding.”

Nick shrugged. It honestly didn’t matter to him which sexy girl he had sex with first.

“Wh-why don’t you go first?” Carly offered to Rose. “I think I still need to get a little more worked-up… that way, when it’s my turn…”

“Ah, seizing all the pleasure for yourself?” Rose tittered. “I should have expected as much… but don’t worry, I’m fine with that. Too bad, though… I was thinking of maybe edging myself, watching you two go at it… get some nice BP from my bounty sheet… but no fucking way. I’m not going all night without an orgasm.”

And with that, she pounced. She planted kisses all along Nick’s jawline and neck, taking care not to touch his lips. She could still taste his semen in her mouth, and was considerate enough to spare him the same.

Then she reached his hard cock, and gave it a nice, long lick. Once she planted a kiss on the head, she scooted back up and whispered into his ear, “We did it missionary style our first night together… and it was the most romantic thing I ever felt.” Her voice was surprisingly tender and gentle, given the steamy situation they found themselves in.

She wasn’t done, though. “Carly, on the other hand… she doesn’t want romantic. She wants pleasure. So why not take me from behind… and let me handle the rest?”

Nick blinked. “Doggystyle?”

Rose turned red. “D-don’t call it that!” She scolded him with a swat. “You make me sound like a-! Just… you, you know what to do, so…”

In spite of her studies and practice, Rose still hadn’t experienced a lot for herself. She knew the positions, but had no idea how it would feel. So while she climbed onto her hands and knees and began to sway her ass to tease Nick a little bit, she had no idea how amazing it would feel to have him actually thrust inside of her.

“AWW, FUCK!” She moaned, arching her back. Her arms instantly gave out and she fell face-first onto the mattress. “Doggystyle” had turned into a prone bone in the span of a couple seconds as Rose came instantaneously, flooding the bed with her juices as her eyes rolled up into her head.

“My… it looks like someone isn’t as experienced as she boasts,” Carly laughed, scooting over to get a closer look at the trembling blonde. “Was she that much of a quickshot when you were together the first time?”

“Sh-shut up!” Rose managed to pull herself up onto her elbows and looked over her shoulder at Carly, giving her a withering glare. “I-I’m doing this for- FUCK! For you, after all!” She spat. “The least you could do it- ahn! Oui, right there! Fuck!”

She bit down on her lip, practically making herself bleed. The last thing she needed right now was to start squealing in French right in front of Carly, and Holly, for that matter.

At least she could take care of one of those problems.

“H-Holly!” She spat out, not even having the strength to look towards the cage. It took all she had just to stay afloat as the waves of pleasure crashed down into her. “You can fucking cum!”

THAT was sure something.

It took a second to register, but then the tiny yips and yelps coming from the cage gave way to a deafening moan that filled the suite, drowning out even Rose’s passionate cries. Even from all the way on the bed, the banging couple could hear the sounds of Holly’s juices flooding her cage as she finally, FINALLY got her chance to cum, after who knows how long she’d spent going without.

Unfortunately for Rose, it didn’t have the intended effect. She’d hoped that Holly’s orgasm would have taken Nick’s attention, but apparently he knew what she was after, because he hadn’t let up for a second. She didn’t want to give in, she didn’t! No matter how hard that burning hot cock insisted on it! But she couldn’t help herself, this felt so much better than the night they’d shared together, even if it didn’t touch her soul in quite the same way.

Rose had expected hot and dirty. She wasn’t even looking at Nick, the only sign he was even there was the feeling of his strong hands wrapped around her waist, and his hard cock buried in her pussy. This was supposed to be the kind of sex you weren’t supposed to fall in love with, the sleezy sex only for pleasure!

So why did that jerkface have to keep making her feel so loved, damn it!? It was infuriating! The one time Rose actually wanted to be a sexy, superficial seductress, and she couldn’t even do that right! How could she hold her head up as a dignified actress if she couldn’t even play a slut properly?!

“W-wow…” Carly licked her lips. “That’s actually… really hot, seeing you two go at it like that…”

“I know,” Nick groaned. “Fuck! She’s so fucking sexy!” He slapped her ass, grabbing a nice, meaty handful of her booty, and Rose twitched. She definitely hadn’t given him permission for THAT, but… who fucking cared?! As far as she was concerned right now, Gina had the right fucking idea. Being a submissive sex **** felt pretty damn good.

“More!” She groaned, using a bit of her remaining strength to push back against him, burying his cock even deeper inside of her as she pressed her ass against his crotch. “Again!”

Who was this slutty girl begging for a spanking? Because it sure wasn’t Rose.

Nick was happy to oblige her, though. Rose had been a bit of a bitch for the last few days, and it felt really damn good, spanking her like that.

“Hey, uh… do you mind… if I try?” Carly wondered, leaning in and studying the red marks beginning to form on Rose’s tight apple bottom.

Nick, too lost in the heat of the moment to consider all the details of the situation, just nodded. If Carly wanted to be attracted to women, playing with a woman like the one in his arms was a good place to start.

Carly took a deep breath, wound back her hand, and gave her ass a nice, meaty smack.

“OH FUCK!”

The tremor from her hand surged up Rose’s ass, into her spine, and caused her whole body to shake. She arched her back into Nick with a moan as she came on the spot again.

Thankfully, the orgasm was enough to bring her back to her senses.

“HEY!” She snapped, looking over her shoulder. “Hands off the merchandise!”

Carly paled. “B-but…”

“Nick’s fine, but you… you, come over here!”

Rose smacked the mattress in front of her, and Carly crawled over instantly. She felt a wave of guilt rising up, after having done something Rose technically hadn’t consented to.

But when she looked into Rose’s eyes, the blonde was all smiles.

“Now that…” Her voice cracked, breaking into a moan. “…THAT was real fucking good… let me… mm, fuck… let me return the favor…”

Carly shivered. “You, uh… you want to spank me? Because that…”

“No, no…” Rose shook her head, an action that looked rather odd given how it was bobbing around on her shoulders from Nick’s thrusts. “At least… not yet… No, I want… to do other things with you…”

Her laughter sounded odd, mixed with her moans. Carly bit her lip, and nodded.

She’d soon regret it.

Rose lunged forward, grabbing Carly’s stockings. She dug her fingers into the dark fabric that covered her pussy; soaked, just like Rose had expected.

She looked up at Carly with an evil gleam in her eye.

“These aren’t your clothes, so it doesn’t matter what we do with them, right?” She tittered. And with a few sharp tugs, she tore a hole through Carly’s stockings to reveal her steamy, moist peach beneath them.

Carly moaned.

“Now… you just stay still…” Rose leaned in close. Her face was hot with embarrassment. She didn’t want to do this, she really didn’t. The thought of licking another woman’s vagina didn’t really appeal to her, but she had to do it for the sake of the threesome, and her own interests. “I haven’t… I’ve never done this before…”

She gave it a light lick, just to taste. It wasn’t the best flavor. Nick’s cock tasted a lot better, for sure. But this wasn’t about her right now, it was about Carly. And judging by the juices that flooded her mouth, Carly was certainly appreciating it.

“Fuck, yes! That’s so good!” The other girl moaned, bucking her hips, pushing her pussy up into Rose’s mouth before she had a chance to say anything.

That wasn’t exactly appreciated. But it was certainly a good sign, if Carly was getting into it.

The feeling of Carly’s fingers wrapping into her hair? A less good sign.

“Fuck! Right there! Don’t stop!” Carly’s moans filled the air, along with Nick’s grunts. And Rose ended up the monkey in the middle.

Rose couldn’t exactly pull out of Carly’s snatch if she wanted to, not with the other girl’s grip as strong as it was. But hey, that’s the reason she was here, right? To make things better for the two involved. And Carly needed to have as much girl-girl contact as possible for her experiment to bear fruit.

You’re gonna owe me big time after this, cosplay girl! Rose silently promised, working harder with her tongue.

The problem with getting a girl like Rose to do this, though, was that she had no idea what she was doing. Oh, she’d played with herself on occasion, but she only had a bit of experience with Nick. She knew what felt good for her, but on another girl?

That was trickier.

Fortunately, Carly was very receptive to her touch, and Rose’s Marital Aide was putting in work. It wasn’t long before Carly was on the brink of orgasm, which was good.

Rose could hardly stay conscious with how much pleasure Nick was giving her poor, brutalized little pussy.

…Or maybe it was oxygen deprivation. Either way, when Carly finally arched her back and came, practically cramming Rose’s mouth into her crotch, Rose felt a wave of relief wash over her along with the wave of pussy juice.

Rose: 5400 BP + 500 BP = 5900 BP

Carly’s hand fell limply to her side, and she slumped back, panting for air. She could barely keep her eyes open as she stared down at Rose, who lifted up her head, her face glazed over with vaginal discharge and her hair ruined.

Rose was redfaced and unamused, but that only lasted for a moment, because right then, Nick thrust in as deep as he could go, another orgasm pushed her over the edge.

“FUCK!” She groaned, falling limply onto the bed as Nick pulled out of her to spray her back with semen.

Rose was really a target today, wasn’t she?

“That… fuck, that was amazing…” Nick groaned.

“You’re telling me…” Rose could barely remain conscious she’d come so hard, and so many times. “Wow…”

“W-we’re not done yet, right?” Carly asked, looking desperately at Nick. To her relief, his dick was still hard as a rock this time.

“Don’t worry,” Nick promised her, wiping his forehead. He was a little out of breath after just plowing into Rose as hard as he did. “I just need a moment… a moment to… fuck…”

“We just had that…” Rose panted. She tried to sound amused, but really, she just felt exhausted. She might end up sitting this one out. She tried to climb up onto her hands and knees, but even that felt like a chore.

Still, she needed to. She had stuff to do. Debts to repay… and collect on.

“Um, sorry about before,” Carly said, blushing. “I got caught up in the heat of the moment. I shouldn’t have grabbed your hair like that.”

“Oh, you mean my precious hair that I got from my maman?” Rose said snootily. “No, you shouldn’t have!”

Then her expression softened. “Just to be clear, Carly, the only reason I ate you out like that, is because one of my bounties wanted me to bring a girl to orgasm in front of Nick. I’d say that’s a success, wouldn’t you?” She tittered.

Carly laughed. “You got me there…”

“And since edging’s out of the question, there’s one more bounty you can help me collect on,” Rose said, a saccharine smile on her face. But Carly could see some malice behind it. “You won’t mind doing it doggystyle with Nick as well, right?”

“Uh…”

“You won’t mind, right?” Rose insisted.

Well… Carly was up for just about anything, and doggystyle always felt good when she did it before. So she assumed the position.

“Hey, uh… but doesn’t Nick need some time to recover?” Carly asked, looking over her shoulder.

Rose answered that with a swift smack to Carly’s bottom.

“Yow! Hey!”

“That’s payback,” Rose tittered, tenderly rubbing the spot she’d just hit. “Don’t worry, the next ones will be lighter.”

“…Next ones?! But I only spanked you once!”

“I know, but my bounty says that I have to spank you at least five times, or it doesn’t count. Come on, after I agreed to come have a threesome with you, you won’t even let me have this?” Rose whined. “I just ate you out to orgasm, and everything!”

That had been for money, but Carly understood just how big of a favor Rose was doing for her, so she obliged.

“Besides, think of it as working up Nick even more,” Rose encouraged, giving her another swat. This one was much lighter, per her word. “Come on, only three left!”

SMACK! SMACK! SMACK!

She delivered the next three in swift succession, and her BP jumped again.

Rose: 5900 BP + 300 BP = 6200 BP

Carly sighed in relief. It was finally done. Now all that was left was the pleasure of Nick’s penis lodging itself inside of her-

“…And one more good measure!”

SMACK!

“HEY!” Carly exclaimed. THAT certainly hadn’t been part of the deal!

“Sorry, couldn’t help myself,” Rose apologized. “But still, three smacks to each cheek, that way you’re symmetrical! Okay, have fun!”

Carly only had a few seconds to process what Rose meant by that, before two strong hands grabbed her waist.

Then she felt Nick’s hot cock shove up inside her.

“OH, FUCK!” Carly moaned, shaking as she nearly came instantaneously. She’d had sex with Nick quite a few times, but it had never felt like THIS!

“Fuck, Carly, you feel amazing,” Nick groaned, thrusting into her as hard as he could. It was a marvel that he could have withstood the pleasure of being inside Rose for as long as he had; he would have cum instantly if not for that first orgasm wearing him out!

This was very much the same. Carly’s insides were tight and hot and clutched him hard, practically sucking on him like a mouth. Whenever he tried to pull out, it felt like she was dragging him back inside her cavern! It was a struggle just thrusting inside of her!

“She’s so hot…” Rose murmured, pulling up next to Nick. He could see that she was struggling to stay upright, but her eyes were hot with desire. “And that body… no wonder Dani fell for her. Even I could forget that I’m straight, looking at a body like that…”

Nick wasn’t sure if she was telling the truth, or if this was Rose just trying to turn him on. Whether that was her intention or not, she sure succeeded.

“Mary’s a bit of a cow, but this one… imagine if she started lactating too, just like her?” Rose tittered. “She’d be a real cow then, huh?”

The thought of Carly and Mary standing next to each other, their nipples leaking milk as they offered them up to Nick to feast on, soon pushed him over the edge. He wished he could last longer, he really did. But with Rose whispering sex into his ear, and Carly wrapping his dick with it, he could barely remain conscious!

It was a miracle he’d lasted as long as he had. At least he didn’t have to worry about Carly not being satisfied; just like him, she’d been practically on the brink of orgasm since they started! And by “the brink” he could tell from her body’s movements, and the way she shook and squeezed on him, he actually meant “had cum four or five times already”.

Rose could sense it too. The end was coming, in more ways than one.

So she chose to make a move of her own. “You know, those boobs… I’ve just gotta get my hands on them!”

She scooted over to Carly, who was shaking in orgasm so hard she could hardly stay focused. Though unlike Rose, she could at least keep her hands stable, holding her upper body up.

Which also happened to present her boobs just perfectly, leaving them to dangle out like- well, like udders.

Rose may not have been attracted to women, or breasts, but she knew just what would happen when she grabbed a couple nice, meaty handfuls.

“HYAAAAHHNNN!” Carly moaned, her back nearly bending at a 90 degree angle. Her arms shook, and she lost her balance, and plopped over onto her face as she nearly passed out from pleasure. Her eyes rolled back in her head and she bucked her hips against Nick’s.

And that was all she wrote. Nick couldn’t hold on any longer, and with a moan, he tried to pull out of Carly, but her spasming pussy was too tight to allow that, not after she’d just gone over the edge like that. Surrendering to the power that overwhelmed him, he groaned, and emptied himself inside of her.

Nick slumped over and nearly collapsed on top of Carly, who had nearly collapsed on top of Rose. The three remained huddled together in a cuddle puddle, gasping for breath and drenched in sweat.

“That… hah…” Carly picked herself up, her whole body shaking. She looked up at Rose, then up at Nick, and smiled. “That was amazing…”

Threesome! (Carly) +10 VP

First! x2 Multiplier

Threesome! (Rose) +10 VP

First! x2 Multiplier

That's quite a leap in points!

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)