Alena makes her obvious choice

Alena suddenly became fidgety. "B-but school is done for the day... It would have to be one of the members of the softball team... I mean... Any sports team, not just the softball team..."

"A girl on the softball team?"

Alena's cheeks turned beet red "Well... what about... no... she'd..."

"Who?" You asked, Alena avoiding your gaze "Come on, I won't judge."

"Chris." Alena suddenly blurted out, her face turning an even brighter shade of red. "I-I mean... she'd probably say no... and she's probably busy... with softball practice... and stuff." Alena continued as you looked down at her.

"Why don't you ask her?" You suggested, causing Alena to remain silent "It wouldn't hurt, and it's not like Chris will bite. Well, maybe she will, but only if you want her to." You joked, causing Alena to hyperventilate, her mask puffing up and down on her face as her head was filled with that fantasy. Wow, you didn't realize Alena could get so flustered. It might be that all the things you did with Dana, but you feel your S streak start to awaken again. You feel the incredible urge to bully this dweeb of a girlfriend.

You put on a mock tone of worry: "Alena, you sound like you have a really big crush on her... Should I be worried?" You asked in a half-joking tone.

"N-no!" Alena blurted out as she looked up at you "I mean, I love you! But Chris..."

"Oh no... you love her more?" You continued to tease Alena, watching her face turn red as she blocked out the remainder of her face with her hand. "And here I thought I was enough for you... maybe I should call Dana back and tell her you're cheating on me with Chris. Will she take me back..."

"Noooooooo..." Alena squeaked out in a falsetto pitch, ramming her head into yours and rubbing furiously, "IloveyouIloveyouIloveyouIloveyou-" Alena wailed. You felt a wet patch on your scalp, and realize you were taking this too far.

"Alena... hey... I was just kidding... calm down." You pet Alena, causing her to look up at you with a teary eye "I was just teasing you." You explained, causing Alena to avert your gaze "I am totally on board with the three of us together." You said, causing Alena's eyes to dart toward you.

"...Really?" Alena asked, her voice meek, "You wouldn't mind?"

"I like her too." You replied, causing Alena to look up at you before nuzzling her face against your chest again. "...But first, blow your nose." You pulled down Alena's mask and held a tissue up to her face, causing the edgelord to blow her nose loudly. You pulled back Alena's mask and kissed her on the forehead, causing Alena to giggle slightly.

So cute.