Jen breaks out the toy box

“OK…” Jen said, trying to sound authoritative. “For my next request…”

Sonya waited expectantly. Seeing her like this made Jen a little more nervous about making her order. “Um… I want to… see what you have in your toy box…” she said in a small voice.

“Hmm?” Sonya responded, legitimately not hearing the shy request.

“I… I want to see your toys…” Jennifer uttered loud enough for Sonya to hear.

Sonya lit up and grinned. “Oh, alright…” she said as she turned to one of the shelves to dig out her toys. “I haven’t gotten a chance to use them, but I think they should be fun!” she said as she rummaged. “Here it is!” She pulled out a dusty old cardboard box and set it on the floor. It let out a plume of dust as it landed. Sonya waved the dust away, coughing. “Sorry about that!” She leaned in and blew away as much dust as she safely could without filling the air with the motes. When satisfied with the cleaning, she stepped back and opened her arms to make way for her mistress to peruse.

Jen approached cautiously. She’d never looked through another girl’s collection before and was afraid to ask if any of these were used. She knelt down and started to dig into the box. Inside the worn cardboard was a chest. She pulled it out and set it down. It was an unassuming black box with a latch on it. Jen flipped the latch and opened it up. She was surprised to see dildos and vibrators stored neatly inside like a tool chest. The box was a specialized sex toy chest! She looked over at Sonya in astonishment.

The athletic blonde shrugged impishly. “I like to keep organized…” she explained.

Jennifer smiled at that answer. She was also one to keep organized. She pulled out a long, pink, double sided dildo and examined it. Sonya’s eyes widened and she sucked in her bottom lip. Jen placed it back in the box, worried that it might be too big for her. Sonya’s posture dipped a little. Jen giggled to herself, realizing that Sonya was reacting to potential items that would be used on her.

Next, Jen pulled out a rabbit vibrator. She was familiar with these although she didn’t own one. It had two protruding appendages, one long one to insert in the vagina and a shorter one that pressed up against the clitoris. She wondered what it would feel like.

Glancing over at Sonya, then around the room, Jennifer was reminded that she was the boss now and could do whatever she wanted! Filled with a newfound sense of power, she sat on the mat with the rabbit in hand. Sonya looked on with interest. Jen laid back and hovered the toy close to her vulva. She felt her heartbeat pick up as she was about to insert the sex toy, but suddenly had an reflexive urge to stop! She glanced at Sonya, still looking on.

“Um… turn around…” she ordered her submissive.

With a look of dejection, Sonya turned her back to her mistress. Feeling more secure, Jen kept her eye on the back turned Sonya and inserted the pink rabbit into her hole. She let out a gasp as it pushed up against her inner walls.

“Oh… Oooh…” she responded, getting a feel for the toy. The second ear pushed against her clit, making her squeeze the toy in response. Suddenly it started to vibrate, catching her by complete surprise!

“Ah!” she gasped, getting flooded with erogenous vibes. She held the rabbit there, enjoying the low rumbling against her clit. She could feel herself getting wet from it. Looking up from her plaything, she noticed Sonya squirming in her spot.

The tall blonde was getting antsy, hearing her mistress having fun without her. Jennifer felt a tinge of regret over keeping Sonya from looking, but felt an even bigger sense of arousal knowing the attractive athlete wanted to watch her. She continued to play with herself and after a minute, she called out, “Sonya…”

Sonya’s ears perked but she didn’t dare turn around.

“You may look,” Jen granted.

Slowly, Sonya turned her head. A smile formed on her lips as she caught a glimpse of Jen, dildo in pussy. She turned around fully and watched.

Jennifer felt a flush of excitement after allowing her former competitor to watch as she plunged the pink sex toy into her pussy, grinding it against her clit. She felt exposed and dirty, never having played with herself in front of another person before. Even with Samantha, it had been a mutual act, but now, she was performing solo in this makeshift wrestling venue.

Sonya began to fidget anxiously as she watched the petite blonde pleasure herself. She eyed Jen and covered her chest nervously, as if needing something to do with her hands. They eventually started kneading her breasts as her legs squeezed together. Watching Jen was getting her worked up!

Jennifer recognized this, but wanted to **** her new submissive some more. She played up her motions by lifting up her hips and gyrating her pussy for her audience. Sonya’s jaw went slack as she gazed at the scene. She remained silent though, allowing the hum of the rabbit to fill the room.

Slowly, Sonya started to creep her hand down her waist. She inched it closer and closer to her pussy, keeping her eyes trained on Jen and the rabbit.

“What are you doing?” Jen asked, just seconds before Sonya was about to touch herself.

“I… I… what?” Sonya stammered.

“I didn’t give you permission to touch yourself,” Jen said, getting a rush from being in control.

“I… uh… OK… may I touch myself?” Sonya asked, hopefully.

“You may not,” Jen decided, to Sonya’s dismay. “... because I want you to use this on me,” she went on to say, letting go of the rabbit so that it remained lodged in her hole.

Sonya’s heart skipped a beat as she realized what her mistress was asking of her. “Yeah!” she agreed, walking over to the smaller woman and kneeling down to meet her.

The track star took the toy and picked up where Jen left off. Jen straightened up, feeling strange from having Sonya do the dildoing. It heightened her arousal even more, feeling someone else working the soft pink plastic inside of her. She moaned and laid back, parting her legs even wider.

Sonya proved to be proficient with the toy, finding Jen’s g spot and bringing it loads of attention. Soon, Jen’s hips rose to the air again, writhing with pleasure from Sonya’s deft toy skills. Sonya held her up by the ass and plunged the rabbit as deep as it would go, holding it firm and setting the vibrator to its max setting.

Jen’s pussy felt like it was on a rollercoaster ride. Her arousal escalated quickly until she felt herself teetering on the edge! She held there for as long as she could, straining and tensing up, fighting the urge to release. She groaned, shivering in Sonya’s arm. Finally, she couldn’t take it any longer! Her pussy felt like it was dropping as she was overcome with a harrowing orgasm!

“AAAh!” Jen cried out, body shaking!

She convulsed and shook some more, dripping with girl cum. After she finished cumming, Jen cried out again and collapsed on the mat, breathing heavily. Sonya unplugged to dildo with a pop, causing Jen to gush out her juices.

“Oh my God!” she gasped, covering her face. She couldn’t believe how much she had cum from that.

“Don’t be embarrassed,” Sonya said. “That’s actually impressive!”

“Thanks,” Jen bemoaned. She needed another minute to recover, but as she did, she started to contemplate what she could do with Sonya next. “I think it’s your turn,” she told her submissive.

“My turn?” Sonya asked, with a hint of excitement.

“Bring me the box!” Jen ordered, still laying on the floor, recovering.