Push for information on Susan and Steve

"So...sis, you seem a little familiar with 'my' penis," I said. "What's that all about?"

Susan looked up at me, a shocked expression crossing her face. Then her cheeks flushed and she looked away.

"It's not like you're thinking," she said softly.

I ground her brother's cock against her pussy and she moaned softly.

I am not sure what she thought I was thinking, but I was thinking about an eighteen year old, slutty Susan sucking on her brother's big dong. Maybe letting him raw dog her while their parents we're asleep down the hall.

"What was it then?"

"My-my senior year, when he was a freshman in college, my best friend Jessica slept over one Friday night," Susan said. "I woke up in the middle of the night and she was gone. I went looking for her and I found her and Steve in the kitchen."

"Uh-huh?"

"She was on her knees, wearing MY pajamas while she sucked his cock in front of the refrigerator. He had his hand on her head, holding it in place while he fucked her mouth. Jessica had had a crush on Steve since we were six, but I had no idea he even looked at her."

"Did you go back to bed or did you watch them?" I asked, moving my lips down to her neck

"Oh God, I watched!" she moaned. 'I'd had sex a few times by then, but it had been sloppy and uncomfortable. I had also watched a couple of softcore porn on Skinemax, but I'd never actually SEEN anybody have sex."

"Did you like it?" I whispered in her ear.

"Yes," Susan said. "I got wet watching them and started touching myself."

I couldn't picture my barely legal wife fingering herself while watching her brother and her best friend. It seemed so out of character for her, even when we first got together.

"Then he pulled it out of her mouth, and that was the first time I saw it," she said. "I didn't even know that got that big. Cinemax never showed them and the two I had been with were...very small compared to that."

"Most people are small compared to Steve," I said, which made her giggle.

"He picked Jessica up and sat her own the kitchen cabinet where my mom fixed us breakfast," Susan continued. "Then he pulled her cotton pajama shorts down...MY pajama shorts down and ate her pussy. He also started gently rubbing her nipples through her top. I orgasmed and had to bite my lip hard enough to make it bleed, just so I didn't moan out loud."

Her pussy was so wet I could feel it dripping on my cock. Slowly I slid down her wet body until I was face to face with Susan's pussy. I was familiar with her scent, but somehow it smelled different through Steve's nose. I raised one of her legs over my shoulder and attacked her clit with my tongue.

"The two guys I had been with at that point had tried to eat my pussy, unsuccessfully...oh...yes," she continued. "But Steven was such a caring and attentive lover. In less that five minutes he made her squirt, which I didn't even know was a thing."

She had an orgasm as I ate her.

"After that he stood up, stepped between her legs and slid into her," Susan said. "Jess moaned so loud I couldn't believe it didn't wake my parents up. Then he started kissing her after going down on her, which I had thought was gross...but he made it kinda hot."

I slid out from under her leg and kissed her. Susan had never kissed me back like she did then, and she almost never kissed me after I had eaten her pussy.

Then I picked her up, gently placing her back against the shower wall. She wrapped her legs around my waist as I entered her.

"Oh fuck," she moaned. "He fucked her for more than a half hour. Between softcore porn and my two guys, I had no idea a guy could last that long."

"I'm not sure I will this morning," I said.

"That's okay, I have to....of God...I have to work."

We fucked, a lot longer than I could have done in my own body, but eventually even my brother-in-law reached the end.

"Where did he finish?"

I wanted to recreate her teenage fantasy. Secretly I hoped he came in her pussy. I wanted to shoot my brother-in-law's load into his sister's pussy.