The Right Sister

The next day we went for a drive to get out of the house. We found a new hiking trail and made quite the trio. Victoria and I were both limping. Her from the night before, me from the blue balls she'd given me on the drive as she rubbed me through my pants while talking dirty in my ear. Eventually, Angie had insisted that she drive for safety reasons as Victoria and I climbed into the back seat. She started giving me head, but before we could finish we pulled up to the hiking spot.

"This is the last time I go anywhere with you two!" Angie’s voice croaked worse than yesterday. "You're like horny teenagers!"

"Aww, don't worry! We'll find you your Dan soon."

"I hope so. I can't wait to have a Dan of my own."

"Aww. Well until then, we can share. Right, Dan?" I hoped I didn't look guilty as Victoria turned to me. "I mean, hold her hand! We can all walk together."

I reached out and offered my hand to Angie. She grabbed it and squeezed. "Aww, that's cute! Now all three of us are holding hands."

“Skip with me!” I said as I led the way.

"I'm going to take a shower!" Victoria called out as she walked towards the bathroom when we got home.

"Who's only wearing a towel now?" Angie yelled.

Victoria unwrapped her towel, showing off her growing tits. She stuck her tongue out and made Angie and I laugh. "Hey, if I did that, you'd kill me!"

"Damn right! Don't forget," she said as she closed the bathroom door.

Angie turned to me. "Alone at last. Hey, about yesterday-"

"I know!" I interrupted her. "What was that?"

"I don't know! But I really liked it. I've never done anything like that before. But I feel really safe around you, you know? It makes me want to explore new facets of my sexuality. And apparently, I'm into that shit. But I'm sorry if it was too far for you. We totally don't have to do anything like that again."

"No, I… actually, I feel the same way. It was really hot."

"Really?!" She looked like I gave her a puppy. "Oh, fuck yeah! That was so hot. I don't think it was even about the humiliation, you know? Like, I didn't really feel humiliated. I mostly just felt owned. Like a piece of property. Your property."

I grinned.

"Wow," she sighed. "I was worried, you know? Now I can't wait until we have this place to ourselves again."

She ran over to my spot and made out with me, listening for the water to stop.

After a minute I pulled away from her. "Hey, say something else."

"In my raspy sex voice?"

"Yes, please."

"How about this, Daddy. The next time you want to hear my voice sounds like this again, all you have to do is fuck the shit out of my throat until my tears smear my makeup and you **** me out with your big dick."

"Wait, did you say Daddy?"

"That depends. Do you like it?"

"Normally, I'd say no. But when you do it…" that earned me a kiss.

Several minutes went by before we heard the bathroom door open. Angie jumped up, shocked by the fact that the water was still going. She fell backward over the coffee table, rolling into the ground and causing me to chuckle.

"That was work!" Victoria called through the doorway, out of sight. "I guess I have the day off tomorrow too! Hell yeah!"

"Awesome!" I called out.

She closed the door and resumed her shower.

"Hoo-fucking-ray," Angie shouted as she got up. "I think I need a drink after hearing that news. Want one?"

"Bring the bottle."

The three of us got reasonably drunk that night. We ended up in my bed, and after Angie began to snore Victoria turned to me.

"I want you inside of me."

"I want that too," I told her.

"Do your balls still hurt?" She asked.

"Not as bad now, thanks to the booze."

"I'm not really sore right now either," she whispered.

"Too bad we have company," I reminded her.

"Yeah." She was silent for a moment. "Although… she is sleeping." She reached over to grab me. "Hey! You didn't tell me you were hard."

We began kissing. After a few minutes, she paused. "She's a heavy sleeper."

"Really?"

"Yep." She resumed kissing, and I wondered for a moment if I would be able to get away with mounting her.

"You kiss differently now," she told me.

"Really?" Shit.

"Yeah, you're more aggressive. A little bit rougher." I started to hear my own heartbeat, waiting for her to finish. "I like it."

"I think we've become more comfortable around each other," I suggested.

"I'd say we definitely have. And the sex just keeps getting better."

If I didn't feel guilty before, I did now.

She wrapped her leg around me and crawled on top of me. "Think we can get away with it?"

I kissed her. "If we're quiet."

"Fuck it," in the second time I ever heard the F word leave her mouth.

She gasped as she pulled me inside her. She was as wet as I'd ever felt her. The rhythm started slow, and she only moved an inch or two but it felt amazing.

She moaned again, and I suddenly became aware that Angie was awake. Victoria was oblivious, still drunk and distracted by the pleasure. I reached out my arms and felt two things. My phone in my left hand, Angie's hand in my right.

I had already turned on the app before bed, just in case I wanted to be a dick to Angie, so all I had to do was press the volume button up.

She squeezed my hand when I did, trying to maintain her breathing and stay quiet. This continued as my girlfriend sped up, the sound of her ass slapping my hips growing steadily louder. I turned up Angie's vibrator up to the second level, the third shortly after.

Angie's hand began to move as she pleasured herself more aggressively. I pressed the button once more, bringing Angie to the fourth level for a minute.

I began to hear the sound of the vibrator, so I reached over to slap Victoria's ass.

"Shhhh," she whispered in my ear as she sped up, creating even more noise than my spanking had between her moaning and the sounds of our bodies colliding.

I was close, so I grabbed her ass cheek with one hand to speed her up. She cried out, moaning in ecstasy as she reached her orgasm. Her pussy tightened around me, bringing me to climax right along with her.

At the same time, Angie's hand tightened around me in a **** grip, expressing all it was taking to keep quiet as she reached an orgasm of her own.

I wasted no time grabbing my phone. I messed up, reaching too fast and pushing my phone instead of gripping it. It slid right off the bed despite my best efforts to catch it, banging against my nightstand with a loud thunk.

"What was that?" Victoria asked me as she collapsed on my chest.

"My phone," I said as I tried to sit up.

"You don't need it. I need you for a pillow right now because I don't think I can move."

Right at that moment, Angie erupted in laughter.

"Sorry, Angie. Were we too loud?"

"Just a bit, little sis. Just a bit."

We joined her in laughter, the three of us relieved at the break in tension from the awkward moment.

But it was short lived.

We all heard it at once. The sound of something that could only be a vibration.

"What's that sound?" Vicky asked.

"Umm… maybe it's my phone?” I suggested. “Maybe I should check it…"

"No, it's coming from the other side of the bed."

Angie sat up. "Well, I'm going to go use the bathroom…"

"Wait. Are you using a vibrator?"

I could almost hear the wheels spinning in Angie's head as she tried to come up with a response. I was just as blank.

"Eww! Were you using a vibrator while you were listening to us have sex?"

Another pause. There was nothing I could think of that wouldn't incriminate me more.

"It was really hot, okay?"

"Eww! Angie! I'm your sister!"

"That doesn't make it sound any less sexy! You guys are really fucking hot."

There was another pause. Then Victoria started to giggle again. "At least you aren't related to Dan," she pointed out. "Wait, why didn't you leave?"

"Because I can't escape it, okay? I can still hear you guys in the next room."

"Wait, do you pleasure yourself every time we make love?"

"Pretty much!"

Victoria giggled again. "I can't believe my big sister masturbates to the sound of my boyfriend and I having sex!"

More giggling. "Okay, so now the question is, where did you even get a vibrator?"

Angie seemed to have already thought of this. "It was in my pants. I didn't realize it was there until I tried to fall asleep."

She started to laugh along with her sister. "Hey, Danny, why are you so quiet?"

"Because I'm still balls deep in your baby sister," I said. This pushed both girls into fits of giggling.

"Okay, last question. Hey Angie?"

"Yes?"

"Why is it still going?"

Angie jumped up. "Because I can't figure out how to turn it off, okay?"

This time I joined in Victoria's laughter as Angie ran out of the room.

"And who walks around with a vibrator in their pants anyway!" she yelled after her sister.

"Wow," I said.

"I can't believe that just happened." She squeezed. "Wait, are you hard again?"

"Apparently." I gripped her hips and bounced her up and down. "Are you up for round two?"

"Only if you gag me. Otherwise, we are basically making audio porn!"

"All I heard was, 'gag me'."

"Are you comfortable with being responsible for getting two sisters off in the same night?"

I flipped her over and began to tickle her. "Sounds pretty fucking hot to me!" Her laughter was louder than her protests.

I fucked her, this time the opposite of the first. It was rough, hard and fast. And it would be a lie if I said I didn’t imagine that it was Angie underneath me.