She tries to catch Haruto's attention of course!

Haruto had no initial intention of doing a second shoot with Ami. He'd heard the rumors surrounding her, how she was a **** walking red flag and so on. She wasn't particularly attractive either, the most bland girl he'd ever seen. Her only truly striking feature was her pear-shaped physique.
That all changed when he received a text from Ami herself. It wasn't much really. Just an image of her remaining costumes.

Haruto despite his looks wasn't one to be swayed by lust, not that it was lust he was feeling when thinking about Ami in those clothes in the first place. No, Haruto saw potential. He saw a needy, **** and insecure girl that would do his every bidding. He saw the chance to make some easy money..
The previous session they had together was actually just a commission he'd received from some random who followed his work. Usually he just posted fetish stuff he drew by hand, but every once in a while someone requested something a bit more ..real.

Sure, Ami was no looker. But perhaps with a bit of work she could become a great asset to have, maybe even worth fucking every now and then. Yes, the more he thought about it, the wiser it'd be to invite her over for a second shoot. Perhaps share some of his ideas.
The way she'd looked at him.. Haruto was sure that Ami had a crush on him or something, easy enough to exploit to get her in on something she might not otherwise have done.

"Looks hot.. Want to bring them over after school tomorrow and do another shoot? ;)"

He may have overdone it a bit. Sure the costumes could've been hot on someone, that someone sure as hell wasn't Ami though. That didn't matter though, there was always an audience for bland girls with low self esteem..

Ami was over the moon. The response she'd gotten was waaay better than she could ever have dreamed of. She was prepared to go to war to get another shot with Haruto, yet here he was. Proposing they do another session on his own initiative.

"Absolutely! I'll bring them both!"

The rest of the day was just Ami going about with her day with the most "giddy schoolgirl" expression on her face.

The hardest part about her second meeting with Haruto wasn't actually convincing him to do it. It was getting the magical girl wand/staff to school and storing it while the day went it's course. Fortunately the boardgame club remained empty as ever throughout the day which made it the prime spot to store the needlessly large rod..

Just as last time, Ami got changed while Haruto set up his equipment. Unlike last time, she didn't actually wear the outfit under her uniform as there were two of them, and they'd be a slightly bigger inconvenience during the day. Instead she had to change right there in the corner.

First up was the cheerleader costume she'd bought. It was a pretty basic skintight uniform with no skirt. It looked more like a gymnasts outfit than a cheerleader uniform. The only detail that gave away what it's intended use was were the two pompoms in her hands.

Haruto was feeling a tad devious today. When he saw Ami in her outfit obviously looking very uncomfortable in her own skin he decided he wanted to parade her around for a bit. It was a Tuesday afternoon and the least busy day of the week in terms of club activities after Friday, so the chances of actually being seen were slim. It did however not ease Ami's mind when Haruto first told her where he wanted to take the photos.

"The pool? Do we HAVE to?"

Somehow he managed to convince her that the best location for a cheerleader to be was in the gymnasium or at the pool. Of course they could've done it at the track and field as well, but even Haruto wasn't that vile..

He wasn't usually sadistic like this, but just being around and involved with Ami made him feel overwhelmed with the temptation of humiliating and using her for his own whims.

Ami lined up against the tiled wall by the pool, just where the real cheerleaders would stand and cheer whenever the school hosted a competition. Today was the only day the pool stood empty. Lucky them..

The poor girl hated how the tight outfit hugged her body, leaving nothing to the imagination. Her usual style of wearing baggy clothes whenever possible hid her flabby body from onlookers. Here everything was laid bare with nowhere to hide. She found it impossibly hard to even smile. Her expression was instead this dull, almost stupid look of confusion.

How did she get in this position? What's she doing in a cheerleader costume? Look at that gut! The potential hate comments she'd get if these pictures were ever uploaded anywhere dominated Ami's imagination as she posed for the camera. Her pose being incredibly stiff and static, cementing the bitter truth that she'd never cut it as an actual cheerleader.

"Great! You mentioned another costume? I think I know just the spot for it!"

Ami didn't like the way he emphasized his words, not that she'd ever turn him down though. Had he known just how far she was willing to go for his validation things might've gone too far real fast.

The two walked back to the boardgame clubroom and Ami was well on her way to change into the next costume. Despite covering more of her thighs, it felt skimpier than the cheerleader outfit. Maybe because it was nearly see-through and looked more like underwear than an actual dress.

In addition to the staff, she'd also brought a second pair of glasses she had lying around. They matched the color of her costume and she thought they looked a little cute. If one were into glasses she might have passed as a little cute. Too bad they framed the dullest and most boring pair of eyes you could ever have the misfortune of seeing.

With her outfit complete Ami followed Haruto through the entire school without a clue of what their final destination was. It came as a shock when he announced that they do the final photos outside on the roof. Apparently one of the exits there had a busted lock.

It was quite windy that far up and Ami had to do her best not to let the dress get caught by the gusts. Whenever Haruto wasn't holding his camera she'd rest the staff against the wall and hold the costume down with all her might, afraid to flash Haruto her panties.

In truth she didn't actually mind letting him catch a glimpse, believing it'd help her in seducing him. Her only gripe was coming across as easy and ****. With her complete lack of self awareness she failed to realize how that was the only impression he and everyone else had of her.

Haruto finally caught a decent photo of her, though he'd prefer it if she smiled a bit more. Maybe next time, he thought to himself. It was obvious that she didn't feel very comfortable in the situation as it was. Forcing her to smile in addition to introducing her to these scenes was probably not the best of ideas.

"That should do it for today.."

"Already? Aww, I was just beginning to feel comfortable too.."

It was a lie. Ami was relieved that she was finished. She was relieved that it'd gone by without incident. Relieved that Haruto seemed satisfied with the results.

After coming down from the roof they both went their own way. Ami back to the clubroom to get changed, and Haruto to the shoe lockers. He had a bunch of photos to touch up and edit before posting them to the onlyfans accounts he'd set up for Ami without her knowing. It was highly illegal, but even if he was caught doing it, he was sure he could convince Ami to play along..

If you enjoy it so far, do consider giving it a like!
This is a commissioned story and will follow a very strict prompt. I'll gladly take any feedback you might have, but suggestions may be ignored if they conflict with the established concepts and ideas from the commissioner.Should you want to read further into the story there's already additional chapters available on my Patreon, as well as other exclusive content not found on CHYOA.

I also take commissions for specific stories whenever there's an opening, which there is right now.

https://www.patreon.com/Felixfalck