You

“John.” Nicole announces smugly, only for her breath to catch in her throat when she turns towards you to see your face so close to hers that her short blonde locks nearly whipped your nose as she span her head. There’s a pregnant pause before she states your dare, during which her eyes drop tellingly to your lips. "Since you can’t keep your hands to yourself, a-and because it’s only fair seeing as how all you guys are … like that.” She adds, gesturing to your exposed dick with a trembling hand. "I dare you to pick a girl and strip them. Naked." As soon as she said that final word she turned away again as her cheeks burned scarlet, throwing your name shyly back into the hat.

With folded arms Nicole looks straight forward but you can tell that she's occasionally glancing at you out of the corner of her eye. Despite acting mad at you for kissing her you know what this dare really is. It’s a play, hoping that you’ll pick her. You called her sexy, after all, it's now on you to prove to her that you meant it. Looking at her again, she really is sexy. She's got a tomboyish charm, with short hair and hidden curves, that's offset by her naïve blush. All of it's made even dirtier by the fact that you almost think of her as a sister, and now you're picturing her naked. She might not have childbearing hips like the other girls, but she's got round little breasts and a firm ass wrapped up in her skinny jeans. Don't you want to unwrap her and see how sexy Nicole can really be?

But what if it isn't part of some plan? This could be her way of saying "Okay, fun's fun, but now get serious and go get Miranda." Maybe you're misreading the signals and really Nicole is giving you a free shot at your crush. She's been supportive of you pursuing her before, this could be another escalation of that which you're about to blunder away if you choose anyone but Miranda. If you choose Nicole and you're wrong, not only would you miss your shot, you might damage your relationship permanently with her too. Even if Nicole does want you, you've wanted Miranda for years. Would it be so wrong to go after her when you've got a golden opportunity, the best chance you might ever have to see her full 36C breasts in real life?

Regardless of these two difficult choices, there's always the wildcard option. Sarah. She had possibly the sexiest body you'd ever seen, a full ass that was begging to be squeezed, bouncy tits that were always threatening to spill or burst out of whatever she wore, and thick thighs to keep your ears warm as she sat on your face. Perhaps most importantly, stripping her would result in no hurt feelings (Except possibly Matt, but getting to see her naked would probably overshadow anything else.) Sarah certainly wouldn't mind getting to flaunt her figure and it would avoid picking a side between Nicole and Miranda. (If you weren't reading too much into Nicole's body language and there were even sides to pick, of course.) Choosing her might make you look like a horny idiot, but it would avoid treading on anyone's toes.

This deliberation had only taken a few seconds but still you realized that everyone was looking at you and you would have to choose a girl soon.