Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 13 by JakeSnakeCakes JakeSnakeCakes

How does she answer?

Natalya says Dare

"Dare" she says, bemused.

Jackie reaches into the pot. "It's hard to read with all of this underwear on my face." He puts the paper close to his eye.

"I dare you to suck the smallest cock until the timer runs out." She takes a look at the paper. "Alright, line up and get yourselves hard."

You all shuffle around the table. Natalya takes a shot, and refills it. "In case I have to rinse the cum out."

You stand alongside Dinesh, Phil, and Jackie. None of you are erect fully, but you watch as their penises become longer and harder, and it stirs up a reaction in your own cock. You think about what these beautiful penises could do, the holes the could fill. The cum they could give you. Your cock rockets to attention, springing up alongside the others. As you all reach full mast, appreciating each others' dicks Natalya begins to compare you all with her hands. It's just a quick, brief touch but she gives yours a compliment.

"It will make someone very happy." she says.

"What about my dick?" Jackie asks.

"It's the biggest. Stand over here." She makes you stand from smallest to largest. After carefully measuring yours and Dinesh's, she has you stand right next to Jacky. Second best, barely.

Phil's cock is average sized, five inches. You almost feel bad but then you see Natalya go to town on his cock. Slobbering over his rod as she plays with his balls. Phil starts to let out a moan and he cums right away, filling Natalya's mouth. She stops for a moment, washing the cum down her throat with soju.

"Natalya, the timer is still going." Jackie points. The glass isn't even a quarter done. Natalya rolls her eyes and gets back into it.

"Oh god, it's so sensitive." You see Phil's legs shake and he squirms as he gets the best blowjob of his life.

"This is... this is my first time" he says. "Thank you for being so good".

Natalya gives him a thumbs up. You watch her masterwork. You see her pull her mouth away as it bobs on his dick, and it's fully hard again.

"Is she, is she gonna make him cum twice?" It looks like she's going for it. She furiously bobs on his cock and the timer ticks down. Stella and Claire cheer her on, and you join in as well. His lubed up cock, his face, twitching with pleasure. The beautiful blonde giving it her all until...

The timer stops. Natalya turns around, and opens her mouth. No cum.

"Th-thank you" Phil says. "I'm glad I could lose my virginity to you."

"You're a virgin? No wonder you came so quickly. But don't speak so soon, you may lose your real virginity later on." Phil reaches for his cock, which is hard and begging for attention. Jackie grabs his hand, and pulls it away.

"You can't touch yourself unless it's part of a dare." Jackie says.

"Aw fuck." Phil says. He sits down. All of us do, our cocks still stiff and begging for release. Especially after that show that Natalya put on.

Who does Natalya choose and what do they pick?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)