More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by Thatguy88 Thatguy88

What do you try?

Polyamory

"What if it wasn't just sex?" asked Whitney, "Lola and I, well, we're more than friends and know the two of you are close."

"Are you suggesting adding a third? To our marriage?"

"Is that so ridiculous?"

"I mean thats a huge step, especially given this seems to be coming out of nowhere."

"I think it would be perfect," said Whitney, "we can start out slow, I'll talk to Lola, the two of you can go on a date."

You woke up the next morning to more back and forth in the hallway, Lola seemed angry but after a while Whitney seemed to calm her down. You got out of bed after Whitney left and went to shower but found Lola in the hallway seemingly lost in thought.

"All good?"

"Yeah," said Lola, "did Whitney talk to you?"

"She did," said Lola, "date tonight, you and me, no...limits."

"You like out of the box things," you said, "I have an idea."

You turned to walk to the bathroom but an urge suddenly crept up, you turned back to Lola, you leaned in and Lola closed her eyes, her lips gently parted and you kissed her plump lips, softly, your tongues just barely touching. As you went to pull away Lola put a hand on the back of your head and pulled you in, her tongue pressing into your mouth. You grabbed her tiny waist and pulled her into you.

"Tonight," you said barely pulling away.

"Tonight," she said breathing heavy.

It was hard to focus on anything at work, why was Whitney offering this, how would the date go, how far would you both be willing to go. You got home and got ready, you got dressed up, not too dressy since that wasn't Lola's style and you waited in the living room. As you waited Whitney came home, it was only 6, you had no idea why she was home so early.

"Excited for the big date?" she asked, "you look handsome."

"Thanks, you're home early "

"I wouldn't miss this," she said, "and well, the late hours are over, I'm transferring to a local branch."

"That's great Whit," you said kissing her, "I've missed you so much."

You held Whitney for a while just holding your wife.

"Someone is in for a treat," said Whitney pulling away from your embrace so you could see Lola standing in a little black dress, it was tight and had thin straps up top, it came down to her mid thigh. She'd also blown out her hair, she looked like a pin up model from the neck up and a dream from the shoulders down.

"Wow," you said involuntarily.

"Thanks," said Lola blushing.

"I won't keep you for long," said Whitney, "I just need to talk to Lola quickly."

You waited as you heard talking in the hallway, they came out a moment later and hugged tightly.

"Have fun you two," said Whitney, "I'm going out with Zoey tonight so you'll have the place to yourselves."

"Thanks mom," said Lola taking your hand.

You took Lola out to a hotpot place and soon you were picking out what you wanted.

"This is so cool," said Lola, "I've never been to one of these places."

"I'm glad you like it," you said, " seemed like someplace you'd enjoy."

"Burt," said Lola, "that kiss this morning, was that lust or?"

"Lola," you said trying to figure out how to articulate your feelings, "we've been friends for like twelve years, when we're together it's like no time has passed. I trust youike very few other people."

Lola tensed, shit what had you done?

"You know Whitney is the most important person in my life, but you're just as important, when im with the two of you I'm happier then ive been with anyone else."

You took her hands, "so what's wrong?"

"Not tonight," she said, "tonight its just us, I'm sorry it's just a lot of emotions."

You ate and Lola told you about work, how indifferent she was about it and how she didn't want to stay in Texas anymore but didn't know where to go.

"Dessert?" you asked after dinner.

"No," said Lola.

"Because you're sweet enough?"

She rubbed your calf with her foot and smiled.

"I am, want a taste?"

"I'm done tasting," you said wishing you were already home with her.

It took every ounce of restraint in you to not run out of the restaurant, to drive safely and to not sprint to your front door. Once inside there was no more restraint, the two of you kissed like you needed it to live, you pushed her back against the wall, you wanted her now but you also wanted to take your time.

You kissed her neck and held her waist, Lola breathing heavily, eyes closed. You grabbed her waist and picked her up, she wrapped her legs around you waist, her arms around your neck as she kissed you hard.

"I'm scooping you up Lola," you said.

"Finally," she said, "I haven't wanted someone this badly...ever."

You carried her to her bedroom and laid her down before pressing a kiss to her lips. She rolled onto her stomach giving you access to the zipper on her dress, you unwrapped her slowly and as she wiggled out of her dress you admired her tight little ass in a black thong. You pulled the thong off next and then rolled her onto her back and kissed her as she tore at your shirt trying to get it off. Once she'd succeeded she undid your pants and watched as you pulled them and your boxers off.

You stood naked admiring Lola's form as she motioned with one finger for you to come get her. Slowly you climbed on top of her, your lips met, then your tongues, as she laid back you felt her hand around your cock, guiding you towards her. You entered her slowly, her eyes wide, her moans loud as she slowly took you into her.

"You're so tight," you said meeting her eyes.

"You're so deep," she said wrapping her legs around you.

You kissed her neck and teased one of her nipples as you thrusted slowly.

"I never say this," she gasped, "but be gentle."

You kept it slow and steady as you and Lola kissed again, seemingly unable to keep your lips apart.

"Go deep," she pleaded, "but slow."

With your first deep thrust she squealed and smiled through your kiss.

"Yesssss, just like that."

You sucked hard on one of her nipples, trying to keep your pace as Lola held you against her.

"A little harder," she gasped followed by a squeak as you drove yourself in.

"Am I hurting you?"

"No...opposite."

"Can I try something?"

"I told you," she said, "you can have anything."

You leaned back so you were kneeling and grabbed Lola's waist pulling her off of the bed and started to hammer her impossibly tight pussy.

"Holy fuck," she whined, "I'm gonna, I, God, fucking **** me."

You grabbed her throat and squeezed, Lola's pussy clenched around you forcing you out and she squirted harder then you'd seen her before soaking the comforter. Lola laid shaking and whimpering.

"On your back," she said as she composed herself.

She straddled you and slowly slid herself back onto you. Bracing herself on your chest she started to ride you biting her lip as you watched.

"You are so goddamn sexy."

"You mean it?"

You grabbed her face with both hands and pulled her in for a kiss as she started to ride you. Lola bit her lip as she rode you, her eyes clothes, her hands on your chest.

"I love your cock," she cooed, "it hits right where I need it."

You laid back and let her work watching her move slowly and deliberately, then picked up the pace.

"I'm gonna," she gasped, "oh just give me a minute."

You reached down and rubbed her clit with your thumb and she shivered clinging to you. When her orgasm passed she leaned down and kissed you hard.

"I want your cum," she pleaded.

"And I want to fold you," you said.

"Do it hard," she growled between kissing you, "make me scream."

You laid Lola on her back and brought her legs up so they were wrapped behind her head, slowly, you **** yourself into her impossibly tight pussy.

"Holy shit," you both groaned almost in unison.

You slammed yourself hard into Lola as she clung to you squealing with each thrust. Lola's screams were driving you crazy and before long you buried yourself in her and unloaded going almost dizzy from your orgasm. You pulled out and collapsed onto your back next to her as cum ran out of her onto the bed. The two of you lay breathing hard for a while before she finally spoke.

"I needed that," she murmured wrapping herself around you.

"I think we both did," you said.

You hadn't wanted anyone but Whitney for as long as you could remember and now, having had Lola you only wanted more. Your cock stirred as you lay intertwined.

"Hey big boy," said Lola, "you just shot a gallon of cum into me how are you getting hard again?"

"You promised me everything," you said.

"My ass?" she asked feigning innocence, "I don't know."

"Come on," you said, "I've never done anal, you'd be my first."

"Oh really," said Lola, "ok, but, and this is going to sound weird, I actually like it really rough in my ass."

She got you lubed up and in the same position you'd just creampied her in you slid yourself into her rear hole.

"God that's tight," you marveled.

Bracing yourself on the bed you started to ram your cock into Lola who lay wide eyed and whimpering and after a short while her pussy erupted spraying you.

"Jesus christ you really like a cock in your ass."

"I fucking love it," she squealed.

You pulled out marveling at her gaped hole before shoving yourself back in. You pulled her on top of you and grabbing her waist fucked her as she squealed louder than she had holding your arms for support. Lola clung to you tightly, her nails digging in and with tears welling in her eyes she squirted again down onto you her whole body shaking.

"You're a fucking faucet," you said as you steadied her.

You got her onto all fours but she was so weak she let her arms down just keeping her ass in the air. You slid back in and holding her waist you fucked her as hard as you could manage, the little blonde practically screaming. When you felt she'd had enough you pulled out, spit into her gaping hole and slid back in.

"Hard enough for you?" you growled.

Lola looked back at you but just whimpered as you used her ass. You pushed her prone and wrapping an arm around her neck you fucked her into the mattress kissing her cheek and whispering how good she felt. With a loud groan you flooded her ass and collapsed onto her.

"Holy fuck," you groaned now entirely exhausted.

"You're exhausted?" she mumbled, "I just had my ass destroyed."

Climbing off of Lola you laid down next to her and rubbed her back gently as a smile crept across her face.

"That was," she paused, "I'm really happy."

You heard a door open and you weren't sure what Whitney's response would be.

"Looks like I missed the fun," said Whitney from the doorway, "clothes on, let's talk."

"Let's talk," you said with a chuckle, "am I in trouble?"

You were joking until you saw the sullen look on Lola's face.

"Hey," you said as Lola pulled a robe on, "Lola what's that look, what aren't you telling me?"

"Nothing," she said before pulling you in for a kiss, "Whitney will tell you."

You suddenly felt like you were walking into an ambush. When you and Lola got into the living room Whitney had set drinks out for you.

"Ok," you said, "what happened?"

"Burt," said Whitney more serious then you'd seen her since she sat for the CPA, "you're right something has been off at work."

"Yeah," you said looking at Lola who was suddenly avoiding eye contact, "but you transferred."

"I did," said Whitney, "but," she paused and suddenly looked really upset, "I was having an affair with my boss."

"You?" you said entirely blindsided and then it dawned on you, "and Lola knew?"

"Burt I'm so sorry," said Lola practically crying.

"Lola found out," said Whitney, "and she told me to tell you, she said if I didn't before the end of her trip she would."

"Lola," you said trying to maintain your composure, "I don't blame you at all, but Whit, how could you? And now you're involving Lola in all of this."

"I am so sorry," said Whitney, "it is over and it has been killing me."

"And what I'm just supposed to forgive you?"

"No," said Whitney, "not right away, but."

You drained your glass and stewed, your mind was torn, you had just had an amazing night with Lola and now Whitney was throwing this at you.

"I'll give you some space," said Whitney, "I can stay with my mom."

"No, Whit," you said, "I don't want you to go."

"Ok," she said seemingly relieved as she wiped some tears away.

Whitney left to get ready for bed and you sat across from Lola.

"I'll leave you," said Lola getting up, she went to dart past but you took her hand.

"Lola," you said standing up and looking into her eyes, "I did really enjoy our night together."

"I did too," she said as you wrapped your arms around her.

You leaned in and kissed Lola as she melted into you.

"Good night," she said when she finally pulled away.

In your room you got into bed and were content to try and sleep but Whitney slid into bed behind you and wrapped her arms around you.

"Whit," you groaned.

"I know," she said, "I do love you Burt."

"I love you too, but I need time."

What's next?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)