Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 53 by PhoenixAuthor PhoenixAuthor

What's next?

Playing with the Girls

Amy looked up at the taller blonde with wide eyes. The gorgeous cheerleader was looking down at Amy smirking, and Amy was whimpering softly as Skylar’s hard nipples grazed along the incredibly sensitive skin of Amy’s pale tits, and whenever said hard nipples brushed Amy’s own hard nipples, Amy would gasp in pleasure.

It wasn’t her fault her boobs were so sensitive! They’d just always been like that. The fact that it was a girl making Amy feel like… this was weird to Amy, but she also was weirdly not against it. There was a hotness between Amy’s thighs, and she was pretty sure that not all of the moisture there came from the shower-head.

“So? Are you going to tell me?” Skylar asked eagerly, deliberately making her tits bounce so that her nipples would keep tracing light lines across Amy’s massive melons.

Amy’s mind briefly blanked whenever Skylar’s nipples met hers, but she stammered out what had happened at the party.

“Um, I- I don’t know, it w-went OK.” Amy tried to dissuade Skylar from caring, but she was like a dog with a bone.

“Stop being so embarrassed and shy!” Skylar rolled her eyes, “Goddamn, Amy, if I had your body, I’d have every man in this town on their knees.”

“W-what?” Amy blinked. Skylar shook her head, and she leaned in close until her lips were millimeters from Amy’s.

Amy’s green eyes went huge as Skylar’s nose nearly bumped hers, and the two green-eyed girls stared into each other’s eyes.

“Amy, your body is ridiculously sexy. You should be proud of it, not afraid of showing it off. I don’t know how you can not notice that every guy you pass drools over you. If it wasn’t for Jace, you’d have guys begging to date you every damn second.” Skylar told Amy firmly.

“No- no way, you’re lying.” Amy blushed madly. Skylar threw up her hands and stalked out of the shower, and Amy finally took a deep breath. Whew, she was finally gone, and Amy could relax-

Before Amy could even finish her thought, the shower door opened again and Skylar came back in, hauling a football player with her. Drake Malone, a huge burly black boy who served as the team’s defensive tackler, seemed very confused by his presence there, but then his eyes landed on naked Amy, and Amy’s legs practically gave out watching Drake’s huge cock start rapidly hardening.

“Drake, do you find Amy attractive? Even slightly?” Skylar asked redundantly.

“Fuck, girl, I find Amy super hot.” Drake shook his head, “I’ve always wanted to do a little something with her.”

“Oh, really?” Skylar asked with fake surprise, giving Amy an ‘I told you so’ look.

“For sure.” Drake nodded emphatically, and he gave Amy a big grin, “Is this my chance?”

Amy’s green eyes were locked on Drake’s huge cock, and Skylar almost laughed seeing Amy practically drooling over it.

“Not today, Malone. But clearly she likes you.” Skylar smirked, and Drake looked disheartened, but he left the shower without complaint. Despite his imposing size, Drake was really a teddy bear. He’d never do anything to hurt a girl, which was exactly why Skylar had went and grabbed him, because she trusted he wouldn’t do anything Amy wouldn’t want.

“So, do you believe me now?” Skylar put her hands on her bare hips and giving Amy a smug smile.

“I.. I-” Amy mumbled.

“I guess you liked Drake’s cock? You can go find him any time. You’re an adult woman, Amy, you don’t need to be all shy and blush whenever someone mentions sex. If you want it, go get it.” Skylar encouraged the girl, “So, now that we’ve established you’re sexy as fuck, spill about that party, or I’ll make you talk.”

Amy flushed darkly.

“Um, nothing really happened.” Amy lied very obviously. Skylar clicked her tongue and walked forwards, backing Amy back up against the wall and pushing her body flat against Amy’s, making the shorter girl gasp.

Skylar’s hands found the ginger’s thick curvy hips and she gave them some squeezes as she rubbed her tits all over Amy’s bigger tits.

“Wanna share yet?” Skylar asked huskily.

“I… Evan and I danced.” Amy fumbled for something to say.

“Now we’re getting somewhere!” Skylar exclaimed approvingly, “What happened when you guys danced?”

Her hands kept squeezing and caressing Amy’s hips, and they slid around her to find Amy’s plump, fat, round ass.

Amy gasped as Skylar kneaded her ass with her hands.

“He grinded on me!” Amy panted, “And… and I grinded on him.”

“And?” Skylar pressed.

“He kissed my neck, and… and I felt his cock!” Amy exclaimed.

“Ooooh.” Skylar cooed, and she briefly slowed her **** of Amy’s fat ass. The redhead had such an amazing body, soft and voluptuous, nice and jiggly in just about every part of her.

“So, Evan got you all flustered, huh?” Skylar teased Amy, “Did you do anything more with him?”

“N-no! I left, very quickly.” Amy admitted. Skylar nodded slowly.

“What else aren’t you telling me?” Skylar wondered, and her hands trailed around to Amy’s waist, where her fingers slowly started sliding their way up.

“I… I went to the bathroom.” Amy said, and now her cheeks were burning red, “And… I touched myself.”

Skylar was hooked now, incredibly eager to hear more. Her hands reached Amy’s huge fat tits and she eagerly began squeezing and groping them, making Amy’s sexy whines start up again, with more fever than last time.

“Then what? Did you get yourself off in my bathroom?” Skylar asked eagerly.

“I… yes.” Amy said, but she still sounded like she was hiding something, so Skylar pinched Amy’s nipples hard and elicited a long, horny moan from the busty ginger.

“Spill.” Skylar ordered, and Amy nodded breathlessly, clinging to Skylar’s waist to keep her steady. Skylar noticed excitedly that Amy was on shaky legs. Skylar slipped her arms beneath Amy’s arms and wrapped her arms around the ginger, holding her up and holding her close.

With Amy and Skylar’s bodies cuddled up together, Skylar’s face was extremely close to Amy’s, and Skylar gave Amy a lasting kiss on the lips. Amy gasped adorably against Skylar’s mouth, but gently kissed back. Skylar wasn’t one for a gentle kiss though, and her tongue slipped inside Amy’s mouth to wrestle for dominance, but Amy submitted instantly, and Skylar got full reign over Amy's mouth.

“Tell me.” Skylar murmured against Amy’s plump lips, and the blushing ginger nodded rapidly.

“I… I was touching myself and then… Aiden walked in… with his cock out.” Amy stammered, “And… when I saw it… I orgasmed! I orgasmed while moaning my brother’s name.”

Heat rapidly grew between Skylar’s legs.

“That’s so fucking hot.” Skylar moaned, and she slammed her mouth against Amy’s, who yet again yielded instantly, to Skylar’s pleasure.

Amy’s arms wrapped around Skylar’s neck, and Skylar took one hand off Amy’s back to slide it down to between the ginger's thick, inviting thighs.

Skylar’s fingers lightly brushed Amy’s lower lips, and the girl whimpered in pleasure. Skylar gave Amy an encouraging kiss as her fingers slowly parted Amy’s lower lips. They didn’t penetrate her just yet, Sky was just enjoying playing with Amy. But Skylar Wayne was not known as a patient young woman, so she quickly stopped fucking around and slid her fingers inside. Amy gasped and her hips writhed wildly at the penetration, and Skylar took her lips off Amy’s to bring them close to the shorter girl’s ear.

As Skylar’s expert fingers worked Amy’s wet pussy, the kinky blonde began to talk.

“You know, boys don’t just walk into bathrooms with their cocks out.” Skylar whispered in Amy’s ear, “Your little brother was jerking his cock to you.”

Amy gasped, and Skylar fingered her harder, making Amy’s legs shake. Amy clung tightly to Skylar to keep upright, and Skylar’s free hand wrapped around Amy’s waist to push her up against the wall and pin her there. Skylar nibbled on Amy’s neck while she fingered her, and Amy’s moans reached a new crescendo, making Skylar smile.

“A-Aiden wouldn’t.” Amy shook her head, which accidentally hit Skylar in the face with her wet red hair, but Skylar was unbothered.

“Sure. Your horny, virgin little brother just happened to walk into the bathroom with his cock out, and then just watched you finger yourself. Standard brotherly activities.” Skylar said dryly and then gave Amy a nip on the neck for being dumb.

Amy was breathing hard, panting for breath. Her pussy was soaked, and Skylar didn’t plan on letting up anytime soon.

“Your brother wants you bad.” Skylar pressed, “And it seems from your story that you want him just as badly. Most sisters don’t cry out their baby brother’s names as they orgasm.”

“It… it was an accident.” managed a mortified Amy.

“Which part?” Skylar asked innocently. Amy’s green eyes were wide and her lips moved soundlessly as she tried to puzzle it out. Skylar waited patiently, her fingers never slowing their **** on Amy, which could be why Amy was taking so long to string thoughts together. Skylar Wayne had been known to finger girls stupid in the past, after all.

“S-stop being mean.” Amy stammered, and Skylar reached up with the hand not inside Amy to grab Amy’s nipple and twist it, making the busty ginger yelp.

“Don’t talk back to me.” Skylar ordered, and a cowed Amy nodded obediently.

“Y-yes, ma’am.” Amy blurted before she could think about it, and then she froze in horror. A huge smirk spread across Skylar’s face.

“Ma’am, huh? I could get used to that, Amy.” Skylar told Amy, and then she kissed the sensitive skin on Amy’s neck where she’d been nibbling at her.

“I…” Amy said weakly.

“It was an accident?” Skylar asked with a raised eyebrow. Amy nodded meekly. Skylar laughed and kissed Amy again, loving how submissive the buxom redhead was.

“Well, do it again.” Skylar ordered.

“Yes, ma’am.” Amy obeyed in a moan, and Skylar sucked in a breath. Fuck, she loved Amy calling her that.

“Good girl.” Skylar panted, and her mouth found Amy’s neck eagerly. She was going to leave so many hickeys on this girl’s neck. To mark her as Skylar Wayne’s property. Skylar did her work on Amy’s neck, but didn’t want to stop there.

Skylar left a trail down Amy’s neck, sucking and biting as she went. Skylar sucked hard along Amy’s collarbone and then down to the feast that was Amy’s huge fat tits. Amy’s moans became frenzied as Skylar sucked and bit at her sensitive tits. Amy’s hips were writhing and each time Skylar’s teeth grazed along Amy’s tits, the busty ginger’s breath hitched.

“That’s my girl.” Skylar moaned, her mouth full of Amy’s tit, so she didn’t even know if Amy had her, but when Skylar next bit down, Amy shrieked and began to writhe wildly, and Skylar’s fingers told the truth of what was happening.

Amy was orgasming, and it was a big one.

Skylar enjoyed the feeling of Amy’s body shaking in pleasure, and then when Amy finished riding it out, Skylar caught the girl by the hips so she didn’t fall, and only then did Skylar take her mouth off Amy’s delicious boobs.

“Shhh, I’ve got you.” Skylar murmured to Amy, and cupped Amy’s face tenderly, though it was with the hand covered in Amy’s pussy juices. Amy didn’t seem to notice, though, and she just leaned her head into Skylar’s hand.

Skylar held Amy’s soft voluptuous body tightly in her arms, giving Amy time to recover a bit, as she was definitely on unsteady legs right now.

Skylar gave Amy plenty of kisses while she was recovering, kissing all over Amy’s face and cheeks and lips and nose. Skylar even made a little game of trying to kiss each one of Amy’s countless adorable freckles. She was maybe a quarter of the way through when Amy seemed to regain function. Skylar did have that effect on women.

“We’re going to be so late for class.” Amy mumbled.

“And?” Skylar raised an eyebrow. Amy flushed, and Skylar couldn’t resist kissing her.

Skylar took her hand off Amy’s cheek and lifted it up to the top of Amy’s head, and Amy looked up at Skylar in confusion as Skylar guided the redhead to her knees.

“What are you doing?” Amy asked confusedly.

“Don’t question me.” Skylar ordered, and Amy nodded. Skylar raised an eyebrow.

“Well?” Skylar demanded.

“What?” Amy asked, confused.

“Say it.” Skylar ordered, and Amy blushed as understanding filled her green eyes.

“Yes ma’am.” Amy whispered, and the words sent a hot thrill of delight through Skylar.

“Good girl.” Skylar approved, and then she spread her legs a little wilder so Amy had easy access.

“Have you ever eaten a girl out, Amy?” Skylar asked.

“No! I have no idea how to do that.” Amy protested.

“No better time to learn, then.” Skylar smirked, and she gestured to her eagerly waiting pussy.

Amy looked uncertain, but she leaned in and lightly kissed Skylar’s pussy. When Amy drew back, her lips were coated with Skylar’s juices, and Amy at first didn’t look happy with that, until she actually tasted it, and then she actually looked eager for more.

“Oh, that’s not all you’re doing.” Skylar laughed.

Skylar put a hand on the back of the ginger’s head, smirking down at her. Amy’s wide innocent green eyes met Skylar’s horny and hungry green eyes.

Amy gasped as Skylar stepped forwards and pushed her pussy against Amy’s mouth.

“Eat me out.” Skylar encouraged, and Amy gave it her best.

———

Brooklyn Robinson gasped as Evan Simmons’ strong hands kneaded her ass. He was meant to just be washing her, but he was spending an awfully long time on her ass… something Brooklyn couldn’t deny she was enjoying.

She loved when guys touched her ass, even if very few ever had, and a good number of them were accidental brushes. This kind of in-depth groping of her ass was entirely new to her, and it felt incredible. Her hands were pressed flat against the shower wall, a slight bend to her body, thrusting her ass out for the tall and muscled linebacker to grope.

Brooklyn couldn’t believe she was doing this. She’d always been the good girl, the kind who would never get involved in something like this, especially not with someone like Evan! She’d heard far too many stories about him being a player, and completely tossing aside girls.

She couldn’t believe she was doing this with someone like him. But she was enjoying herself, and, well, Dana had been telling her for years she needed to enjoy herself more.

Brooklyn yelped as Evan gave her fat ass a savage spank, and she threw him a dirty look that was maybe a little pouty. Ok, the look wasn’t very dirty at all. It was a mix of pouty and horny, but she didn’t like admitting that to herself.

There was nothing wrong with what she was doing, she kept telling herself, this was just something that only wild girls did. And, well, girls like Skylar Wayne always seemed to be having a great time.

And the last time Brooklyn had done something like this, she’d really enjoyed herself then… even if it had been with her little brother. She’d been fully clothed then, thankfully. Right now, with Evan… she was definitely not.

She was naked in front of a boy, and he was very, very naked, too. His big veiny cock was on full display, and whenever Brooklyn saw it, she found herself biting her lip.

“Don’t like the spanks?” Evan chuckled after Brooklyn threw him the look.

“No.” Brooklyn lied. Evan’s eyes seemed to stare through her eyes, and he held her gaze as he spanked her again. She moaned, then cursed herself for it.

“Liar, liar.” Evan clicked his tongue, “Your panties would be on fire, you know, if you were wearing any.”

Brooklyn huffed at the joke, and she tried to stand up, but Evan’s hands went to her thick hips and started squeezing. Brooklyn’s lips quivered, and she clamped them tight to avoid any noise escaping.

“What are you doing?” Brooklyn managed to say in a steady voice after taking a moment to steady herself.

“Soaping you up. Your body has a lot of spots that need soaping up.” Evan told her.

“Are you saying I’m fat?” Brooklyn gasped. Evan’s eyes widened, and he leaped forwards to grab her tight from behind. His cock slipped between her cheeks and nestled there as he wrapped his arms tightly around her and leaned down to whisper into her ear.

“Absolutely not. You have one of the sexiest, curviest bodies I’ve seen in a long time. And fuck, do I love girls with huge fat asses like yours.” Evan growled in her ear. Brooklyn moaned, helpless to resist that this time. She felt too good right now, and his compliment didn’t help.

“You… you love my ass?” Brooklyn asked dumbly.

“So fucking much.” Evan growled, rubbing his cock against her plump butt eagerly. No, not rubbing. He was grinding on her ass.

Brooklyn looked back at Evan, and she was stunned at the fire boiling between her thick thighs.

His wet hand found her chin, and when he tipped her head back to kiss her on the lips, she let him.

Evan’s lips were hot on hers, and hard. Hot and hard. Much like something else of Evan’s that she also felt right now, rubbing along the valley between her fat cheeks.

Brooklyn whimpered into the kiss when Evan’s free hand found one of her very large tits and began to squeeze. Her whole body jerked suddenly, and that meant Evan’s cock moved abruptly from its’ first spot to now having the tip resting right against her asshole.

Brooklyn whined into Evan’s mouth, completely surprised by the unexpected poking at her hole. He hadn’t penetrated, but she could feel his tip pressing lightly to her dirtiest hole.

It was Evan who moved away from that position, surprisingly, though, and he returned his cock to its’ original spot.

“You’re not ready for that, Bubbles.” Evan smirked, and Brooklyn felt… disappointed, she realized. Disappointed. Oh, God, she was going crazy.

It took her a minute to even register the nickname, and then she looked back at him funny.

“Bubbles.” Evan explained, somehow already knowing what she wanted from him, “Because of this flawless bubble butt, and of course the soap I’m rubbing all over you.”

Brooklyn’s cheeks heated, and Evan smirked at her.

“You like your new name, Bubbles?” Evan asked her in a husky tone that made her shiver.

“It’s definitely a new one.” Brooklyn said weakly.

“Not what I asked.” Evan said simply, and Brooklyn flushed.

“Yes. I like it.” she confessed.

“Good. It’s a cute nickname for a sexy little thing like you.” Evan told her casually, and Brooklyn’s heart fluttered. Evan gave her ass another slap, and Brooklyn didn’t even try to hide the moan that came from her plump lips.

It was then that her watch started beeping, and she startled.

“Crap! That means I’m going to be late for my next class!” Brooklyn gasped.

“Seriously?” Evan asked incredulously.

“Yes! I’m not going to miss class!” Brooklyn exclaimed, and a still surprised Evan stepped out of the way so she could wash the bubbles off her bubble butt, and then she was moving for the exit and wrapping her towel back around her.

“One last thing.” Evan said, and she turned impatiently.

“What? I’m in a hurry.” Brooklyn complained. Evan stepped forwards and slipped his hands up the bottom of her towel and gave her ass a big two-handed squeeze. Brooklyn moaned, her toes curling. Evan leaned in and kissed the busty cheerleader one last time, then he gave her ass one last squeeze.

“See you around, Bubbles.” Evan told her with a grin as she opened the shower door, and the stupid heat between her thick thighs pulsed a little.

Brooklyn didn’t reply to Evan or even slow down, she just quickly hurried out and closed the shower door.

———

David and Dana were lost in admiring each other’s bodies. David’s eyes raked along Dana’s petite, flawless body. David’s eyes feasted on Dana’s large pert breasts, her flat stomach, her smooth skin, her slender curves, her bare pussy, and then back up to her gorgeous eyes.

Dana’s gorgeous eyes, though, were focused on David’s goliath of a cock. David was rock hard and Goliath was pointing directly at Dana’s thighs.

“I… I can’t believe it.” Dana breathed, breaking the silence between the pair of best friends.

“Believe what?” David wondered idly, trying to rip his eyes off Dana’s amazing boobs.

“How big you are!” Dana exclaimed in amazement. David looked at Dana, then, and his heart swelled with glee. So it wasn’t just Rachel and Danielle. Some small part of him had been afraid even despite their assurances. Afraid that Dana might find him a freak, but no, she seemed as exuberant as her mother.

“I’m just gifted.” David shrugged, unable to resist a grin on his face. After years of shame for his oversized cock, the time since Saturday had completely changed him. Now, he was proud of Goliath, and so damn happy about the benefits it was reaping.

“Yes, you are.” Dana blurted, and then her cheeks reddened slightly.

“Should we shower, then?” David asked a little awkwardly. He clearly had Dana’s attention but he didn’t know how to push further. Rachel had been the aggressor in that whole situation, and all David had had to do was hold on for the ride and enjoy it.

With Dana, like this, there was no aggressor. Just awkwardness and attraction. David especially didn’t know how to make a move on one of his two best friends. Idly he wondered about Brooklyn and Evan, but then Dana moved and her boobs jiggled and his brain forgot all about that.

“Yeah, yeah, let’s shower.” Dana nodded, and David and Dana moved as one to slip into the hot water, which meant they bumped up against each other, and Dana moaned as Goliath ran across her stomach. David moaned as his tiny best friend’s large bust pushed against his chest.

“Fuck.” David grunted, and Dana’s hands wrapped around Goliath. His eyes widened and his cock throbbed in her grip.

“Whoa, what…” David blinked. Dana quickly let go of his cock, looking embarrassed.

“Sorry, sorry!” she shook her head, wet blonde hair shaking.

“Don’t worry about it.” David murmured, and Dana looked up at him. David’s eyes met her fascinating blue-green eyes, the eyes he’d always loved, and without thinking he kissed her.

Rachel would be proud, David figured, as his lips met Dana’s and his hands found her slim hips. Dana arched her body up against him, and Goliath pressed up against her stomach as she wrapped her arms around his neck to hold herself there, pressed up against him.

Dana was standing on her toes, David’s hands on her hips, his cock sticking straight up, pinned between their stomachs. Everywhere David’s body touched her, especially around his behemoth cock, Dana felt fire. Hot, blistering fire that drove her mad.

Her hands clawed at the back of his neck like she couldn’t get herself close enough to him, and well, she couldn’t. She was glad she didn’t have long nails at the moment or she was half worried she’d claw up the back of his neck.

David and Dana’s kiss lasted a while, both best friends soaking in the feeling of each other’s bodies. They held each other, even did a little washing, though they only washed themselves, they didn’t get into the washing each other phase yet. They lost track of time, and showing up for their next class wasn’t anywhere in their brains. It wasn’t until they heard the door of the shower next to them open that they sprung apart, both of them thinking it was the door to their own shower at first.

David couldn’t help but laugh, and Dana’s soft body slid up against him as she moved suddenly, shoving him out of the way so she could see out into the hallway. David’s big cock slid between Dana’s perky cheeks like the hot dog in a comfy bun, and she looked over her shoulder at him with a heat in her oceanic eyes.

“Brooklyn just left. I should go with her.” Dana managed. David nodded.

“Yeah, yeah, of course.” David mumbled. Dana hesitated, looking like she wanted to say something, but instead she just grabbed her towel and hurried after her other best friend.

David sighed, and moved to stand beneath the water, thinking wistfully of Dana’s incredible body.

What's next?

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)