Phoebe first

After Piper had fallen asleep, the demon heard Phoebe come in and go to bed. After he was sure she was asleep, he paid her a visit and did the same spell on her as he did to Prue. "Phoebe, you trust Piper completely and will not notice anything unusual about the way she behaves or dresses. You can't stand Prue, however, as she thinks she's smarter, more mature, and better than you. If you are ever pranked, you know it's here behind it. Also you love having sex with men over fifty. You crave licking their balls and sucking their cocks. You will drop out of college and get a job somewhere were older men hang out, so you can seduce them. You love dressing as sexy as possible around them."

The demon made Phoebe wet her bed and made sure she'd blame Prue. He then got into bed with Piper and woke up the next morning with her mouth on his cock.