Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
Chapter 2
by
ManRayMansker
Which Prompt will you choose to address first?
Orgasms
This game had already gotten pretty wild, but the energy in the room shifted again when Mia leaned forward with that mischievous glint in her eyes.“Never have I ever had an orgasm.”A few people laughed and took drinks immediately. Jake downed half his beer in one go. Sarah blushed but sipped too. I just sat there, fingers tight around my still-full glass, face burning hotter by the second.
I hadn’t.
Not once.
Not with a partner, not by myself, not even close. I’d faked it plenty of times just to make things end faster, but the real thing had never happened. I always told myself I was just not that type or too stressed or whatever excuse worked that week.
Now the truth was sitting in my lap like a spotlight.Mia noticed right away. Of course she did. She never missed anything.
Her gaze zeroed in on me and her eyebrows rose. “Wait. You didn’t drink.”
The room quieted. All eyes turned my way.I shrugged, trying to play it cool even though my cheeks were on fire. “Nope. Never.”
A couple of people looked surprised. Sarah’s mouth actually fell open a little. Mia, however, looked delighted. She looked like she had just been handed the best gift of the night.
“Oh honey,” Mia said softly, her voice warm but dripping with challenge. She uncrossed her legs and stood up, moving toward me with that slow, confident stride. “You’ve been sitting here listening to all of us talk about our dirtiest stories and you’ve never even had one? That’s criminal.”
She stopped right in front of me, tilting her head.“Here’s what we’re going to do,” she continued, her tone leaving almost no room for argument. “Since you’ve never had one, you don’t have to drink. But if you want to stay in the game and keep playing with the grownups, you’re going to let me fix that. Tonight.”
Mia reached into the same black box from earlier and pulled out a sleek black toy. It was small, curved, with a smooth silicone finish and a quiet little motor I could already imagine. She held it up so everyone could see.
“You’re going to take this, go into my bedroom with me right now, and we’re not coming out until you’ve had your first one. I’ll guide you. I’ll teach you. And the rest of the group gets to wait out here and listen if they want.” She smiled wickedly. “Or we can do it right here on the couch if you’re feeling really brave. Your choice.”My heart was pounding so hard I could feel it in my throat. Part of me wanted to bolt. Another part, the curious, aching, secretly frustrated part, was already clenching at the thought.
Mia crouched down so we were eye level. Her voice dropped to an intimate whisper that still carried across the silent room.“You deserve to know what it feels like. No more faking. No more wondering. Just you finally letting go. So tell me…”She brushed a strand of hair behind my ear. The toy still dangled temptingly from her other hand.“Are you going to keep pretending it doesn’t matter, or are you finally going to let me make you come for the first time?”
The room waited.
Your move: Do you accept and go with Mia to the bedroom?
Do you agree but want it to happen in front of the group?
Do you try to negotiate or stall?
Or do you have a completely different reaction?
Your continuation. Take it wherever you want. The night is young and Mia is very patient. Until she isn’t.
What's next?
- No further chapters
- Add a new chapter
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)
A Compilation Tale of Never Have I Ever
Play the game contributions welcome
Each Chapter is begging for you to take the challenge
Updated on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
Created on Jun 27, 2026
by ManRayMansker
- 7 Likes
- 767 Views
- 3 Favorites
- 2 Bookmarks
- 26 Chapters
- 3 Chapters Deep
Comments moved below the chapter.
Comments