Noelle’s answer.

How long was I asleep for? Like 30 minutes, according to my phone. Glancing around the room, I saw that Grace and Sarah were still asleep beside me, but Mila was alone on the other bed. The door to the living room was half-open, letting me hear the conversation happening there.

“Are you sure?” Alice asked.

“Yes, it’s fine. You simply said the things I’d also been thinking about. You worded it better than I could’ve, too,” Noelle said. “And like I said, I had my answer already. I gave it some more thought and it hasn’t changed.”

Carefully, I got out of bed and stepped out of the bedroom, showing myself to the two naked girls sitting on the sofa. “Sorry. I woke up and didn’t want to eavesdrop on you.”

“We weren’t talking about anything you can’t hear,” Alice said, moving away from Noelle to give me space to sit between them. I did. “I was asking her if we made her uncomfortable with that talk about sharing you with others.”

“Ah. And…”

“You heard, right? I didn’t mind. We had to talk about it eventually,” Noelle said. “And the truth is… I’m okay with you being with other women. If anything, it bothers me that it doesn’t bother me.” Noelle took my hand and rested her head on my shoulder. “It should, right? I agree with Sarah that the word love gets thrown around a lot, but I really do love you. I want you to be mine, and… I know you are, just not exclusively, and that’s fine. I mean, I asked you myself to let me be your girlfriend, remember?”

Ah. Right, she had.

“I think I was bothered by it because… Because it wasn’t normal, because I thought it couldn’t work,” Noelle continued. “But now? We hang out all the time, we share tons of moments, and even in an orgy like this, you still outlast us all. I’d have to look for things to complain about.” She took a deep breath and placed a hand on her chest. “So yeah, I want you to be with other women. Both because it’s what you want and because… I think it’s hot,” she admitted shyly.

I let go of her hand, turned my upper body to face her and placed both of mine on her cheeks, kissing her forehead. “Thank you. Things may change a bit, but it’ll be for the better. I’ll make sure of it.”

Alice chuckled. “Coming from you, that doesn’t sound like an empty promise.”

She hugged me from behind, pushing her huge breasts on my back and nibbling my ear. “I’m looking forward to it. More women will get to taste this magic cock.”

Smirking, Noelle decided to play along with Alice. She pushed her tits against my chest, sandwiching me with Alice as she held my face and planted soft kisses all over it. “They’ll go crazy for you, I just know it.”

“I don’t know,” I said. “I have to ask them out first, and I’m still not the best at talking to strangers.”

“Ugh!” Alice groaned and spanked me in the butt. It took me completely by surprise and made me flinch. “Confidence, Oliver! Confidence! You’re spending the night with five girls who worship you from head to toe! If you want another woman, you can have her!”

Noelle laughed, then she began to lewdly lick my chest. “She’s right. You need to have more confidence in yourself.”

“So what? I go up to them and tell them I want to see their tits?”

“I wouldn’t go THAT far!” Noelle said, laughing even louder.

“I don’t know. I bet that would work,” Alice said, smirking. “At least, it’d be really hot if it did.”

I moved to sit well on the sofa to have access to both girls at the same time. I got an arm around their waists and pulled them closer, kissing Alice’s lips first. “You’re such a pervert…”

“Hmmm, yess…” she purred, licking my tongue. “Your own, nasty little pervert…”

“I want you both now,” I told them, moving my hands up to grope their tits.

“How?” Noelle asked breathily. “How may we serve you?”

I gave her lower lip a little nibble before we changed positions. I lay on my back on the sofa, Noelle straddled my face and Alice my hips.

Alice sank slowly on my cock, moaning softly. “Mmmm, my pussy is still sensitive. I might have trouble walking tomorrow.”

“I know, but…” Noelle’s back arched when she felt my tongue along her slit. “Oooh, just a bit more…!”

I had my hands on Noelle’s thighs as I slid my tongue inside her pussy, flicking it inside her and drinking her flowing juices. Meanwhile, Alice brought down her hips on me, driving my cock deep inside herself.

Noelle let out a soft chuckle. “I can almost understand Oliver’s obsession with boobs. Seeing these bounce is almost mesmerizing.” She reached out and grabbed one of Alice’s boobs.

The blonde stopped bouncing up and down, switching to rocking her hips back and forth to grind the tip of my dick against her cervix and to let Noelle grope her more easily.

“And seeing this face lewd face is also quite the turn on for me,” Alice said, cupping Noelle’s cheek.

The two girls leaned closer to each other and came together into a deep kiss. As they did, Alice continued grinding her hips on me and I kept on eating Noelle’s wet pussy.

Our combined moans and laughter must’ve woken the other three up, because they came out of the bedroom at the same time. Most notably, however, was the detail that Mila came out holding her phone and pointing it at us.

“We fall asleep for two minutes and you’re already going at it without us,” she said, grinning from ear to ear.

“Anyone want some water?” Grace offered.

“Me,” we all answered.

Sarah sat down to watch us while Mila kept recording us. Alice and Noelle kept making out on top of me and groping each other’s chests. Soon, Alice came on my cock and Noelle on my mouth. I drank all her juices like they were syrup while also letting out my own fluids inside Alice.

“Haaah… Haaah… No more,” Alice gasped heavily. “I can’t. I’m going to break…”

“Me too,” Noelle said, letting a mix between a groan and a sigh. “Any more and it might start to hurt…”

“Seems we’re all spent,” Grace said. “Congrats, love. You outlasted all five of us… again.”

Alice and Noelle had to ask Mila and Sarah for help getting off of me, or they risked stumbling and falling.

“I don’t think I can go again, but I can still use my mouth if you want,” Sarah offered, kneeling in front of me. Wordlessly, I leaned back on my seat, spread my legs a bit and let Sarah work her magic.

We spent the next two hours talking. Noelle told them she approved of me going for other women, but after that we talked about silly things, debated some odd topics and brainstormed ideas for the summer, like making a trip to the beach.

I’d call that a pretty decent first Valentine’s Day. Wouldn’t you?

Patreon.