Nicole

Sarah announces your small friend's name whilst dropping the piece of paper back in the hat, doing her best to avoid dripping any cum in there as she does. When she hears her name Nicole leans her head off you to sit up straight and her hand quietly slips away from your cock. "Nicole, since someone has made a mess of me I think I need some help cleaning up. Lick my hands clean." Sarah smirks as she says it, pushing her hands forward to display just how coated in sticky jizz they are. "Ew gross." Nicole grimaces like she just bit into a lemon. "It's not that bad!" Sarah laughs, before sticking her tongue out and scooping up a spoonful of Matt's cum and swallowing it with a sigh of contentment. Nicole still looks displeased but with Sarah putting her money (and Matt's cum) where her mouth is she knows she cant really argue.

"Hey, at least Sarah proved it's not poisonous." You reassure her as she gets up from the couch, making everyone else laugh. "For cum it actually tastes pretty alright." Sarah giggles. "I bet you drink plenty of water, maybe you could eat some more pineapple though." She continues, dissecting your friends cum like a semen sommelier. Matt looks so pleased from Sarah's praise that his dick might get hard again already, and if that's not enough then Nicole licking her fingers might finish the job. You know you're looking forward to the sight, even if you wouldn't say that to Nicole.

Sinking down to the ground beside Sarah Nicole frowns as she looks again at the meal set out for her. You don't know if Matt naturally came a lot or if this was just a result of his sexy crush milking him dry, but Sarah's hands are almost like a pair of glazed donuts. Opening and closing her mouth a couple of times Nicole tilts her head in confusion. "Where do I start?" She sighs in consternation, her eyes flicking from one coated finger to the next. "Here comes the airplane!" Sarah teases, swirling her pinky finger through the air towards Nicole's mouth. Nicole glares at her but dutifully parts her lips, allowing Sarah's finger between them. Wrapping her lips around it Nicole grimaces again as she sucks the salty goo off it and quickly swallows, doing her best to avoid tasting it too much.

With one finger down Nicole makes her way along through the others in much the same way, sucking, frowning, and then swallowing. When she gets to her thumb Sarah inserts it a little more slowly, taking care to teasingly smear it on Nicoles tongue. Your blonde haired friend looks confused by this but she still sucks and swallows without complaint, forcing down a little more of Matts cum.

Before she can get to the other hand Nicole takes a second to complain. “If this is what alright cum tastes like then I never want to taste bad cum.” She groans, screwing up her face and sticking out her tongue in disgust. “Trust me, it’s only gonna get worse if you let it get cold.” Sarah warns her, pushing her unlicked fingers towards Nicoles mouth. Sighing in frustration, Nicole returns to her finger licking. She even moves her head forward willingly, like she was trying to deepthroat Sarah's fingers, every time a sticky finger was brought to her lips. Soon all of Sarah's fingers are (relatively) clean, and poor innocent Nicole is in something of a daze.

While Nicole is still processing all the cum she’s already drank Sarah holds up the jizz covered backs of her hands. "I can’t exactly fit my hand in your mouth so you’re gonna have to use your head. Or your tongue." She tells her. Nicole doesn’t look happy about it but with a final sigh she holds Sarah's hand delicately by the wrist and leans forward with her tongue out. From the wrist up to the knuckles Nicole licks and swallows quickly, lapping at it with small tongue movements like a cat rather than taking long licks like a dog to collect more at once. Nicole's method might be less efficient but it probably felt less weird than lavishing Sarah's hands with slow strokes of her tongue, like an artists paintbrush against a pale white canvas.

How exactly she chose to employ her tongue didn’t matter to you, the sight was still entrancingly erotic. You watched with one hand wrapped around your cock as innocent Nicole gave slutty Sarah a sloppy manicure, thoroughly cleaning off Matt's cooling cum and leaving behind a sheen of her own spit. Despite Nicole's efforts to remain clean, demure, and ladylike, she was making a mess of herself too, her drool starting to spill down her chin as she kept licking and licking. With one hand done Nicole leans over to get the other one, catching herself mid way when she realizes that her mouth is hanging open with her tongue sticking out. Closing her mouth and taking a deep breath in alongside a quick shake of her head Nicole leans over again, doing her best to look and act more proper.

An act that falls apart when her mouth opens to lick up more cum, moving even more hurriedly as she realizes it’s starting to congeal. With much more vocal licking and swallowing, combined with occasional coughs of disgust, Nicole hurried through cleaning the back of Sarah's left hand. With the tender urgency of a lover Nicole flips Sarah's hand so the palm is facing her and begins to desperately caress it with her tongue. Sarah giggles at the spectacle and she’s not the only one, the rest of you snicker quietly at Nicole's cum eating desperation. When the final drops pass through her lips and down her throat she sits back on her heels and visibly relaxes.

"There, done." Nicole sighs. "Erm, Nicole I think you missed some." Sarah points to the cum on her chest as a joke. To her surprise (and everyone else's) Nicole mutters "crap" and throws herself at Sarah. Her tongue is on her chest, licking just above her tits before Sarah can even say anything. It’s only after she’s swallowed most of the cum that Nicole stops and looks up at Sarah wide eyed, her tongue still pressed against her smooth skin. "That wasn’t part of the dare, was it?" She asks, sheepishly retracting her tongue into her mouth. "Nope, but thank you though. I always appreciate a cute girl licking my tits." Nicole blushes deeply and pulls away, getting quickly to her feet. "She’s not the only one." Tom chimes in. "You appreciate a cute girl licking your tits?" Miranda asks him mockingly, but he just laughs it off.

You're still laughing at Miranda's joke as Nicole comes back to sit beside you, laughter that she interprets as being at her expense. "You think it's funny that I've got cum in my mouth John? How about you give me a big kiss." She teases, puckering her lips and making kissy sounds as she moves to sit back next to you. Now it's your turn to grimace, but as she draws closer you decide to do something she wouldn't expect. Calling her bluff you grab her chin with one hand, pulling her in to your lap and suddenly kissing her deeply. She's completely shocked and you feel her gasp into your mouth as your tongue brushes against hers. You do your best to ignore the strange taste of what she just ate still on her lips until you slowly break the kiss.

When you pull back her eyes are wide and her cheeks are blushing again. She clearly didn't see you calling her bluff coming, and by kissing her like that you had almost surprised yourself. You make silent eye contact with Nicole until she blinks a couple of times and suddenly looks away. "I... I mean- the- er the hat? Yes, the hat please Sarah." She stutters, turning around and taking the hat from the smirking Sarah, who is making her way to her own seat beside Matt. Sarah shoots you that same knowing look over Nicole's shoulder as she settles down beside Matt. Hat in hand Nicole sits down, stubbornly refusing to look at you. Despite not being able to look at you she sits so close that she's almost in your lap, the heat of her flushed body burning into your side. With her head down she stirs the slips, looking at no one as she draws a name.