Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 4 by Uber_B Uber_B

How do you return?

Naked.

You walk back into the room naked and all eyes follow you to your seat. You decide it would be weird to cover up and act shy now so you try to act natural. Despite your best efforts, you are too embarrassed so you escape into your mind. You leave your body on autopilot as you eat. You feel a hand creep up your thigh and press between your legs. You spread them to allow Jake access to your pussy. He wastes little time and two fingers slide into your surprisingly wet pussy. He curls his fingers in a come hither motion repeatedly. It doesn't take long for you to cum.

"Ahh my god!" You moan with your head down.

Having spoken and the silence that followed brought you back to where you are. You lift your head and say.

"uh, m-my god I sure can cook."

As you look from Trent, to David, to Mitch, and to... an empty chair.

"W-where's Jake?" You ask.

"Bathroom." Mitch says from the chair closest to you, on the side you currently have fingers exploring your womanhood.

You try to close your legs but this just holds his hand in place.

"Please, you have to-" You start.

"Have to what dear?" Jake says as he returns to his seat.

"Yeah. Have. To. What?" Mitch thrusts his fingers with each word.

"H-have to... Have... to... Um. Have to, more- eat. eat more." You say trying to not give away your predicament

He finger fucks you the rest of dinner. Afterwards Jake asks if they want to watch a movie. You try to signal a no to Jake but he just nods yes. You realise he is punishing you for disobeying answering the door, that must be it. You all pile into the living room and the lights are turned off. The only light is from the tv. Jake sits in his special recliner and the three guys sit on the couch. You stand around wondering what to do.

"Make room for Maria on the couch , guys." Jake says.

It's really dark right now so you can't see. You find the couch and feel around for a seat. You feel legs and a bit over you feel... A cock, already hard. You gasp quietly. You feel further and more legs. There's no room for you.

"There isn't any room." You say

"Just sit on someone's lap, babe." Jake says.

"But I'm..."

"Your gonna ruin the movie. Maybe if you would have answered the door this would have played out differently."

There's your confirmation. You are being punished for not playing the game right. You give up, but aren't willing to go so far as to allow a bare cock that close to you. You excuse yourself for a moment and go to get a condom. You get three just in case. You return to the couch and quietly hand them each a condom and whisper.

"No bare cock will touch me."

You wait a minute then go to sit on whoever is in the middle. You were too careless and ended up sitting on his cock. It shot right into you slamming against your cervix.

"HOOOOLY FFFFFFuuuck- eh hem, s-sorry." You say

You never felt this full before in your life. The only other person who has been inside you has been Jake and he does not begin to compare. He leans close and whispers.

"You didn't wait long enough."

"For what?" You whisper back.

He brings the condom into your view. You panic as the realization hits you. His bare cock is touching you. You officially cheated on Jake. There is no way he intended for this outcome. Then you suddenly hear snoring. Jake is asleep on his chair. He always falls asleep in the first five minutes of a movie. You want this to end, but... You stand up off his cock.

"What happens if we end this here and now and go no further?" You ask

"Um' our balls would turn blue and fall off. Ever heard of 'blue balls'?" He says

You have in fact heard the term, you never knew what it meant. You can't leave these guys to such a fate. You hand him the condom.

"Put it on and I will make sure that doesn't happen, as an apology for getting you into this situation." You say.

"You could just suck us off." One suggests.

"I do not want cocks in my mouth, I am not some, slut." You say proudly. "Is it on?"

He says it is and you go around the back of the couch and bend over it.

"I will be like this, just go ahead and relieve yourselves with my body." You say.

You watch the movie as the first guy takes his turn fucking your pussy from behind. Your breasts overhang the couch and the other two just keep sucking and licking your nipples. You just want to make sure you don't climax with a cock other than Jake's. You concentrate on the movie. He stops thrusting and presses deep inside you. His cock pulsating. You know he must be filling the condom. He pulls out and places the oddly heavy used condom on your back. He switches places with one of his brothers. This cock is the best- so far, smaller than the first but to the perfect size to fill you without pushing into you. You find yourself unable to ignore his cock like the previous one. Right when you are about to fail and cum, he stops. He fills his condom and leaves it on your back.

Last up presses into you and then starts pounding. The sound of your flesh and his slapping together fills the room.

"Oh my, g-god. W-what is t-this?" You moan

"This is what it's like to get fucked." He says all too loudly.

He keeps pounding into you.

"I'm g-gonna c-"

He stops. Your orgasm fades. He starts moving again.

"Oh god, I'm gonna-." You are getting frustrated "Urg, stop, stopping." You say.

"I thought this was just for us?"

"It... it is, I'm s-sorry."

Before he starts up again. Jake starts making noises. You freeze. You hear him get up.

"I'm gonna head to bed hun. Those guys leave already? I Can't see a thing." He asks.

You realise the movie had ended and the tv had been turned off.

"Y-yeah, just cleaning up before bed." You say.

"Goodnight, love you."

"Loooove- mmm- y-you t-too." You struggle to say as the cock in you started moving again.

Jake leaves and you let the guy fucking you know he can't keep making so much noise. He suggests it would be quieter on the couch. You agree and lay down on your stomach. You push your face into a pillow because you know you wont be able to hold back. He places his body weight onto you and slides his cock between your legs into your pussy. You notice he feels different. You lift your head.

"Is the condom still on?" You ask.

"I don't know why it wouldn't be." He says.

You put your face back into the pillow and assume it's just your new position. He begins, and begins rough. He pulls all the way out before slamming all the way in. You cum repeatedly and scream and moan into the pillow. After a few minutes he whispers into your ear.

"The condom fell off. Where should I cum? In your womb or your mouth."

You don't want cum in your mouth, but inside your womb would be too risky. You turn your head and just say.

"Don't stop, please."

You didn't need to tell him twice. Your whole body was bouncing into the couch with how rough he was fucking you. You cum and cum and cum. You feel him cumming and you moan to him.

"Keep fucking me until you c-can't."

"W-why would I do that?"

"It f-feels too good. PLEASE!" You beg.

He doesn't say anymore but he doesn't let up. His cum pumps inside of you but he keeps going. He cums again but keeps going. You swear they switched but you keep getting fucked so you don't care anymore. Over and over. Then after an hour when they switch, you roll onto your back. You pull whoever is about to fuck you into a kiss. Your brain is trying to tell you to stop but all you hear in your mind is 'FUCK ME' over and over. You want this pleasure to never end. But alas, it does. You don't know when, but you wake up to the sun hitting you in the face. You sit up and cum drips from your body. The couch is soaked. You hear Jake waking for the day...

What happens?

  • No further chapters
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)