Mistaken Identity

Nicole turned on the lights in the janitorial closet, and Dan quite quickly realised he was not having sex with his girlfriend. Bent over in front of him was Leonie. She was not someone who Dan knew that well but had they shared a few classes and they chatted every so often. Leonie was a fairly petite blonde, only about five foot four. Dan thought she was on the girls' soccer team but might have been mistaken. The one asset Leonie was really well known for was having D-cup-sized breasts, she bloomed quite early in that regard and got a lot of attention from boys.

Leonie looked over her shoulder in surprise at Dan. “You're not Ben.”

Nicole appeared behind Dan and peeked out from beside him and looked down at Leonie with an expression of amusement.

“The rumours are true. I heard a girl was sleeping with that cute teacher's aide.” Nicole commented.

“He was meant to meet me here. I thought he was Dan.” Leonie complained.

“And you didn't even wait to see if it was me.” Nicole playfully teased.

“You said to meet you here, and you were wet and wanting to fuck.” Dan replied.

Dan continued to fuck Leonie slowly while the conversation was happening. Dan noted she was moaning softly and trying to pretend like she was not enjoying it, a mock protest because she was fucking the wrong person.

“Ben's not coming. I saw him running off to deal with some crisis. But we are, and you are fucking my boyfriend, Leonie.” Nicole said menacingly.

“It was a mistake. I thought he was Ben. We were going to meet up here and fuck.” Leonie tried to explain.

Nicole started stroking Dan's arm.

“I think you should punish her, baby,” Nicole suggested.

“I can leave if you guys want some privacy.” Leonie pleaded.

“Girl, you have my boyfriend's cock buried in your cootch, and you want to just leave?” Nicole taunted.

Nicole stepped around from beside Dan and moved so she was standing in front of Leonie. She smiled at Leonie sweetly, any hint of menace had been dropped. “I'm joking. I watch Dan hook up with other girls all the time. If you want to fuck him, Leonie, I don't mind.”

“You guys are a really weird couple,” Leonie replied.

Dan got the impression that Leonie did not want him to stop. He started going faster, pulling out until he was only just inside of her and then fully back inside of her. Leonie started pushing back on him, meeting his thrusts. Dan watched Nicole lift her skirt in front of Leonie and pull her panties down.

“Lick me.” Nicole requested.

“I've never done that before,” Leonie told her.

“I don't care. My boyfriend's inside you, and I wanted to get fucked. I'll settle for a tongue on my clit.” Nicole advised her.

Nicole did not bother waiting for a reply and pressed her flower into Leonie's face. He watched as Leonie started very cautiously licking at Nicole's clit. He heard his girlfriend making soft moans. He shifted a little so he could drive into Leonie with a slightly different angle. He heard her moaning louder.

“You're really hitting my spot. Keep going like that I want to cum with you inside me.” Leonie moaned.

Dan watched as Nicole started grinding herself on Leonie's lips and tongue. He saw that Nicole had her eyes closed and was entirely lost in the pleasure that she was experiencing. Dan felt Leone's pussy convulse on him really hard as she came. She pushed him out for a moment and then slid back inside her as deep as he could go.

“Did she cum on your cock, babe?” Nicole asked

“She's really fucking wet,” Dan replied.

“How does he compare to Ben?” Nicole said, looking at Leonie.

“He's a lot bigger, and Ben would have come by now,” Leonie said reluctantly.

“You stopped licking,” Nicole told her.

Leonie resumed her attention to Nicole delicate parts. She seemed more eager now that she had experienced an orgasm herself. Leonie alternated between really slow licks and sucking on it. She changed how hard she was sucking in response to Nicole's moans. After a moment, Leonie got brave enough to push her tongue into Nicole. This made Nicole start grinding herself really hard on Leonie's face. The combined actions of both girls quickly brought Nicole over the edge, and she started climaxing. Throughout all of this, Dan had continued fucking Leonie, he went slightly slower while he was watching and enjoying the show. He could see that Nicole was dripping wet. Leonie lapped up her juices without being encouraged to do so.

“You know I did promise Dan one thing. Keep fucking her baby.” Nicole said

She moved and stepped back behind Dan and went into her bag. When she returned, Dan saw she was clutching a bottle of lubricant. Leonie looked back over her shoulder at Nicole and Dan with a look of concern on her face.

“He's a little big for that,” Leonie told them.

“I promised Dan anal. I never said it had to be with me.” Nicole replied.

She started pouring lube over Leonie's ass and rubbing it into her. Nicole pushed a finger inside of her and Leonie let out a quiet moan. Nicole eased her finger in and out quickly. She added a second finger to stretch Leonie further. She used her other hand to cover Dan's cock in lube as well.

“I've done it with Ben and kind of liked it,” Leonie told them.

Nicole didn't reply she just grabbed Dan's cock and pressed it against Leonie's ass. They both heard Nicole cry out a little when she was impaled on Dan's length in this way. Nicole reached under her to play with Leonie's clit. Dan pushed into her, making her take more than the head of his cock.

“He's too big,” Leonie called out.

“You're doing okay. Just take him a little deeper.” Nicole told her.

Dan eased a few more inches into her until he was half inside her. Nicole had been tighter but guessed that Leonie had not done it recently either. Dan slowly went in and out of her, he felt Leonie relax a little and increased the speed of his strokes. Dan went deeper until she was taking all of him. Nicole was rubbing her fingers in a circular motion over Leonie's clitoris. He started going faster and harder, making Leonie take every inch each time he went. Dan knew he was nearing an orgasm of his own, he kept going, his groans getting louder as he did.

“Please don't cum inside me,” Leonie begged.

Nicole reached down and pulled Dan's cock out of the blonde's ass and took the head into her mouth. She felt her boyfriend's cock kick in her mouth as he started to cum. Nicole locked her lips around it as Dan deposited a large hot load into her mouth. Nicole grabbed Leonie by the throat and brought their lips to together. She kissed the other girl forcefully, and Dan could tell Nicole was making Leonie taste his seed.

Leonie stood up and smoothed her skirt.

“This was weird but fun,” Leonie told them.

Dan and Nicole took a moment to smarten themselves up before they all exited the janitor's closet. As they did so, they ran into Manny outside. He said nothing but simply gave them a knowing grin and fist-bumped Dan. Leonie disappeared down the corridor, leaving Dan and Nicole alone.

“What class have you got next?” Nicole asked.

“Schaefer asked me if I could come by after drama,” Dan answered.

“I've got history with Christa,” Nicole replied.

“If you have Gwen in your class, she's sweeter than she appears,” Dan told her.

Nicole was confused at the mention of the name but kissed Dan before they parted ways to head to their separate classes.