Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 172 by Samus1001 Samus1001

What's next?

Midnight in the mansion

Caleb woke up needing to pee very badly. It took him a while to work his way through the tangle of the half dozen women in his massively oversized bed. He had spent the rest of the evening tending to some of the women that hadn't caught him at the orgy.

Kathy decreed that the harem would have to sleep in their own rooms so that the other women could get what they came for. He still hadn't serviced every woman that attended, but that was because some of them had paired off with others and spent the night with one of them instead.

He finished his business in the master bathroom when his stomach rumbled. He had burned a ton of calories and had only eaten a light dinner. He briefly wondered how much energy it took to produce his huge cum loads, and whether he should increase how much he ate.

Out of curiosity he poked his head into the bedrooms in the harem wing as he headed to the kitchen. Kathy, Chris, Lottie and Cora were in bed together. One of Cora's huge boobs had worked its way out of the tank top she wore.

Caleb licked his lips at the sight. He knew he could have her anytime he liked, but wanted her to come to him first. Only then would he claim and breed her. Knowing Kathy, it wouldn't take long. Three of the five largest sets of tits in the house were in that bed, and while he was tempted to join them, he was more hungry than horny.

In Angie's room he found her snuggled up with her mom, Megumi. Next to them lay his cousin Emily and his aunt Lori. Unlike in Kathy's room, these women were all naked, with a camera set up at the foot of the bed. He would have to take some time to watch some of the porn they were making. He resolved to tell Megumi she should quit her day job if she was going to be making porn. According to his mother, they didn't need the money, and Megumi was not happy with her job. If she was happy making porn, then that is what she should do.

The next room he checked was April and Melissa's. He grinned at the ropes and other restrains hanging on the wall on Melissa's side of the room. On Melissa's dresser lay a bunch of toys and other sexual implements, including a riding crop and a paddle. April's side of the room was quite spartan by comparison. Everything was neat and tidy. The stripper pole was a surprise, and he made a mental note to ask her about it.

When he looked to the bed he saw April's eyes staring back at him. She had Melissa cuddled up on one side of her and Bonnie on the other. She whispered, "Is anything wrong Caleb?"

He whispered back, "No, I got hungry and was just checking in on everyone as I headed to the kitchen. Go back to sleep. Sorry for bothering you."

She blew him a kiss as he quietly closed the door.

The next room down the hall was Sonia and Gabbie's. Their room was an interesting contrast. On Gabbie's side sat a sewing machine and a dress dummy. Gabbie made a lot of her own clothing since most of what she wore was vintage fifties styled. Her idea of the perfect life was to be a housewife and she modeled herself on that theme. In addition to her schoolwork, she cooked and cleaned and did everything else a housewife would be expected to do.

On Sonia's side of the room he found a bookcase filled with religious texts. Upon the walls and on her dresser were several religious icons from various different religions. The two surprising items were a huge dildo laying in front of a framed picture of him. He glanced down at her as she snuggled up with Gabbie. He was very glad Sonia had come into his life.

Lori's room was empty since they hadn't moved in yet. The next room after that was Katie's. She did not have a roommate, but that was because she usually slept with Chris and Kathy. Tonight he found Holly and Marilyn in bed with her. He wasn't surprised to find her room filled with exercise equipment. When he claimed Holly he would have her move in with Katie since they were both athletic. He was on the fence about Marilyn. She didn't really fit in with the younger women in his harem. If he decided to claim her, she would make a great roommate for Amelia, but his mom was already spending half her time there.

The next room was Hazel and Tina's. Technically they belonged in the family wing, but he insisted their room was over here. He loved his sister and wouldn't even dream of making her move. Every time they had sex, he got a naughty thrill out of it. Thanks to his normalities, no one questioned it, but to him it was ****. A taboo that before he found his watch, would have enraged people at the thought of him fucking his suster.

He almost laughed out loud at the sight of the bed. The girls from the poker game were all crammed into it. It seemed that they passed out from too much sex. There were sex toys spread all over the bed and upon the floor. He did guffaw at the dildo Hazel was sucking like a pacifier. He left the room quickly, before his hardening cock led him to waking the room.

Mary's room was next. She also didn't have a roommate. He would have to fix that, and soon. She looked lonely laying by herself. She shifted in bed and opened her eyes. "Caleb is that you?"

Shit. "Yeah, sorry for waking you. I was just on my way to the kitchen."

She sat up and rose from the bed saying, "I guess I'll join you, if you don't mind. I haven't been able to sleep. I haven't slept alone since before I got married. Kathy's bed was full or I would have been with her."

They walked out into the hall and Caleb said, "I'm sorry. Would you like it if we got you a roommate? Or you can always come to my bed if you like."

Mary sighed and said, "Thank you for the invitation, but Kathy wanted the harem to leave you alone to service our guests. I suppose Cora will move in with me after you claim her. At least until you claim Brandy too."

Caleb held Mary's hand as they walked. He poked his head into Amelia's room and found she wasn't there. He thought briefly that she might be in his mother's room. The thought of them having sex in her marital bed amused him.

He kept his face neutral though as he closed the door and said, "You don't want me to claim them, do you?"

Mary squeezed his hand and replied, "No, it's not that. I do want you to claim them. I really, truly do. They need a man like you in their lives. It's just that..."

Mary sighed, "They are my daughters, and thanks to Mark's illnesses, I missed out on a lot of things a mother should get to do with her daughters when they become adults. Mark could barely get hard anymore the summer before Cora went to college. And by then, Mark's loads were pathetically small. We didn't have any money to spare, so I didn't get to give them their first taste of cum. Did you know Kathy is the only one of my daughters I've had sex with? If it wasn't for you, I might not have even gotten that."

Caleb remained silent as Mary spoke, "A good mother is supposed to teach her daughters about sex. Only Cora got to watch Mark and I do it, and he could barely stay hard. That kinda thing damages a woman's confidence. I didn't feel sexy anymore, and I was working two jobs. And because of those things, I didn't get to teach my girls anything about sex."

"Cora and Brandy went off to college without my imparting that knowledge to them. Part of me is sort of glad that I didn't. Mark didn't love me, he just used me. Making love with you is so much better. Maybe that is the difference. When I'm with you, we make love, we don't just fuck. All of the women in the harem feel that way. You give us exactly what we need. Melissa want's rough sex, April likes being dominant, Hazel and Tina like feeling used. We all like sex differently but you give us what we each want every single time."

Caleb was sure that was his normalities doing more than it was him. He made it so that they came hard and often whenever he had sex with them. Most of the time he just did whatever they wanted since he knew he would enjoy it anyway. He also made himself a naturally gifted pussy licker, which would explain part of it.

Mary stopped and pulled Caleb to her, wrapping her arms around him and pressing her tits against his torso as she lay her head on his chest. "I want you to claim my girls. I know you will love us all. I know you would never cheat on them like Mark cheated on me. And I want you to make love with them, and the four of us share you together and with the rest of your harem. I love you Caleb. You've made me happier than I ever thought I could be."

Caleb held Mary in his arms, touched by the emotional tone of her sincerity. He sucked in a breath and bit back a snort, wondering what she considered cheating. He literally fucked any woman he wanted. But as he held her he realized, it was the love they shared that meant the most to her.

He titled her head up and kissed her slowly, lovingly. When he pulled away he whispered, "I love you too. I am going to claim your other daughters, and you four will be part of this family forever. But they have to come to me. I am not going to claim them unless I know they want it too."

Mary smiled, "That's all I ask. Love us Caleb. Love us, breed us, and keep us happy."

Caleb's stomach rumbled again, causing them both to laugh. The intimate moment was broken, so Caleb tugged her by the hand further down the hall.

He poked his head into Heather's room and found she was also not there. The scratching posts, cat trees and cat perches still felt weird to him. He guessed that she might be wandering the house. If he remembered correctly, cats were nocturnal and wondered if that applied to cat girls too.

Heather's room was the last one in the harem wing. When he stepped into the main portion of the house he looked outside at the pool and found a few of their guests were taking a moonlight swim in the nude. One of the maids was out there in her alternate uniform and he assumed Chloe had assigned her to keep an eye on their guests.

He cut through the entertainment room and surprised Elena Garcia and her wife watching a video on the big screen TV of his aunt and cousin having sex. They seemed to be copying whatever Lori and Emily did in the video.

Caleb bit back a laugh and said, "Don't mind us. We're just passing through."

Both women were blushing at having been caught, but they really shouldn't be embarrassed and he told them so. "Ladies, you are guests in my home. You are more than welcome to make love to each other wherever and however you like. Just don't stay up too late Mrs. Garcia, you have school in the morning."

Mary was still giggling when they entered the kitchen. It was here they found the missing women. June and Heather were drinking Amanda's milk straight from her breasts. Amanda was making soft 'moo' noises as she shuddered in orgasm. Amelia smiled at Caleb and said, "I guess we weren't the only ones that were hungry."


Writing takes energy and coffee provides energy. If you like the story please consider buying me a cup of coffee at https://ko-fi.com/samus1001

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)