Make her reveal herself

Checking the living room, you didn’t see her in the same spot you had when you first entered the house and instead of wandering around to find her, you decided to get her to go where you wanted instead.

Level 1 details
…
Active -
Underwear Thief
Condition(s): Be within 20 metres of the User.
Effect(s): When activated, the subject will stop what they are doing, before finding the User’s underwear and attempt to steal them for themselves. Subject will prioritise used underwear when available and if caught in the process of stealing, cooldown will not reset.
Cooldown: 12 hours

With Lucy’s effects being used recently, you were quick to realise that you could use another one of her lower-level effects to your advantage in this moment.

Activating ‘Underwear Thief’

You listened for any noise while you were at the bottom of the stairs but you didn’t hear any movement. After picking up your bag, you quietly made your way up the stairs and towards your room, expecting to wait inside for Lucy to turn up.

What you didn’t expect, was that she was already in there, getting caught while she had opened the top drawer of your dresser where you kept your underwear.

“...” A moment of silence passed between you and Lucy made no move to explain what she was doing.

“Speechless twice in one day huh” you joked, getting an eye roll from her before she finally closed the drawer in front of her without taking anything from inside.

“I bet you set me up with Mom earlier” Lucy mumbled, taking a seat on the edge of your bed and letting herself fall back so she could lie down.

“Nope, that was all her” you replied, sitting down at the side of her before you continued to give an explanation.

“I had told her earlier that she could be a role model for getting everyone to be more open if she was willing to try it. She’s still our mom and she does have a lot of sway in this house… I just didn’t think she would take it so literally when I told her that” you said, knowing that your reaction to Mom’s words earlier had been as genuine as Lucy’s.

“Well it doesn’t exactly work if you tell one of the other two people about the plan” Lucy replied, nudging you in the side.

“I think it will. That’s the point of us all being honest right? Just because you know Mom might be pushing you to be more open, doesn’t mean it won’t work. And like she could ever keep up a lie for longer than a day. I mean you saw how nervous she was before I was open about us all being more intimate” you shot back, knowing that Mom was pretty bad at keeping secrets.

“I guess that’s true… It does ruin my plans to embarrass her though” Lucy said with a pout, a hint of sincerity poking through her comment even though she meant it as a joke.

“I’m sure you will still get your chances with that. If she does try to push herself to be more open, it’s only gonna give you more opportunities in return. Just don’t go too far and ruin the progress I’ve been making. If you can do that, I’ll not ask about you stealing my underwear… I’ve forgotten where we ended up on the whole underwear thing” you commented, trying to park Lucy back up before your thoughts turned back to some of your older plans.

Everything before the weekend now felt like ages ago with the amount of progress you had made and you were sure this feeling was only going to get stronger as more time passed and your life changed accordingly.

“Deal. And… yeah neither can I. You wanna just start from scratch on that?“ Lucy asked, sounding like she had forgotten like you had.

You still roughly knew the previous deals had been in your favour and you were sure Lucy remembered them being unfair to her as well. Instead of getting rid of everything though, you still wanted to keep things interesting and if you could somehow have Lucy’s effect still give you an advantage in an otherwise even sounding deal, you wanted to take that option.

“How about we just say we can each go and get each other’s underwear whenever we please, and as long as we put them in a washing bin when we are done then there’s no harm right?” you suggested, waiting to see what Lucy’s reaction would be before you added anything else.

“...That’s fine with me. Just don’t mess up my drawer if you go routing around” Lucy said in agreement, not having a reason to doubt you.

“But… What if we still did something similar to what we did before, just to keep things interesting on top of that?” you added, getting Lucy to actually turn and look at you.

“You already have something in mind so you might as well come out with it” Lucy replied, already knowing you had some agenda before you even spoke.

“Oh come on, it's not that bad. Just that if either of us actually see the other take some underwear, we then get to boss them around for a bit before helping them out. That way you still get to cum but it makes the sneaking around part a bit more interesting. And it makes finding the other person have some actual reward” you explained, hoping that Lucy would agree with this as well.

You doubted you would be going off to find Lucy’s underwear any time soon as you were already struggling to find time alone and even if you were alone, you doubted you would spend it masturbating given that you had at least six people willing to help you out.

Instead, it would be Lucy who would be getting caught more often and especially when you could use her KDK to place her at the scene of the crime exactly when you wanted.

“So I’d get to boss you around if I ever found you looking for some of my panties?” she asked, wanting to clarify.

“Yep, and I’d get to do the same if I caught you” you said, telling her it would work both ways.

For the first time, she sat back upright on your bed and faced you, crossing her legs and looking straight at you.

“So there’s no other catch or anything like that? Just an even deal that you are suggesting?” Lucy asked, trying to gauge your reaction to see if you had something else up your sleeve.

You tried to keep a straight face but you couldn’t tell if Lucy was seeing something on your expression while you waited. Even as she looked, your thoughts did turn to start thinking about what ways you could turn this to be even more in your favour, wondering if there was anything small enough that you could add while also getting Lucy to agree to it.

Author's note: Spoiler chapter will be updated shortly :)