Let the games begin

"Heh... You really think that loser can outlast Daddy?" Emma laughed, before stuffing her mouth with Nolan's shaft. "Gluurk gluurkk Gluuahh~ No offence Liam."

"Some taken."

"Uughhh... We're not out to humiliate him." Nolan groaned as he explained. Emma's head still dutifully bobbing up and down his cock. "I've been holding myself back for most of today. You can probably feel how full my balls are right now?"

Emma's hands started fondling Nolan's balls. With his cock still down her throat, she grunted in agreement.

"Heh. Yeah. Next to that, there's you." Nolan pulled her up by her hair. Drool covering her braces as she blushed and smiled at him. "Nobody knows how to take care of their daddy like you do."

"Ahem." Sarah coughed. Sharp eyes staring daggers at Emma.

"Except for my darling Sarah, of course." He quickly recovered, flashing her a confident smile.

Sarah pouted and looked away, but I didn't get what the big deal was? Obviously Nolan was talking about a different kind of care than Sarah was used to giving her father.

"Point is, my cock's been aching to feel your tight little holes." Nolan's voice rumbled in a low growl. "Just two rounds inside you will be over in a flash."

"But two rounds isn't enough for me Daddy~" Emma stared up at Nolan with wide puppydog eyes.

"Who said we'd be stopping there?" Nolan ran his large, rugged hands under Emma's crop top. Her lips trembling as he teased her nipples. "We'll have all night together to play, after Liam passes his challenge and finally takes my sweet Sarah to bed."

"Wait..." Emma pushed Nolan hand away from her chest, her eyes darting between me and Sarah. "You guy's haven't fucked yet?"

"Kind of."

"No."

Sarah and I spoke at the same time, sharing a quick awkward glance. Sarah was right that we technically hadn't had sex yet, but I think last night's fun still counted for something.

"We've fooled around a little... but we haven't gone all the way yet..." I admitted.

"That's what tonight is about." Sarah said. "Liam's going to prove he has what it takes to satisfy me!"

Is that how Nolan had explained this to her? I had been napping when he told her about the challenge, so I didn't know how he had phrased things, but he had assured me he wouldn't bring up anything related to my proposal. I guess he had just explained things in their simplest terms. That he wanted to make sure I could... satisfy his daughter...

The more I thought about it, the stranger it felt. I knew he was doing it for the right reasons, but my instincts were still telling me it was wrong. But I had to keep ignoring that feeling, to push past what I thought was normal.

For Sarah.

Slowly walking forward. I followed, thinking we were walking over to the couch, but instead she approached her father. Kneeling down beside Emma whose small soft hands gently stroked Nolan's throbbing cock.

"Well come on you dumb slut." Emma teased Sarah. Slapping her father's cock on her face, rubbing it against her glossy lips while looking at her. "And don't hold back just because your loser boyfriends virginity is on the line."

She was starting to really annoy me now. For one thing, it wasn't just mine, but both our virginities on the line. And I really didn't like the way she casually insulted Sarah like it was a joke.

But maybe her bratty attitude would be a good thing? If I was annoyed and agitated, surely I would be able to last longer?

"One more thing." Sarah said. Leaving the room for a moment she came back quickly. Wearing a pair of blue nitrile gloves, holding a chain of condoms in one hand, and a fleshlight in the other.

"There's no touching between us until you pass." Sarah told me. "But that won't be a problem, right Liam?"

At first, I was disappointed I wouldn't get to feel Sarah's bare hand against my cock again, or the feeling of her mouth enveloping me, but then I understood. Sarah was rigging the game in my favour. With gloves on, a condom over me and only a plastic toy to get me off, there was zero chance I could lose here. Not when Nolan had an actual nymphomaniac fawning over him. Practically worshiping his cock.

"Absolutly." I said with a smile.

"You could put five condoms on and you'd still squirt that load before Daddy cums." Emma taunted.

Okay, what the hell was her problem with me? I was motivated to win enough already, but now I needed to rub it in her face.

"Sit down Liam." Sarah told me. Ignoring her friend. "And take your pants off. Please."

"Uh, yeah. Sure thing." This was feeling almost clinical. Which was a good thing. It seemed paradoxical, but Sarah showing less interest in this, in me, right now, was her trying to help me win.

This couldn't be sexy at all. Not until Nolan came twice and I could prove to everyone, Emma especially, that I was just as much a man as he was.

"Oh, we've started already?" Emma said. "Go on Liam, let's see that tiny little pink dic-"

With a ferocious suddenness, Nolan wrapped his hand around Emma's throat. **** her hard enough to make her white cheeks go red. It scared me for a moment, but from the lust crazed eyes Emma had, it was obvious that she was into it.

"Don't worry Liam." Nolan smiled. Running his hand down his chest to her tube top. Yanking it down and exposing her soft, small boobs. Groping them with as much **** as he was using on her neck.

"I'll shut this bratty little minx up. You just focus on my daughter." Nolan flashed an innocent smile at me, while slapping the tit he had just been groping hard enough to make the sound echo throughout the room.

"You're already fully hard?" Sarah asked. Noticing that my eyes were looking towards her friends tits instead of her.

"B-because I'm so excited for this..." I told her. Probably not sounding very convincing, although it was the truth.

She had pulled down my pants and ripped a condom open. slipping it over my throbbing shaft. The condoms was a little loose on me, but it did the trick.

Beside us, Nolan had flipped Emma over and was fucking her face while she lay upside down. The wet gagging noises of her gagging on his cock rang heavily in my ears, making my cock twitch involuntarily. But I tried to tune that out. It was just me, and Sarah right now.

"Oh gosh darn..." Sarah held the fleshlight by my hard cock. Looking back and forth between it and her father. "I forgot to get any lube."

"Bring it here. This slut makes plenty for the both of us."

Nolan reached out to take the fleshlight while I watched on, confused by what he meant. But I understood soon enough as he pulled his cock out of Emma's throat, and poured her excess drool and spit into the toy.

"Ahh... guuahhh...." Emma caught her breath. Eyes rolling back in pleasure, until she turned to look at Sarah with an impish glare.

"Dadddys cock tastes better than ever. Shame you're stuck over there with, that thing."

"Mmmmm...." Sarah mumbled with a frustrated look on her face. I could tell she was just as annoyed at Emma as I was right now, but clearly didn't want to say anything bad about her friend.

"Almost done." Nolan said. Taking the dripping fleshlight and forcing his cock into it. Groaning deeply as his cock stretched out the tight plastic hole. "Mhmmm... there. That should get its insides nice and covered now."

"Well give it back and hurrying up and cover my insides Daddy~" Emma moaned.

"Women are so insatiable." Nolan rolled his eyes. Passing the toy back to Sarah. "I'm sure you'll see what I mean soon Liam."

"Uh. Yeah... can't wait..." I really didn't know what to say to that, and I was still shocked from seeing him just shove his dick into my toy. It didn't feel like the sort of thing you just, shared... but, I was wearing a condom. So I guess it wasn't a problem?

"Are you ready Sarah?" I asked. She was looking down, staring deeply at the entrance of the fleshlight. Running her fingers over its now slightly bigger entry hole. She must have been just as confused by him using it as I was.

"Y-yeah... I'm ready." Sarah gulped. Glancing back at her father who was lining his uncovered cock up to her friends dripping wet pussy.

"Just hang on." She told me. "This will all be over soon..."