Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 36 by Syreno Syreno

What does Tiffany decide to do now?

Let's make the most out of this.

Tiffany paces behind Stacey and Jocelyn as they talk wondering what to do now with Stacey. She’s sad that she didn’t get a brand-new pussy to play with. Tiff looks at Stacey longingly admiring her natural beauty. She ogles her pantsless figure and takes in her delicate curves. Stacey’s ass is impeccable. It’s very soft and peachy and it bumps out a bit because of her adopted posture. Tiffany’s cock stiffens liking what she sees. She knows what she must do now.

“Stacey, I think I should make the most of this,” says Tiffany as she gropes Stacey’s rump.

“Huh? Ahh!” Stacey yelps.

“I’m gonna pump your ass full of cum! This is great actually. I haven’t done anal before,” states Tiffany.

“Oh! Okay!” Stacey perks up. “But if you’re gonna do me we’ll need lube. I’ve got some in my bag. Jocelyn, could you please get it for me?”

“Sure,” says Jocelyn.

“Why do you have lube with you?” Asks Tiffany.

“Well…this isn’t my first time spontaneously hooking up,” answers Stacey her cheeks becoming even pinker.

“Dammit, I was so hoping you were a virgin,” remarks Tiffany.

“I’m sorry Tiffany. I’ll find some way to make it up to you,” says Stacey.

Jocelyn returns and squirts some lube onto her hands. She grabs Tiffany’s hard cock and thoroughly applies the lube. Stacey bends forward putting her hands on her knees and Tiffany spreads her cheeks. Tiffany positions her cock onto Stacey’s lovely anal ring, and then pushes herself in.

Stacey’s asshole spreads wider and wider as it swallows Tiffany’s dick. Stacey quivers and she moans as Tiff buries herself to the hilt. Tiffany grips Stacey’s hips and starts thrusting into her ass. Tiff is taken aback by this new but in some ways familiar sensation. The smooth friction of pumping into Stacey’s ass feels very nice. She slows her motion drinking in the heat of Stacey’s bowels. Stacey starts to clench her butthole. It grips tight to Tiffany’s cock as she retracts and then goes back in. The cling of Stacey’s ring and the spasming of her bowels sends surges of pleasure through Tiffany.

Tiffany reaches forward and hugs Stacey into standing straight. Tiff struggles a bit to continue the pace of her pumping. She sneaks under Stacey’s bra and insistently massages her nonexistent chest.

“Oh Tiffany! That feels so good!” Moans Stacey still maintaining her femininity.

“Yeah? You like me squeezing your itty-bitty titties?” Teases Tiffany right in Stacey’s ear. “You’re so cute! You the cutest girl I’ve ever stuck my dick in!”

“Yes! It’s so good!” Stacey cries. “Tiffany I’m so happy to hear that. I’m so happy to be your new girl!”

“You’re the kind of girl who loves taking it in the ass, aren’t you Stacey!” Tiffany says.

“I am! I love it so much!” Stacey shouts.

Tiffany leans forward bending Stacey with her and then she grabs hold of Stacey’s thighs. She lifts Stacey up carrying her by her legs. Stacey whimpers as Tiffany continues to trust up into her ass. Tiffany pumps and grunts. She realizes she might not have the strength to keep fucking Stacey standing up, so she backs up and sits on the bench behind her.

As soon as she sits Tiffany gets back into actively bouncing Stacey on her dick. Tiffany lets go of Stacey’s legs and goes back to rubbing her chest. Stacey lets her legs flop to the sides. She lets her entire body go limp to fully absorb every single one of Tiffany’s thrusts. Tiff moans as Stacey’s bowels squeeze around her cock.

Looking past Stacey’s shoulder Tiffany stares at their reflection in the big mirror on the opposite side of the room. Stacey looks absolutely deranged. Tears collect on her eyelids. Her eyes roll back to their edges. Her tongue hangs out of her mouth. With each bounce Stacey’s tongue and her own dick flop around. Tiffany also notices that Jocelyn has been recording them with her phone.

“I gotta send this to Sarah,” says Jocelyn typing on her phone. “’Check out Tiffany and her new super cute girlfriend.’”

“Oh God yes! I’m so happy to be one of your girlfriends Tiffany!” Exclaims Stacey. “I wanna be your adorable little whore!”

“You’re such pretty cock-hungry babe, and you’re all mine!” Proclaims Tiffany.

Stacey’s own cock is now rock hard and flails wildly as she bounces on Tiff. They can both feel the pressure building. The smacking of their flesh echoes through the room. Tiffany thrusts harder and faster. Stacey works her ass sucking at her mistress’ cock. Tiffany’s dick swells with ecstasy and she reaches her limit. She cums into Stacey completely flooding her bowels with her futa jizz. Stacey cums as well shooting her jizz straight into the air and landing on the floor. Tiff lifts Stacey off her lap and the cutie falls on the floor. She’s a panting sniffling mess with futa cum oozing from her asshole. Tiffany lays her head back also panting and pretty worn out all things considering.

“That wasn’t half bad a workout,” says Tiffany going to stand beside Jocelyn.

“That was a pretty good show for your first time,” says Jocelyn putting away her phone. “Also, did you already know you could take control of guys?”

“No, I didn’t know I could do that! It wasn’t something I even thought about testing before” Tiffany says astounded. Stacey sits herself up.

“That was amazing Tiffany! I’m so happy you chose me to make into a fucktoy. I’m the luckiest girl in the world,” Stacey says rosy and radiant.

“Gotta admit. I’m glad I took you even though you aren’t a real girl,” says Tiffany.

“Wait, I’m not a girl?” Stacey says suddenly confused.

“Huh? No? Uuuhh, I guess if you…wait…how do you identify as again,” Tiffany requests also confused.

“I-I’m a girl,” says Stacey, but then she looks down.

“But I only have a penis though. Shouldn’t I at least have a pussy?” She continues now looking a bit concerned.

“I guess you changed her somewhere during the dirty talk?” Speculates Jocelyn.

“Dammit, I didn’t want to mess her up!” Tiffany says cursing her carelessness.

“Alright Stacey listen up,” Tiffany orders. “Don’t tell anyone about what happened here. Act like you usually do in public but be ready to obey any order I give you. Youu…Um…Uuh…In truth you are a very sweet and cute girl and it’s okay that you have a penis.”

“Okay, I understand,” says Stacey. She still hasn’t quite returned to her previous cheery state.

“Hmm, not sure that worked as intended,” Jocelyn comments.

“Aargh! I’m so bad at this! How about you fix this Jocelyn!” Says Tiffany agitated.

“Hey yeah! I can definitely help you out here. Just leave it to me. I know how to make sure she’s a happy healthy femboy,” Jocelyn says.

“Really? Good! Thanks Joce. I’m counting on you,” says Tiffany. “Okay Stacey, you do whatever Jocelyn tells you to do and believe. She’s in charge of you now.”

“Okay, I got it,” agrees Stacey.

“Good, I’ll leave you both to it now,” says Tiffany cleaning herself up.

“You’re leaving already?” Jocelyn asks.

“Yeah, I got some things I should be doing. And I’m kinda tired,” Tiffany says gathering her things.

“I’ll talk to you tomorrow to see how it went. Okay see you later!” Tiffany leaves.

“Later,” Jocelyn says back. Then she turns to Stacey. “Alright Stacey we got our work cut out for us so let’s get to it! We’ll fix your identity issues and then make you that new training routine. But first, get down on your hands and knees and stick that cute butt in my face!”

What happens next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)