Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 42 by Ggoopp

Punishment time

Kyle’s story

Kyle went home that day and spent a lot of time thinking about what Stella had told him. He quickly went into his room and pulled his pants down to jerk off. He thought a lot about how he lost his virginity and how fun it was. He also thought a lot about Barry and Anna fucking right next to him, and how they were having such a good time together that they barely paid attention to him. He stroked his long cock in bed, and he quickly became slick with pre-cum.

Suddenly, his bedroom door opened and his sister, McKenzie was walking in. He put the sheet over himself, since they usually they masturbated under the sheets, and he even though she had seen it plenty of times, it felt a little embarrassing for her to see his dick, especially when it was so hard. Despite this, he continued to jerk himself off, since they usually did that while in bed together anyway.

“What’s up, bro,” McKenzie said as she walked in to put her bag down. “Are you jerking off already? Usually we do that at night.”

“Yeah I just couldn’t help it today,” Kyle said.

“Really? What happened to you today?” McKenzie started getting undressed out of her school clothes. She took her blazer off and started unbuttoning her shirt.

“I had sex today,” Kyle said, which caused McKenzie to pause and go quiet. For a moment, the only sound in the room was of Kyle masturbating.

“What was it like?” McKenzie asked as she continued getting undressed again.

“It felt so good. It was like masturbating but even better. Her pussy was so warm and wet,” Kyle stroked his cock faster as he reminisced.

“Wow, that sounds awesome,” McKenzie took her shirt off and threw it in her laundry basket.

“Ugh, it wanna do it again,” Kyle moaned.

“I wonder what it feels like for a girl,” McKenzie unclipped her bra, and let it fall to the ground. Her skin was pretty tan and she had large, pink areolas. Her curly hair nearly covered her nipples, but it was just short enough so that Kyle could see it all.

“I bet it’s just as good or even better,” Kyle said excitedly. “The girl I was with got so horny she squirted! Just like you do at night when you get turned on.”

“You got her to do that?” McKenzie pulled her skirt to her ankles.

“Yeah, and she said my cock felt really good inside of her.”

“Really? It’s not even that big.”

“Yes it is!” Kyle sounded offended. “You just watch so much porn that you don’t know what real dicks look like.”

“Whatever,” McKenzie said as she pulled her panties down. Kyle wasn’t usually very attracted to her cunt since he saw it all the time, but his experience today had him thinking differently. Her pink, puffy pussy lips looked adorable and he couldn’t help but think about her spreading them apart with her fingers while she laid next to him in bed.

“Why don’t you believe me? Look!” Kyle pulled the blanket off and his shiny, hard cock stood straight up. It was about 6.5 inches, which was considered pretty impressive in the locker room even though he was shy and usually tried to hide it. Suddenly, both siblings realized they were staring directly at each other’s crotches.

“I guess it’s ok,” McKenzie said, clearly trying to get a reaction out of him.

“You wouldn’t even know. I bet you would cum immediately from a cock this big.”

“No way,” she scoffed and started putting new underwear on.

“W-wait!” Kyle said as she started to pull her panties up. “Just a second.”

“Why?” McKenzie asked.

Kyle just grunted in response as he stared at McKenzie’s naked body. His eyes darted back and forth from her tits to her cunt.

“Oh, come on!” McKenzie said frustratedly. “You’re so gross.”

“Oh fuck!” Kyle said and erupted all over the bed. His cum got on the sheets and a good bit landed on McKenzie’s side of the bed.

“Are you kidding me, bro?” McKenzie said.

“You cum in the bed every night,” Kyle complained. “Why can’t I do it once?”

“Because you’re a boy. I can’t cum into tissues,” McKenzie started getting dressed again, but Kyle noticed a faint wetness on her panties when she pulled them up.

“That’s so unfair. I have to deal with squirt-covered sheets every night.”

“Whatever, just change the sheets,” McKenzie left the room, leaving Kyle surrounded by his mess. She seemed mad, but Kyle was hoping she would forgive him later. He wasn’t trying to do anything mean to her, he just needed to cum.

Later that night

Comments

      Want to support CHYOA?
      Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)