Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 5 by JustThisOnce3 JustThisOnce3

Who lost the challenge?

Jordan Loses

Honestly when you said your punishment you didn't think the team would accept but Marcus busted out laughing and gave his approval. The group moves inside to a private room and prepare the room for Jordan's punishment.

"Alright boys, whoever doesn't want to be apart of this... get out now." Said Marcus as some of the team do leave while others stay to watch this humiliating punishment.

"Alright... Y'all can come in" Said Jordan through the door and you all enter to see Jordan has already started his punishment

Please log in to view the image

You can see the dildo Marcus brought for Jordan already doing it's magic as Jordan lets the piece slide in and out of his tight hole. He doesn't look at anyone and just focusing on completing his punishment but of course some of the guys start recording.

"Who would've thought Jordan can take it up the ass, HA" said Axel as he gets a close up of the action

Jordan remains unfazed as the guys get closer and attempt to mock him. Marcus then whispers into Jordan ears and then grabs your arm to pull you in front of Jordan.

"I suggest you hold on because I'm not sure what our quarterback here will do to you if you cum all over his face."

You watch as Jordan changes position and Marcus takes your hard cock out so that it's right in front of Jordan's face.

Please log in to view the image

Marcus begins to stroke your cock to the same pace as Jordan riding the dildo. Between Jordan's low moans and Marcus methodical stroking you fear you may not last long. It also doesn't help that Jordan looks like he's ready to devour your cock into his mouth in an instant.

Marcus begins to stroke faster as his other hand roams your body, feeling up your abs and playing with your nipples. Jordan started taking the entire dildo up his ass and his moans have become louder.

You notice that the other players have left and it was only the three of you in the room left... whatever happens next would stay between the three of you. You swear you feel Marcus bulge pressed against your back side and Jordan mouth inching closer to your dick.

That is till a sound breaks you from your trance and Marcus instantly lets go, much to your disappointment. Jordan slowly retracts from the dildo and turns around to show the both of you the aftermath. A small gaping hole that's screaming for more but you knew now wouldn't be the time.

"Sorry to leave you blue ball like this my friend but punishments over for good old Jordan. If only I still had my favor to cash in... whatever. Hey if you want to hang out with us again, call my number, till next time my friend."

With that, you head out of the room with a serious case of blue balls... but with a bunch of new opportunities.

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)