Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 18 by Cheesers123 Cheesers123

What is revealed?

John's little dick

Miranda moved her head down in a single, instant, motion. Time seemed to stop as the moment that Nicole had been waiting so long for finally came to pass. She was going to see John's dick, her best friend and first crush's dick. She'd dreamt about it for so long, pictured it in her mind's eye, and now she was going to see it in all it's glory. Maybe it would be tall and lean, like him, or maybe it would be strong and thick like his biceps, or maybe-

Nicole's thoughts crashed to a halt as John's dick was revealed. It wasn't thick, it wasn't tall, it didn't even look strong. John's dick stood out three, maybe three and a half inches from his body. Nicole was no expert on penises, but she knew that that wasn't a lot. Looking at it now, after how much she'd hyped it up in her head, she found herself completely lost for words.

She wasn't the only one who couldn't speak. An awkward silence descended on the room as everyone stared at John's dick. Tom smirked, Matt looked confused, and the playful smile slowly faded from Miranda's face. Awkwardly, Miranda released her bite on John's underwear, allowing it to snap back loudly against his thighs.

"So?" John asked, his voice an anxious whisper. "What do you think?"

The quiet stretched on after that. Tom looked like he wanted to say something mean, but a tensing of Miranda's forearm as she threateningly squeezed his dick put a stop to him. Nicole wanted to say something complimentary, but she couldn't find the words. Everything that popped into her head sounded either patronizing or too forward. She didn't want to out herself for having a crush on him just yet, but the interminable silence was becoming agonizing.

"I like it, John," Sarah called out.

Whipping her head around, Nicole expected to see the red haired girl smirking cruelly at John's embarrassment, but she actually seemed to be genuinely smiling. There was a warmth in her eyes as she reached out a hand towards John.

"Thanks Sarah," John said, a weak smile returning to his face.

"I like it too!" Nicole quickly added, unwilling to be left out. John's smile seemed to grow at that.

"Cheers, Nicole." John's wilting posture restored itself a little, his back straightening as he glanced nervously back to Miranda.

Anticipation for her opinion weighed wordlessly down upon her, and she took a second to think before she spoke. "Oh, yeah it's. . . cute," She said eventually. Tom snorted beside her but another flexing of her arm **** him back into silence. A blush appeared in John's cheeks, and his smile waivered, nut he still took her compliment in good spirits.

"Ah, thanks Miranda, should I grab the hat for you?"
"Yes please, and if you could grab a name for me too, that would be great. My hands are a little full here." Miranda shimmied her shoulders and presumably slid her hands along Matt and Tom's shafts, making both of them grunt or cough quietly.

If John noticed her stroking their dicks, he pretended not to. Instead, he just turned around and grabbed that hat just like she had asked, which gave Nicole another opportunity to look at the girl she was sitting on.

She still expected to see an insincere smirk on her bitchy rivals face, but instead her eyes were trained on John's dick as he moved. Every step he took from Miranda to the hat and back, Sarah watched intently, focused on his little cock, literally licking her lips at the sight. Nicole had hoped that John's small problem would have been a turn off for a slut like Sarah, but if anything, she seemed much more interested in him.

Only when Sarah caught Nicole looking at her did her expression change, a smug and knowing smirk appearing on her face. She shot Nicole a wink before turning to look at John again, biting her lip as he leant forward to place the hat on the table before Miranda.

Sighing in exasperation, Nicole turned away, completely confused by what had just happened. John's small dick had been a surprise, but she'd hoped that it would have finally gotten rid of the infamously slutty Sarah. Instead, she was practically drooling at the sight and Nicole had no idea what to do next. Whatever plan she would come up with, it would have to wait until after Miranda had given her dare.

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Here's the last of the Patreon chapters. Hope you like it, I'll probably have something different coming soon.

What does John draw for Miranda?

More fun
Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)