Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)

Chapter 22 by Thatguy88 Thatguy88

What do you do?

Hug her

You were extremely tempted, she was beautiful, and so much like Anna. But she was so **** and if you wanted to really repair the relationship you couldn't take advantage of her.

"Ky," you said turning your lips away from her keeping her in your arms, "I am so sorry I hurt you like this."

She leaned into your chest and sobbed, your shirt becoming wet with her tears and as she cried you did too.

A good while later you both sat on the floor against the bed, Kylie's head on your shoulder.

"I called her," said Kylie, "for her birthday, I saw the date and I just called. When I heard her voice."

"That's the only reason I keep her line active," you said, "I needed to hear her voice. "

"And now," said Kylie, "you've got, what's her name, Amy?"

"Just because I'm with Amy and I'm happy with her doesn't mean I've forgotten about Anna, or that I don't miss her."

"And what about me?" asked Kylie, "Anna always joked if you were in my grade you would have fallen for me instead. Do you ever miss me?"

"I do," you said, "I don't think I realized how much until I called."

Amy came running into the room and stopped in the doorway, "the two of you have been gone for so long, I got worried."

"We're ok," said Kylie getting to her feet, "sorry I stole him for so long."

You got to your feet and went to Amy.

"I don't mind sharing him," said Amy as she smiled at you.

You kissed her cheek and held her. Kylie smiled at you both, "I'm glad he found you," she said to Amy, "he's hopeless without a strong woman."

As you laid down that night you felt a lot better, Amy laid her head on your chest.

"You seem more relaxed," she said.

"I feel it," you said, "I'm glad Kylie and I are talking again."

"I thought I was going to find you balls deep in her," said Amy, "she's really pretty."

"I mean she looks a lot like Anna did," you said, "she did try to kiss me, but it didn't feel right."

"You're thinking with your big head," said Amy with a giggle, "they grow up so fast."

The next day you went about your chores with Nyx. You went to Nyx' house later to check on Kylie who you hadn't seen since the previous day.

"Ky," you said walking into the house, her bedroom door was open but she wasn't there.

As you turned she came out of the bathroom and dropped her towel as she saw you.

"Dave," she exclaimed, she reached to pick up the towel but as she stood up she made no effort to cover herself.

You couldn't help but stare for a moment, she was incredibly sexy, just like her sister. You finally averted your eyes turning away from her.

"I hadn't seen you," you said, "I wanted to give you the full tour."

You felt her hand on your shoulder and as you turned to face her you saw she hadn't made any effort to cover up, her tanned skin almost glowing out of the shower, her wet blonde hair draped over her large breasts.

She put a hand on your cheek, "I've wanted this for so long."

She kissed you, her tongue dancing with yours as she pushed you onto the bed. In a flash she was on top of you, your shirt came off and she hurriedly undid your pants.

"Was Amy serious about sharing you?" she asked as she grasped your cock.

"Very," you said sucking one of her hard nipples.

Your hand went between her legs to her sopping wet pussy and you pressed two fingers into her as she gasped, "oh."

You worked your fingers into her, there was no need to get her ready, she was already there so you fingered her fast brushing her g-spot just like Anna liked. She clung to your head with both hands, her tits in your face as she moaned.

"Oh fuck," she whimpered, "oh, oh."

Her body shook as she tried to work her pussy off of your fingers and you laid her on the bed discarding the rest of your clothes as you climbed on top of her. Your lips met as she slowly stroked you. You kissed her neck, groping her tits before moving down to suck on them as Kylie moaned letting you do as you liked. Lining yourself up with her pussy you slid in as Kylie's eyes went wide.

"Oh my god Ky," you groaned, "you feel fucking incredible."

"Shut up and fuck me dipshit," she whined.

You drove yourself into Kylie, your lips pressed to her, your hand holding one of her legs as she wrapped it around you. She brought her hips up to you fucking you back as you drove your cock into her. You could hear how wet she was with each thrust, she pulled away from your lips looking into you with her bright blue eyes. Her moans grew louder as you fucked her harder. You could feel her pussy spasm around you as she came.

"Holy fuck Ky," you groaned.

She kissed you hard climbing on top of you. Kylie worked her hips riding you furiously, she clung to your shoulders for support letting you watch her voluptuous form.

"You're such a dipshit," she moaned, "but you have a great cock."

You held her waist and started to thrust into her as she squealed. Kylie came hard again her nails raking the skin of your shoulders. She climbed off and you got back on top of her, you wanted to look her in the eyes as you came.

"We shouldn't be doing this," she moaned as you slid back into her.

"You want me to stop?"

"Fuck no, give it to me."

You did, you fucked her hard and fast, your hands holding her waist hard, her tits bouncing wildly as she clung to the bedsheets. There was no holding back, there was no stopping, you pounded Kylie in this borderline incestuous romp that could only be completely satisfied one way. You erupted inside her as she wrapped her arms around you a smile spreading across her face.

"We really shouldn't have done that," said Kylie as you collapsed next to her.

"I also need another shower now," she said.

"Ky," you started.

"Dave," she said putting a hand on your chest, "this was fun, but anything we may have had a chance at is long passed."

She kissed your cheek and sat up, "give me an hour for the tour, and bring the girls."

What's next?

Want to support CHYOA?
Disable your Ad Blocker! Thanks :)