He picks Annie

I would have loved to have picked all of them if I could.

But the reality was that my heart was still set on Annie. She was right, without her, this night wouldn't have been possible.

“Im sorry girls,” I said to the other four, “But I'm picking Annie.”

The blonde got off the bed, clapping as coming over to hug me. The others groaned or booed me as they got off the bed. It was hard to let four of them down but it was the nature of the contest. The rules made by then, not me.

“Alright back downstairs,” Katie said, “Let's put on a movie.”

“Yeah, alright, I need to change first,” Milly then added.

The girls all made their way out of the room, leaving me with Annie alone. The blonde smiled as she sat on my lap in the chair. My cock was still at full mast and I was hoping for the love of god that she wouldn't leave me hanging.

When they had all left, she spoke to me, “Sooo... had fun? Worth the trip?”

“Of course but... I mean... I have so many questions...”

“Of course you do… go on…”

I asked her first about why they wanted to do this, what was this meant to prove. Annie explained briefly that it was something they had always argued about, who had their best affect on guys. Now that I was somewhat apart of their group, they trusted me to use me for this test. Annie admitted that their drinking tonight was another reason why they decided to text him to come over.

“But what about Tayla? I mean... what would Declan think if he found out his girlfriend was in her underwear, on top of me, kissing me... if he finds out, he'll kill me... he'll...”

“He'll never know,” Annie told me, “He's been a dick recently... they're on a temporary break again, they'll be back together but until then, Tayla's going to let loose, this happens regularly.”

“So they really do break up often?”

“All the time,” she confirmed, “She may be smart but she sure is dumb when it comes to picking partners, always the same types with no brain inside.”

It reminded me of Annie getting with Henry Foley at the party a few weeks ago, I wanted to bring it up and ask her why she would do the same thing and waste time getting with someone like him. I bit my lip though, not wanting to risk anything between me and her tonight.

She was still sitting on my lap, her legs very warm rubbing up against mine.

I wanted her to initiate the next move.

Was she going to reward me for picking her? Or was this all just a big tease with no grand finale.

“Well... I still picked you over her,” I carefully reminded Annie.

She looked closely at me and gave me that great smile again, a thing of beauty. But like what had happened outside at the party all those weeks ago, the mood was about to shift.

“That's sweet of you,” she said, kissing me on my forehead, “You're like my go-to-guy.”

That would have been okay if she stopped there but she didn't...

“I've never had a good male friend that I can have a bit of fun with like this and know you won't try and take advantage of me.”

Yep, locked away in the friend zone with her.

I started to regret my pick for the little teasing competition. Rose would have almost certainly given me something in return, Milly too!

I tried not to look disappointed in front of her, it was still an amazing night with what they had all done with me.

“Annie!” Milly's voice echoed from the door, “You guys coming downstairs? Board games and horror movies!”

“We'll be there,” Annie said, hopping off my lap, “Come on Leo, you head down, I'll meet you there in a second.”

It was a little bit of a disappointing finish to what was one hell of a show. I headed downstairs where the other girls were all changed into some more comfortable clothing, mostly sleepwear.

For the next hour or so, we played different board games while the girls had their last drinks of the night. When Milly and Rose began to argue over a game of Cluedo, everyone agreed it would be better just to put on a movie in the lounge room before bed.

As blankets and bowls of popcorn came out, I had to pinch myself. I was at a girls sleepover, not just any girls sleepover, the Saturday Night Five girls. There were countless amount of boys who would have wanted to be in my position right now.

In the large lounge room, I found myself on one of the couches by myself. The cheap horror film flick that Katie had picked turned out to be a fizzer. I didn't spend a single second watching it properly, my mind was just replaying the events of the night over and over again. I mean seriously... I can't believe I saw Katie's bare tits!?

The thoughts remained as I got tired, just like the others. Annie was first to fall asleep, on the recliner chair, her mouth wide open. Rose had another couch to herself where she dozed off not long after in a very uncomfortable looking position. Then it was myself who started to close my eyes. They kept flickering until they shut permanently.

I must have started dreaming not long after.

Annie was in my vision, wearing the same lingerie outfit she had on just earlier tonight. She was in front of me, stroking my cock which was now free from its confines.

Her hand was soft, she moved so slowly up and down my shaft, I begged her to hurry up, I wanted to cum. But she was just playing with me, not wanting me to finish yet.

Suddenly my eyes started to flicker again.

The feeling of my cock being played with hadn't disappeared yet.

Holy shit... someone was touching me down there, there was a hand inside my shorts, someone was grabbing my cock…